Across five experiments evaluating an intervention on study strategies, learners achieved superior test scores when guessing answers before reading compared to reading factual statements, yet systematically failed to recognize these gains. The investigation, published in Educational Psychology Review by Steven C. Pan and colleagues, demonstrated that prequestioning produced large benefits across experiments, with effect sizes from Cohen’s d = 0.83 to 1.35. Despite these advantages on criterial tests, participants exhibited persistent metacognitive illusions, judging that reading statements would lead to better performance than guessing about unfamiliar material.
The researchers investigated learners’ metacognitive awareness of this prequestioning effect while testing supports designed to improve awareness across multiple cycles. In each experiment, participants completed up to two cycles involving prequestioning and reading factual statements, reading an expository text, and taking a criterial test. Throughout each cycle, learners provided metacognitive judgments, specifically predicting test performance beforehand and postdicting performance afterward. Prequestioning required learners to make guesses to questions about unfamiliar material before discovering correct answers in expository passages.
In Experiment 1, participants incorrectly predicted and postdicted superior performance from reading factual statements rather than prequestioning. They also preferred reading over prequestioning for future study. Experiment 2 tested whether performance feedback could eliminate this erroneous belief. Even after receiving feedback on their performance, learners continued to harbor the metacognitive illusion, demonstrating that direct task experience and outcome feedback alone did not prompt accurate recognition of prequestioning gains.
To determine how to make learning benefits visible, the team altered the criterial assessment format and instructional texts in subsequent trials. In Experiment 3, separating criterial test items by prior learning technique was associated with more accurate retrospective postdictions. Experiment 4 incorporated a refutation text countering common misconceptions regarding prequestioning. Adding this refutation text improved the accuracy of both predictions and postdictions, indicating that directly addressing misconceptions helped learners align their expectations with actual learning outcomes.
However, Experiment 5 highlighted boundary conditions for this intervention. When researchers provided a refutation text without accompanying performance feedback or separated test items, only predictive judgments improved, whereas postdiction accuracy did not. Despite these variations in judgment accuracy, student attitudes shifted across the series. Although reading statements was initially preferred for future study in Experiment 1, prequestioning was viewed more favorably in later experiments where external instructional supports were introduced.
Overall, the findings reveal a substantial underappreciation of prequestioning benefits among learners, emphasizing that direct experience and feedback do not automatically clarify learning advantages. The authors concluded that external measures are necessary to increase the visibility of these gains. Specifically, structuring assessments to separate items by learning technique, providing background information, and utilizing refutation texts that challenge misconceptions appear crucial for improving metacognitive awareness of the prequestioning effect.
Subject of Research: Metacognitive awareness and illusions regarding the prequestioning effect in learning
Article Title: Metacognitive Illusions About Prequestioning Are Attenuated with Refutation Texts and Test Design
Article References: Pan, S. C., Chua, T. J. E., Rivers, M. L., & Teo, N. W. E. (2026). Metacognitive Illusions About Prequestioning Are Attenuated with Refutation Texts and Test Design. Educational Psychology Review, 38(1), Article 140. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10648-026-10232-6
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1007/s10648-026-10232-6
Keywords: prequestioning, prequestioning effect, metacognitive illusions, metacognitive awareness, refutation texts, test design, criterial test, performance predictions, performance postdictions, performance feedback, expository text, factual statements, guessing, educational psychology, learning techniques, Cohen's d, misconceptions
Cite Scienmag News
Glenn Wilkins. (November 17, 2026). Refutation Texts and Test Design Help Learners Recognize Prequestioning Benefits. Scienmag. https://scienmag.com/refutation-texts-and-test-design-help-learners-recognize-prequestioning-benefits/
Glenn Wilkins. "Refutation Texts and Test Design Help Learners Recognize Prequestioning Benefits." Scienmag, 17 November 2026, https://scienmag.com/refutation-texts-and-test-design-help-learners-recognize-prequestioning-benefits/. Accessed 17 November 2026.
Glenn Wilkins. "Refutation Texts and Test Design Help Learners Recognize Prequestioning Benefits." Scienmag. November 17, 2026. https://scienmag.com/refutation-texts-and-test-design-help-learners-recognize-prequestioning-benefits/








