Gender differences in coping strategies and mental health outcomes among people living with chronic medical conditions

None
Living with a long-term medical condition such as hypertension or diabetes is rarely only a physical experience. The daily demands of monitoring symptoms, adhering to medication regimens, attending clinic appointments, and adjusting to lifestyle restrictions create a persistent psychological load that can accumulate over years of illness. The recent study conducted in the Central Region of Ghana among 457 patients receiving care at two public hospitals offers a window into how heavy that load can become. Using the Depression, Anxiety, and Stress Scale, known as DASS-21, the researchers documented a strikingly high burden of psychological distress across the sample. Stress reached the severe level for 187 participants, representing 40.9 percent, while anxiety at the extremely severe level affected 307 participants, or 67.2 percent of the sample. Depression was most frequently classified as extremely severe among 202 participants, equivalent to 44.2 percent, with a further 132 participants, or 28.9 percent, experiencing moderate depression.

These figures deserve careful reflection because they come from a group of people whose primary reason for visiting the hospital was the management of a chronic physical illness rather than a mental health concern. In many low- and middle-income countries, chronic disease clinics are structured around biomedical monitoring: blood pressure readings, blood glucose measurements, prescription refills, and brief consultations. Psychological suffering in such settings can remain invisible unless clinicians actively ask about it. The pattern observed in this study suggests that distress is not an occasional complication of chronic illness but a common companion to it. When more than two thirds of a sample reports extremely severe anxiety, the finding points to a systemic gap in care rather than an isolated clinical problem.

The study also examined how participants coped with illness-related challenges, drawing on the Africultural Coping Systems Inventory, a measure designed to capture coping strategies rooted in African cultural contexts. This choice of instrument is significant. Much of the coping literature has been developed in Western settings and tends to emphasize individual-oriented strategies such as problem-focused planning or cognitive reframing. The Africultural Coping Systems Inventory instead recognizes approaches that are commonly observed in African communities, including collective coping, in which family members, friends, and community networks share the burden of a problem, and cognitive-emotional debriefing, in which individuals work through their feelings by talking them out with others. Measuring these strategies acknowledges that coping is a culturally embedded behavior, not a universal script.

Gender differences emerged in both distress and coping. Female participants reported significantly higher depression, anxiety, and stress scores than male participants, and the effect sizes fell in the moderate-to-large range, indicating differences that are not merely statistical artifacts but meaningful disparities in lived experience. Male participants, by contrast, reported significantly greater use of collective coping and cognitive-emotional debriefing, although the effect sizes here were small. This asymmetry in magnitude is noteworthy. The gender gap in psychological distress was substantial, while the gender gap in coping strategies, though statistically reliable, was more modest. In other words, women in this sample were carrying considerably more emotional weight, and the coping differences detected did not appear large enough on their own to explain that burden fully.

Several lines of reasoning, supported by broader scientific understanding of chronic disease and mental health, help contextualize these findings. Hypertension and diabetes are both conditions that require sustained self-management, and the demands of that management interact with social and economic circumstances. Women in many households assume caregiving responsibilities not only for themselves but for children, partners, and older relatives, which can compress the time and energy available for managing their own health. Dietary recommendations, medication schedules, and clinic visits may be harder to follow when a person is also responsible for feeding a family or working in informal employment without sick leave. Economic vulnerability can also amplify the stress of a condition that requires regular medication, since interruptions in supply or affordability are common in resource-constrained health systems.

The finding of extremely severe anxiety in a majority of participants also invites attention to the biological and psychological interplay between chronic metabolic or cardiovascular disease and emotional states. Anxiety and stress activate physiological pathways that can affect blood pressure and glycemic control, creating a potential feedback loop in which poor mental health worsens the physical condition, which in turn deepens distress. Depression is similarly consequential: it is associated with reduced medication adherence, poorer dietary self-care, and less engagement with follow-up care, all of which can compromise long-term outcomes in hypertension and diabetes. Recognizing this bidirectional relationship strengthens the argument, made by the study’s authors, that routine mental health screening should be embedded within chronic disease clinics rather than treated as a separate service that patients must seek out on their own.

Screening, however, is only a first step. Identification of distress must be linked to accessible psychosocial support, and the study’s findings about coping strategies offer guidance on what such support should look like. Because men in the sample leaned on collective coping and cognitive-emotional debriefing, interventions that mobilize family and community structures may resonate more effectively than purely individual approaches. Support groups organized through existing chronic disease clinics, peer-led discussion sessions, and involvement of household members in counseling could build on strategies that patients already find natural. Culturally relevant care of this kind respects the social fabric through which many Ghanaians navigate illness, rather than importing models that assume an isolated, self-reliant patient.

