Civil engineering researchers have demonstrated that a coupled structural and geotechnical numerical modeling framework accurately captures settlement and differential displacement in group pile foundations supporting a steel-framed industrial facility constructed over soft coastal soils. Evaluating the three-dimensional interaction between an engineered superstructure and weak subterranean strata, the investigation revealed that immediate elastic deformation governs overall foundation displacement, while long-term consolidation contributes only a minor increment to the cumulative vertical movement. The numerical predictions showed that total settlement reached a peak value of 23.98 millimeters and angular distortion remained between 1/2000 and 1/2058 across adjacent pile groups over a projected ten-year duration. These deformation values comfortably satisfy the serviceability criteria established by Indonesian National Standard SNI 8460:2017, confirming that integrating realistic column reactions into subsurface finite element simulations provides an effective serviceability assessment for complex infrastructure.
The structural setting under evaluation comprises a low-rise, steel-framed industrial warehouse situated on soft coastal deposits with an active groundwater table resting just 0.7 meters below the surface. The facility encompasses a rectangular footprint measuring 47.0 meters in total width across three portal frame lines, designated as Grid A, Grid B, and Grid C, with a transverse spacing of 23.5 meters between rows, and extending 208 meters longitudinally from Grid 1 to Grid 27. To support the superstructure against the weak underlying geology, the foundation layout incorporates two distinct configurations of precast reinforced concrete circular piles linked by solid reinforced concrete pile caps. Four-pile groups designated as PC-1 support the outer framing rows along Grids A and C, whereas six-pile arrangements labeled PC-2 are positioned beneath the central interior row along Grid B, where gravity demands from the structural portal frames are substantially higher.
Geotechnical characterization of the coastal site relied on two exploratory Cone Penetration Test soundings advanced to a terminal depth of 20.2 meters, measuring continuous profiles of cone tip resistance and sleeve friction to delineate stratigraphy. The subsurface profile was subdivided into five principal soil layers, identified by Soil Behavior Type charts correlating tip resistance and friction ratio, and subsequently confirmed by laboratory sieve analyses performed on undisturbed field samples. The precast concrete piles were designed with an embedment length of 18 meters, extending through the compressible cohesive strata and terminating within the underlying stiffer sandy silt layer, creating a combined bearing mechanism mobilized by both skin friction and toe resistance.
To overcome the common analytical limitation of applying simplified uniform loads or idealized point reactions to foundation designs, the authors established a three-dimensional building framework in ETABS to compute exact structural joint forces under critical load combinations. The governing gravity design scenario, combining dead load, superimposed dead load, and operational live load under SNI 1727:2020 specifications, produced the maximum compressive column reactions at the ground interfaces. These computed three-dimensional column forces were directly exported and applied as nodal loads onto the corresponding pile cap locations in the geotechnical finite element model. Horizontal shears were determined to be minor relative to the large vertical thrusts, which reached up to 2,131 kilonewtons on interior columns, confirming that foundation deformation across the building plan is controlled by vertical structural demand rather than lateral forces.
The three-dimensional geotechnical domain was discretized across an extensive model volume measuring 235 meters along the longitudinal building direction, 100 meters transversely, and 20.2 meters in depth to mitigate potential boundary boundary-constraint interference. Solid continuum elements with an elastic modulus of 29,700 megapascals represented the concrete pile caps, allowing explicit calculation of internal stress distributions and load shedding toward individual piles rather than assuming rigid cap behavior. Embedded pile elements were utilized to model the structural piles without requiring excessive mesh refinement, with axial shaft capacity determined through the Schmertmann-Nottingham method for cohesionless layers and the de Ruiter-Beringen approach for cohesive soils. Under this analytical formulation, an individual pile possessed an ultimate axial resistance of 366.13 kilonewtons, comprising 279.44 kilonewtons of shaft resistance and 86.69 kilonewtons of end-bearing resistance based on cone penetration test correlations.
Numerical modeling followed a rigorous sequence of staged construction phases, beginning with initial geostatic stress generation using the K0-procedure under soil self-weight and static hydrostatic conditions, followed by pile and cap activation. Structural column reactions were then applied incrementally across four sequential plastic loading stages corresponding to 25, 50, 75, and 100 percent of the total structural demands to capture immediate elastoplastic deformation. Following full mechanical application, coupled consolidation stages were evaluated over elapsed intervals of 1, 3, 5, and 10 years based on Biot’s consolidation formulation, which simultaneously couples soil skeleton mechanical equilibrium with transient pore fluid flow. This multi-stage progression enabled the authors to separate initial elastic displacement from progressive time-dependent settlement driven by excess pore water pressure dissipation across the foundation footprint.
