The rapid emergence of second-generation quantum technologies, including quantum computing, sensing, and communication, represents a paradigm shift that extends far beyond technical innovation. While these technologies promise profound social and economic transformations, their development occurs within an environment of deep uncertainty and rapid commercialization, necessitating a shift in workforce training. Current higher education programs, which have traditionally focused on specialized technical skill acquisition, are increasingly scrutinized for their capacity to address the responsible research and innovation (RRI) requirements essential for long-term viability. A new study published in EPJ Quantum Technology addresses this training gap by proposing a bidimensional analytical lens that articulates transversal competencies—such as critical thinking, systems thinking, and interdisciplinary communication—with RRI-specific domains including ethical reflection, governance, social impacts, sustainability, and privacy. The researchers argue that responsible innovation practice relies on the simultaneous, integrated mobilization of these capabilities in authentic professional contexts, rather than isolated skill training.
To investigate how these competencies are mobilized, the research team conducted a two-part study consisting of a structured literature review of 44 texts and an in-depth, design-based case study of the 2025 Quantum Dialogues Workshop. The workshop, held in Jouvence, Québec, served as a four-day intensive collaborative design experience for 26 doctoral candidates and early-career researchers from disciplines including physics, ethics, law, political science, education, and communication. Consistent with design-based research methodology, the investigators adopted a dual role as designers and researchers, documenting participant interactions, prototypes, and reflective sessions to examine how design features—such as interdisciplinary team composition and collaborative prototyping—supported the mobilization of RRI competencies. The methodology avoided pre-post measurement, opting instead for a multi-source, exploratory inquiry into the situated, emergent nature of competency integration in collaborative practice.
The study differentiates between technical competencies, which benefit from established pedagogical ecosystems like programming platforms and hardware-specific training, and transversal competencies, which are frequently described as abstract recommendations rather than concrete educational targets. The proposed bidimensional lens provides a framework to translate these abstract RRI principles into actionable learning objectives. The researchers highlight that responsible professional practice requires the simultaneous engagement of these dimensions: for instance, effective ethical reflection is often predicated on the capacity for interdisciplinary communication, while addressing sustainability tensions requires sophisticated complex problem-solving abilities. This integrated view challenges the modular approach prevalent in many current curricula, suggesting that competency development occurs progressively through repeated mobilization in varied professional situations, making the design of authentic learning experiences a critical pedagogical concern.
Empirical results from the workshop revealed that participants often mobilized competencies in recurring configurations rather than as isolated skills. Team Birds, for example, highlighted the fundamental difficulty of developing a common language across physics, law, and ethics during their prototyping work. Their development of an “ethical dictionary” served as a pragmatic response to these communicative barriers, demonstrating how interdisciplinary communication acts as a foundational prerequisite for substantive ethical reflection and governance analysis. The team specifically identified that existing governance structures for quantum technologies frequently exclude civil society, underscoring the need for competencies that go beyond mere stakeholder presence toward the genuine negotiation of power dynamics and decision-making authority.
Complex problem-solving competencies were further observed as participants grappled with structural contradictions inherent in quantum technological deployment. Team Birds’ scenario analysis, which utilized a 2×2 matrix to examine the relationship between computational performance and energy efficiency, identified the classic rebound effect: while quantum improvements might offer climate benefits, the rapid scaling and investment back into high-intensity systems could potentially outweigh initial environmental gains. Similarly, Team Bears encountered an ethical paradox when examining the decentralization of quantum sensors, identifying that the drive for individual empowerment—while ethically desirable for equity—conflicted with the material requirement for rare resources managed by a limited number of dominant corporate entities. These interactions demonstrated that participants were learning to navigate irresolvable tensions rather than simply identifying singular, optimal solutions.
Systems thinking emerged as a particularly salient integrative competency throughout the workshop, enabling participants to connect insights across thematic days dedicated to ethics, sustainability, and social desirability. Team Birds’ Q-Cube prototype explicitly rejected linear, checklist-based approaches to responsible innovation, proposing instead a multidimensional framework where ethics, sustainability, and social impact considerations must be addressed simultaneously. In another example, Team Raccoons’ supply chain analysis demonstrated how systems thinking transforms a basic sustainability concern into a complex geopolitical inquiry, as they traced the significance of rare metals beyond their quantity to include the international relations and national security interests governing their extraction and control. This capacity to trace secondary and tertiary consequences across sectors proved vital for developing coherent analytical frameworks for RRI.