The higher distress reported by women suggests that gender-sensitive care must go beyond identical treatment for all. It requires attention to the specific pressures women face, which may include economic dependence, caregiving overload, and, in some contexts, limited autonomy in health decisions. Health workers could be trained to ask about these circumstances during routine visits, and referral pathways to counseling or social services could be established within the hospitals where patients already receive care. Task-shifting approaches, in which nurses or trained lay counselors deliver basic psychological interventions, have been explored in various low-resource settings and may offer a practical route to expanding mental health support without requiring large numbers of specialist psychiatrists or psychologists.

The study’s methodology also merits consideration when interpreting its results. As a cross-sectional investigation, it captured a single moment in time for each participant, which means it can document associations between gender, coping, and distress but cannot establish causal direction. It remains possible, for example, that higher distress shapes how people cope rather than the reverse, or that both are influenced by unmeasured factors such as disease duration, severity, income, or social support quality. The reliance on self-report measures introduces the possibility of response bias, and the recruitment of patients from two public hospitals in one region means the findings may not generalize to people managing chronic conditions in private care, in rural communities distant from hospitals, or in other countries. DASS-21 is a screening tool that categorizes symptom severity but is not itself a diagnostic instrument, so the reported percentages reflect symptom burden rather than clinical diagnoses of depressive or anxiety disorders.

Even with these caveats, the scale of the distress documented is difficult to dismiss. The analytic approach, using descriptive statistics and independent t-tests conducted in Jamovi statistical software, was straightforward and transparent, and the moderation of claims about coping differences through small effect sizes reflects a careful reading of the data. The open access publication of the work, carried in Discover Social Science and Health, makes the evidence available to practitioners, policymakers, and researchers in Ghana and beyond, which is particularly valuable for a topic that has received limited attention in resource-constrained settings.

For clinicians, the most immediate implication is the value of asking. A brief, validated screening question about mood or worry during a routine hypertension or diabetes visit costs little and can uncover suffering that patients may not volunteer. For health system planners, the findings argue for integrating mental health services into chronic disease care, a model sometimes described as collaborative or integrated care, so that psychological support becomes a routine component of managing conditions that patients will live with for decades. For communities and families, the findings highlight the role that collective coping already plays and the potential to strengthen it deliberately.

For researchers, the study opens several avenues. Longitudinal designs could clarify how coping strategies and distress influence each other over the course of chronic illness, and how clinical outcomes such as blood pressure control or glycemic stability relate to mental health over time. Qualitative work could illuminate what severe anxiety feels like for a patient managing diabetes in a context of medication shortages, or how women experience the competing demands of illness and family responsibility. Intervention studies could test whether culturally grounded psychosocial support reduces distress and improves self-management.

Ultimately, the study underscores that chronic medical conditions and mental health are inseparable dimensions of the same human experience. The 457 patients who shared their experiences in two hospitals in Ghana’s Central Region reveal a population carrying a heavy and unevenly distributed psychological burden. Women bear more of the distress; men, on average, draw somewhat more on collective and debriefing strategies. Neither pattern can be addressed by biomedical care alone. A health response that treats the blood pressure reading and the glucose value as the whole story will miss the anxiety, depression, and stress documented here. A response that includes routine screening, gender-sensitive support, and culturally relevant psychosocial care would align chronic disease treatment with the full reality of patients’ lives.

The authors’ conclusion, that mental health screening and gender-sensitive, culturally relevant psychosocial support should be considered within chronic disease clinics, is a practical and evidence-based recommendation. Its implementation would require training, resources, and coordination, but the alternative is a system in which the majority of patients with chronic illness experience extreme anxiety without anyone asking about it. This study provides the local evidence needed to begin changing that.

Subject of Research: Gender differences in coping strategies and mental health outcomes among people living with chronic medical conditions

Article Title: Gender differences in coping strategies and mental health outcomes among people living with chronic medical conditions

Article References: Ninnoni, J. P. K., Commey, I. T., Harmah, E. B., Amoadu, M., & Opoku-Danso, R. (2026). Gender differences in coping strategies and mental health outcomes among people living with chronic medical conditions. Discover Social Science and Health. https://doi.org/10.1007/s44155-026-00479-3

Image Credits: AI Generated

DOI: 10.1007/s44155-026-00479-3

Keywords: Gender, differences, coping, strategies, mental, health, outcomes, people, living, chronic, medical, conditions