The settlement distribution revealed that foundation deformations were heavily localized beneath the pile caps, decreasing rapidly toward zero in the free-field soil outside the group influence zones. A pronounced transverse differential developed across the building width, forming a symmetric single-bowl profile where the largest displacements occurred beneath the central PC-2 caps along Grid B. Under immediate structural loading, settlement reached 23.06 millimeters at the critical interior node of PC-2, compared to 13.20 millimeters beneath the edge PC-1 caps, producing an immediate transverse differential of 9.86 millimeters. After ten years of coupled consolidation, cumulative total settlement increased modestly to 23.98 millimeters for PC-2 and 13.33 millimeters for PC-1, widening the transverse settlement difference between the central and outer rows to 10.65 millimeters while preserving the geometric shape of the settlement basin.
Temporal analysis demonstrated that immediate elastoplastic movement accounted for virtually all cumulative foundation deformation, representing 96.2 percent of the ten-year settlement for the six-pile caps and 99.0 percent for the four-pile caps. Subsequent consolidation generated only 0.92 millimeters of additional settlement at the critical PC-2 pile cap over ten years, while the four-pile cap gained a negligible 0.13 millimeters, with displacement rates plateauing after the first year. This dominance of immediate settlement occurs because the 18-meter-long piles fully penetrate the compressible clay strata and anchor into stiffer sandy silt layers characterized by elastic moduli of 6,000 to 7,000 kilonewtons per square meter. Because the structural loads are transmitted into deeper, more competent formations through end bearing and shaft resistance, minimal excess pore water pressure is retained within the upper cohesive layers.
Serviceability evaluation confirmed that the pile foundation configurations fully comply with statutory safety criteria, as both total and differential movements fell well below regulatory thresholds. The maximum total settlement of 23.98 millimeters represents only a small fraction of the 228.3-millimeter limit permitted under SNI 8460:2017. Transverse angular distortion between adjacent PC-1 and PC-2 caps spaced 23.5 meters apart measured between 1/2000 and 1/2058, remaining far below the maximum permissible threshold of 1/300.
Examination of pore pressure dissipation verified that hydraulic dissipation occurred rapidly in the initial post-construction period, with positive excess pore pressures of 25 to 30 kilonewtons per square meter dissipating almost completely within three years. Mean effective stress profiles closely tracked the initial geostatic distribution, showing only minor divergence in deeper layers between 17 and 20 meters. Independent hand calculations using the Poulos and Davis elastic formulation yielded immediate settlement estimates of 11.62 millimeters for PC-1 and 18.92 millimeters for PC-2, differing from the finite element predictions by 11.98 percent and 17.96 percent, respectively. The authors noted that while the adopted Mohr-Coulomb model cannot capture secondary creep or stress-dependent stiffness degradation, the coupled framework delivers a reliable, design-stage serviceability evaluation that accurately reflects realistic structural-geotechnical interactions.
Subject of Research: Coupled structural and geotechnical analysis of group pile foundation settlement on soft ground
Article Title: Coupled structural–geotechnical analysis of settlement and differential settlement in group pile foundations on soft soil
Article References: Kusumawardani, R., Nurridwan, A. G. R., Hermawan, I. A., Kusbiantoro, A., & Nugroho, U. (2026). Coupled structural–geotechnical analysis of settlement and differential settlement in group pile foundations on soft soil. Journal of Infrastructure Preservation and Resilience, 7(1), Article 31. https://doi.org/10.1186/s43065-026-00195-x
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1186/s43065-026-00195-x
Keywords: geotechnical engineering, group pile foundation, soil-structure interaction, soft soil, finite element analysis, ETABS structural modeling, consolidation settlement, differential settlement, angular distortion, cone penetration test, embedded pile element, pile cap design, serviceability limits, Biot consolidation, pore water pressure dissipation, settlement prediction, Mohr-Coulomb model, structural engineering
Cite Scienmag News
Denise Maddox. (November 19, 2026). Coupled Structural Analysis Shows Industrial Pile Settlements Settle Safely on Soft Ground. Scienmag. https://scienmag.com/coupled-structural-analysis-shows-industrial-pile-settlements-settle-safely-on-soft-ground/
Denise Maddox. "Coupled Structural Analysis Shows Industrial Pile Settlements Settle Safely on Soft Ground." Scienmag, 19 November 2026, https://scienmag.com/coupled-structural-analysis-shows-industrial-pile-settlements-settle-safely-on-soft-ground/. Accessed 19 November 2026.
Denise Maddox. "Coupled Structural Analysis Shows Industrial Pile Settlements Settle Safely on Soft Ground." Scienmag. November 19, 2026. https://scienmag.com/coupled-structural-analysis-shows-industrial-pile-settlements-settle-safely-on-soft-ground/