Anticipatory thinking also manifested through sophisticated forms of affective anchoring. Team Bears utilized an interactive game design that featured a child character, designed to make intergenerational responsibility emotionally present rather than purely analytical. By requiring players to justify policy decisions to this future-oriented figure, the design facilitated reflection on the long-term societal distributions of quantum technology. While this demonstrated the power of relational imagination, the researchers also noted a persistent gap in anticipatory competence: the ability to foresee future trajectories did not always translate into actionable insight regarding current professional practice, such as addressing issues like gentrification in innovation districts. This discrepancy highlights the necessity of metacognitive scaffolding to support the transfer of learning from hypothetical design scenarios to situated professional environments.
The researchers also identified areas where competency manifestation remained weak, most notably at the intersection of communication and privacy and security risks. Despite the central importance of cryptography and data protection in quantum technologies, this domain appeared minimally in participant prototypes. The study suggests this may result from the technical complexity of privacy concerns, which can hinder interdisciplinary exchange without specific expert scaffolding. Furthermore, while critical thinking was highly developed regarding external governance exclusions, it appeared less frequently when participants scrutinized their own workshop practices, which tended to reproduce the very expert-centered dialogue patterns they critiqued in their scenarios. This limitation reinforces the argument that theoretical engagement with inclusion is insufficient to develop the competencies required for practicing it.
The study concludes that effective RRI competency development for the next generation of quantum researchers requires embedded learning within authentic research practice rather than supplementary formal modules. The authors propose that future pedagogical designs should incorporate structured metacognitive activities, such as guided self-assessment against the bidimensional lens and explicit analysis of how learning transfers to professional contexts. By adopting a posture of accompaniment, educators can facilitate the socio-cognitive conflicts that arise in interdisciplinary design work, ensuring they remain productive encounters for cognitive restructuring. This approach emphasizes that competency mastery is a developmental process occurring over extended timeframes, necessitating a shift from one-off workshops to sustained pedagogical integration.
Finally, the researchers note the potential transferability of the bidimensional analytical lens to other disruptive technology domains, such as artificial intelligence or biotechnology. While the specific content of competency intersections would necessarily vary based on the technological context, the structure—linking transversal capabilities with domain-specific RRI challenges—provides a robust foundation for broader efforts to integrate responsible innovation into advanced scientific training. Addressing the limitations of the current study, including the lack of causal claims and the academic focus of the participant pool, will require longitudinal research and engagement with diverse stakeholder groups, including industry practitioners and civil society representatives, to ensure that the pedagogical models developed are as resilient and adaptable as the technologies they are designed to govern.
Subject of Research: Competency development for responsible research and innovation (RRI) in quantum technology professional training.
Article Title: Responsible development of quantum technologies: from competency landscape to pedagogical design
Article References: Paukovics, E., Meyer, F., Thibault, K., Lison, C., & Lacroix, I. (2026). Responsible development of quantum technologies: from competency landscape to pedagogical design. EPJ Quantum Technology, 13(1), Article 121. https://doi.org/10.1140/epjqt/s40507-026-00567-y
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1140/epjqt/s40507-026-00567-y
Keywords: quantum technology, responsible research and innovation, pedagogical design, higher education, transversal competencies, systems thinking, interdisciplinary collaboration, design-based research, ethical reflection, quantum workforce, social impact, sustainability, metacognitive scaffolding, emerging technologies, professional training, governance, critical thinking, anticipatory thinking, educational innovation, quantum dialogues
Cite Scienmag News
Katie Riggs. (November 18, 2026). Integrated Competencies Essential for Responsible Quantum Technology Development. Scienmag. https://scienmag.com/integrated-competencies-essential-for-responsible-quantum-technology-development/
Katie Riggs. "Integrated Competencies Essential for Responsible Quantum Technology Development." Scienmag, 18 November 2026, https://scienmag.com/integrated-competencies-essential-for-responsible-quantum-technology-development/. Accessed 18 November 2026.
Katie Riggs. "Integrated Competencies Essential for Responsible Quantum Technology Development." Scienmag. November 18, 2026. https://scienmag.com/integrated-competencies-essential-for-responsible-quantum-technology-development/








