In the rapidly evolving landscape of industrial sustainability, the denim treatment facilities (DTFs) in Brazil have emerged as a critical focal point for innovation and environmental responsibility. A recent comprehensive study delved into the intricate dynamics of sustainability-oriented innovation (SOI) within these facilities, uncovering a complex interplay of internal and external factors that either propel or impede progress. Despite the evident potential to embed sustainable practices in the core operations of Brazilian DTFs, the research revealed persistent barriers that pose formidable challenges, restricting widespread adoption and undermining transformative ambitions.
At the heart of these barriers are internal constraints such as a pronounced deficit in technical knowledge and prohibitive implementation costs. These are not mere operational hiccups but fundamental obstacles that require strategic intervention. The lack of expertise within the workforce limits the ability of DTFs to assimilate and apply advanced processes essential for sustainability. Meanwhile, the substantial financial burden associated with upgrading technology and redesigning workflows discourages investment in green innovations. This dual internal pressure is compounded by external factors, including a general lack of consumer awareness and insufficient governmental support, which together create an environment less conducive to proactive sustainable efforts.
Contrary to global trends where consumer demand increasingly drives sustainability initiatives, the local market environment in Pernambuco, Brazil, portrays a contrasting picture. Here, consumer and societal pressures to favor environmentally responsible products are minimal at best. This absence of external demand weakens the motivation for DTFs to pursue SOI out of reputational or market-driven incentives. The study highlights how companies in the region tend to prioritize cost-saving measures and regulatory compliance over voluntary environmental stewardship, reflecting a transactional rather than a transformative approach to sustainability.
This regional context underscores a critical gap in public consciousness regarding the ecological impacts of textile production. Without heightened consumer advocacy and awareness, sustainability initiatives are more likely to be perceived as regulatory obligations rather than opportunities for innovation. The research points to a need for robust public awareness campaigns aimed at educating both consumers and businesses about the long-term benefits of sustainable production. Such efforts could catalyze a demand-driven push for SOI, transforming it from niche compliance into mainstream industrial practice.
Technical limitations remain a significant hurdle for the diffusion of sustainable innovations in Brazilian DTFs. The study identified a pervasive scarcity of modern technological tools alongside inadequate employee training programs in sustainability practices. These shortcomings severely restrict the capacity of these facilities to effectively implement and maintain sustainability-oriented innovations. Bridging these knowledge and resource gaps is critical for fostering a workforce capable of navigating and optimizing new sustainable technologies, thereby embedding them into the organizational fabric of the industry.
One of the most notable methodological advances from this research was the application of the Nominal Group Technique (NGT), which synthesized the perspectives of experts with the lived experiences of local managers. This dual-pronged approach yielded nuanced insights into the practical realities confronting Brazilian DTFs, highlighting the contextual dependencies that shape SOI adoption. Such a methodological framework demonstrates the value of integrating diverse stakeholder inputs to develop decision-making models that reflect both theoretical rigor and field applicability.
The theoretical contributions of the study emphasize the critical role of context in formulating and implementing sustainability strategies. It challenges one-size-fits-all models by illustrating how local socio-economic, cultural, and technological factors distinctly influence the trajectory of innovation adoption in industrial settings. Furthermore, the careful categorization of drivers and barriers into internal and external domains provides a clearer pathway for targeted interventions, allowing policymakers and industry leaders to allocate resources more effectively.
From a policy perspective, the research suggests the necessity of moving beyond punitive environmental regulations toward a more supportive regime that offers technical assistance and financial incentives. This holistic policy approach would enable small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) within the DTF sector to overcome entry barriers to sustainability-oriented innovations. Access to cutting-edge technologies and enhanced training initiatives would empower these enterprises to adopt eco-efficient processes, thus aligning local industrial practices with broader Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), particularly SDG 9 focusing on industry, innovation, and infrastructure, and SDG 12 emphasizing responsible consumption and production.
Although the research findings are rooted in the specific context of Brazilian denim treatment facilities, the implications extend more broadly to the global textile and apparel industry. The distinct challenges and drivers outlined highlight universal themes in the sustainability discourse — notably, the persistent struggle to balance economic viability with environmental responsibility amid varying degrees of stakeholder demand and resource availability. As such, these insights offer valuable lessons for similar industrial sectors aiming to integrate sustainability into their innovation agendas.
The study also brings to light significant sociocultural dimensions that influence sustainability implementation. The reluctance of many DTFs in the region to fully engage with environmental innovation is partly attributable to cultural factors and historical practices around effluent management, which continue to limit transparency and openness to change. Overcoming these deep-seated cultural barriers will likely require concerted efforts to shift mindsets alongside technological modernization.
The research methodology itself stands as a model for future explorations of complex industrial sustainability challenges. By combining qualitative and participatory techniques with empirical data gathering from industry practitioners, the study navigates the often abstract nature of SOI in a grounded, pragmatic manner. This combined methodological rigor and local sensibility invites replication in other contexts, potentially enhancing the global knowledge base on sustainability transitions in manufacturing sectors.
Furthermore, the study’s contribution to managerial practice lies in its development of a decision-making model tailored to the nuanced realities of Brazilian DTFs. This model equips industry leaders and policymakers with a framework for prioritizing actions that address the most pressing barriers while leveraging existing drivers. Such strategic guidance could accelerate the diffusion of sustainability innovations by aligning operational goals with regulatory environments and market conditions.
Despite its comprehensive approach, the study acknowledges limitations inherent in its scope, notably the limited number of managers interviewed and the exclusive focus on DTFs, which constrains the generalizability of findings across the broader apparel industry. These limitations invite future research endeavors to broaden empirical coverage and compare insights across different segments of the textile value chain. Such expanded inquiry would deepen understanding of sectoral dynamics and the varying efficacy of sustainability interventions.
The findings call for a renewed collaborative ethos, urging coordinated efforts among industry, government, and civil society to foster an ecosystem conducive to sustainable transformation. By addressing the specific technological, financial, and educational deficits identified, stakeholders can unlock the latent potential within Brazil’s DTF sector. Such collective mobilization is vital for aligning local manufacturing practices with global sustainability imperatives, thus supporting both environmental preservation and long-term industrial competitiveness.
In conclusion, the study presents a robust and deeply contextualized examination of the drivers and barriers shaping sustainability-oriented innovations in Brazilian denim treatment facilities. It reveals an industrial landscape poised at a crossroads, where technical and societal challenges intersect with emerging opportunities for systemic change. Bridging knowledge gaps, enhancing consumer awareness, and enacting supportive public policies are pivotal steps toward embedding sustainability into this vital segment of Brazil’s industrial fabric. As the world intensifies its focus on sustainable development, insights from this research emphasize the critical importance of localized strategies that are adaptable, inclusive, and grounded in firm empirical evidence.
—
Article Title:
Drivers and Barriers of Sustainability-Oriented Innovations in Brazilian Denim Treatment Facilities: An Expert-Driven Decision Support
Article References:
Brandão, S.C.G., Fontana, M.E., Silva, W.D.O. et al. Drivers and barriers of sustainability-oriented innovations in Brazilian denim treatment facilities: an expert-driven decision support.
Humanit Soc Sci Commun 12, 679 (2025). https://doi.org/10.1057/s41599-025-05006-4
Image Credits: AI Generated
