Deep beneath the expansive and tectonically stable Nullarbor Plain of southern Australia, massive ancient cave networks are slowly leaving their mark on the surface in the form of subtle, sediment-filled trenches. While geomorphologists have long recognized these kilometre-scale linear depressions, their origin remained elusive, often leading researchers to misinterpret them as remnants of ancient fluvial channels or tectonic faults. A new investigation, integrating morphometric analysis, electrical resistivity tomography, and passive seismic profiling, has finally clarified the true nature of these features. The study demonstrates that these elongated, low-relief depressions, which stretch up to 20 kilometres in length, are not the result of surface water flow, but are instead the surface manifestations of vertically propagated collapse from vast, deep-seated cave systems.
The Nullarbor Plain, an immense carbonate platform covering over 200,000 square kilometres, has been subaerially exposed for more than 14 million years. Because the region is tectonically stable and experiences minimal rainfall, surface karst features are generally weakly expressed, making it difficult to identify hidden voids. By applying electrical resistivity tomography (ERT), researchers mapped the subsurface beneath these enigmatic trenches. The results revealed low-resistivity zones in the upper 5 to 10 metres of the subsurface, directly corresponding to the sediment-filled trench floors. These zones are surrounded by higher-resistivity coherent limestone, confirming that the ground beneath these trenches is significantly less consolidated than the surrounding terrain, a telltale sign of subsurface void collapse.
Further verification of this subsurface architecture was obtained through passive seismic measurements. By analyzing ambient noise, the team identified reduced seismic velocities beneath the trench axes, consistent with zones of fractured or less dense material extending to depths of 30 to 70 metres and beyond. These geophysical anomalies align with known mapped cave passages and collapse dolines, providing a clear geomorphic link between the surface trenches and the deep underground trunk conduits that formed during the Oligocene and Early Miocene epochs. At sites like the Clay Dam Cave, where direct access to a collapse doline is possible, researchers observed sagging strata and sedimentary infill that precisely match the geometry and depth of the low-resistivity features imaged by ERT.
The study also highlights how these trenches serve as a chronological framework for the long-term evolution of cave-collapse systems. The researchers observed a systematic west-to-east transition in trench morphology, which corresponds to the thinning of the carbonate sequence from roughly 250 metres in the west to 110 metres in the east. In the western reaches of the plain, such as the Abrakurrie Trench, the surface expressions appear as discontinuous alignments of collapse dolines, suggesting a less advanced stage of upward propagation through thicker limestone. Toward the east, the trenches become more continuous and sediment-filled, indicating that the collapse has more effectively reached the surface through the thinner carbonate layers.
Importantly, the findings disprove the idea that these depressions are ancient riverbeds. The trenches lack integrated drainage networks, downstream sediment transport, or the characteristic branching patterns associated with fluvial systems. Instead, they terminate abruptly, confined to the karst landscape. While the trenches contain basal layers of fine-grained silt and clay, this material is likely a result of weathering of the local limestone and slow wash-in during rare intense rainfall events, rather than fluvial erosion. The lack of surface vertical displacement also rules out a purely tectonic origin, although the linear orientation of the trenches appears to follow the north-south structural control of regional faults.
This developmental sequence is not merely a relic of the distant past. Uranium-thorium dating of calcrete layers within the Clay Dam Cave revealed that while karstification rates are currently low, the processes of collapse, subsidence, and sediment infill remain active. Fresh rock collapses from ceilings and walls continue to feed these surface depressions, suggesting that the landscape is still responding to the slow, relentless removal of rock mass at depth. This persistence illustrates the decoupling between the subdued surface morphology and the dynamic, cavernous structure of the subsurface, where relict conduits from a wetter climatic period continue to exert structural influence.
Beyond the Nullarbor Plain, these findings provide critical diagnostic criteria for identifying hidden cave-collapse systems in other low-relief, arid environments on Earth. Often, such collapse features are overlooked due to their subtlety or the dominance of other landscape processes. By recognizing that shallow, linear depressions underlain by vertically extensive low-resistivity zones and aligned with subsurface voids are likely indicators of cave-collapse, researchers can now identify hidden karst architecture even where surface morphology is ambiguous. This framework bridges the gap between subsurface speleogenesis and surface geomorphology, greatly expanding the number of landscapes where cave systems can be identified and mapped.
The implications of this study reach even further, offering a valuable terrestrial analogue for planetary science. On planets like Mars and moons like Titan, linear troughs and depressions are often interpreted based on surface runoff or volcanic activity. However, if such features are associated with subsurface void development, they might also represent the expression of deep-seated cave systems. The study demonstrates that even in environments where climatic signals are weak and surface processes are slow, the signature of deep collapse can persist, creating a long-term geomorphic record. By integrating topographic data, geological history, and available geophysical constraints, the criteria developed here will help scientists prioritize candidate cave-bearing regions in the search for protected subsurface environments that may be relevant for astrobiological investigation.
To understand the deep roots of these surface expressions, the researchers examined the distinct speleogenetic origins dividing caves across the platform into shallow and deep categories. Shallow cave systems are restricted to the upper Nullarbor Limestone, extending less than 30 metres below the ground and reaching lengths of up to 200 metres. These sub-horizontal passages frequently contain abundant dark brown calcite deposits alongside halite and gypsum, and their development aligns with mixing corrosion during Late Miocene to Pliocene sea-level highstands. In contrast, the deep caves, occurring mainly within 60 kilometres of the southern coastline, formed much earlier within the older Middle to Upper Eocene Wilson Bluff Limestone. These deep conduits developed as extensive trunk passages during periods of elevated effective recharge across the Oligocene to Early Miocene, when southward-flowing groundwater carved wide conduits toward the ancient shoreline. When the sea finally retreated during the Late Miocene to Early Pliocene, regional uplift lowered the water table, draining these deep conduits and removing the buoyant support of water, which triggered progressive roof collapse.
A prime example demonstrating how massive subsurface voids can exist beneath unbroken ground is Cocklebiddy Cave, situated approximately 250 kilometres west of the Abrakurrie Trench. Extending for roughly six kilometres along a north-northeast to south-southwest trajectory, this flooded conduit sits around 100 metres beneath the surface and features collapse domes and passages between 20 and 50 metres wide without generating a continuous surface trench. Direct cross-sectional evidence of this collapse mechanism appears where the southern projections of the Yangoonabie and Yalata trenches meet the coastal Bunda Cliffs along the Great Southern Scarp. High-resolution drone photogrammetry and field surveys revealed subsurface collapse structures exceeding 100 metres in width within the cliff faces. These exposures display distinct stratal sagging, vertical brecciation zones, collapse arches, and cave openings. Crucially, the ground surface immediately above these cliff-exposed collapse zones remains flat and subdued, preserved by intact limestone roof layers, secondary calcrete crusts, and aeolian sand blankets that effectively decouple surface topography from underlying structural collapse.
Detailed sedimentological and mineralogical analyses confirmed the depositional history within the five mapped depressions, comprising the Abrakurrie, Wombat, Koonalda, Yangoonabie, and Yalata trenches. Laser granulometry performed across trench profiles revealed that sediment grain sizes systematically decrease with depth, transitioning from a sand-dominated upper tier into deeper layers characterized by higher fractions of silt and clay. Powder X-ray diffraction and quantitative Rietveld phase analysis identified calcite, quartz, and clays including illite and kaolinite as primary constituents, accompanied by trace amounts of dolomite, feldspar, aragonite, halite, anatase, and gypsum. The trenches span between 100 and 500 metres in width and rarely exceed 9 metres in depth, meaning their surface breadths substantially exceed the maximum spans of known underground cave chambers. The researchers attribute this lateral broadening to secondary mechanical erosion and lateral dissolution operating along the margins of the sinking depressions as sediment slowly accumulated.
To image the subsurface architecture beneath the insulating arid ground, the research team conducted electrical resistivity surveys during October field campaigns following rain events that lowered ground contact resistance. Using a multielectrode Wenner array with electrode spacings between 2 and 5 metres, two-dimensional resistivity inversions consistently revealed a symmetrical, mechanically resistant limestone ledge several metres thick along the trench margins. Borehole correlations confirmed that this resistive boundary coincides with the contact between the upper Nullarbor Limestone and the underlying Wilson Bluff Limestone. Complementing the electrical profiles, three-component passive seismic measurements captured horizontal-to-vertical spectral ratios between 0.1 and 20 hertz, supported by shear-wave velocity calibrations of 340 to 350 metres per second determined from refraction dispersion curves at Abrakurrie Cave. These seismic measurements detected a depressed contact between the Wilson Bluff Limestone and deeper Cretaceous siliciclastics directly beneath the trench axis, confirming reduced seismic velocity and extensive rock fracturing along the vertical collapse column.
Subject of Research: Geomorphological investigation into the formation of shallow linear depressions on the Nullarbor Plain as indicators of subsurface cave collapse.
Article Title: Subdued surface expression of deep cave collapse
Article References: Lipar, M., Leopold, M., Webb, J. A., Ciglič, R., Tičar, J., Zorn, M., Stepišnik, U., Jelovčan, M., Barham, M., Dolenec, M., Miklavc, P., Popit, T., Šmuc, A., Zhao, J.-X., & Ferk, M. (2026). Subdued surface expression of deep cave collapse. Communications Earth & Environment, 7(1), Article 735. https://doi.org/10.1038/s43247-026-04016-7
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1038/s43247-026-04016-7
Keywords: karst landscapes, Nullarbor Plain, cave collapse, geomorphology, electrical resistivity tomography, passive seismic profiling, carbonate platforms, subsurface architecture, sedimentology, planetary science, arid environments, geophysical survey, Cenozoic limestone, structural geology, speleology, landscape evolution
Cite Scienmag News
Courtney Benton. (November 16, 2026). Subtle Surface Trenches Reveal Massive Ancient Cave Collapses Under Nullarbor Plain. Scienmag. https://scienmag.com/subtle-surface-trenches-reveal-massive-ancient-cave-collapses-under-nullarbor-plain/
Courtney Benton. "Subtle Surface Trenches Reveal Massive Ancient Cave Collapses Under Nullarbor Plain." Scienmag, 16 November 2026, https://scienmag.com/subtle-surface-trenches-reveal-massive-ancient-cave-collapses-under-nullarbor-plain/. Accessed 16 November 2026.
Courtney Benton. "Subtle Surface Trenches Reveal Massive Ancient Cave Collapses Under Nullarbor Plain." Scienmag. November 16, 2026. https://scienmag.com/subtle-surface-trenches-reveal-massive-ancient-cave-collapses-under-nullarbor-plain/








