In an agricultural field trial conducted in the semi-arid conditions of Botswana, researchers demonstrated that aqueous leaf extracts derived from two widespread plants, southern marigold and chinaberry, can protect maize crops against the devastating invasive pest known as the fall armyworm. When applied in equal mixtures, these natural botanical treatments substantially lowered pest incidence and feeding injury on maize plants, producing grain yields statistically indistinguishable from plots protected by the standard synthetic chemical pesticide cypermethrin. The investigation evaluated crude extracts of southern marigold, scientifically identified as Tagetes minuta, and chinaberry, known as Melia azedarach, applied both as individual sprays and as combined botanical formulations across multiple concentrations. Conducted at the Botswana University of Agriculture and Natural Resources experimental garden situated in Sebele Valley, the study provides quantitative evidence on how locally accessible, plant-derived insecticidal preparations perform under real-world agronomic and semi-arid environmental conditions in southern Africa.
Fall armyworm, or Spodoptera frugiperda, is a nocturnal moth species native to the tropical and subtropical regions of the Americas that has emerged as one of the most destructive agricultural threats across sub-Saharan Africa following its initial detection on the continent in 2016. The larval stage exhibits an exceptionally broad dietary breadth, feeding on more than 350 host plant species across 76 families, with cereal staples like maize being especially vulnerable to severe foliar destruction. As a highly migratory pest capable of flying hundreds of kilometers under favorable wind conditions and producing up to two thousand eggs per female lifetime, the fall armyworm has spread to more than 70 countries worldwide. In major African maize-producing economies, unmanaged infestations frequently precipitate regional yield contractions ranging between 21 and 67 percent, threatening the basic food security and economic stability of resource-constrained smallholder farming households who frequently lack access to costly commercial chemical inputs.
While synthetic insecticides represent the conventional response to fall armyworm infestations in commercial agriculture, their widespread deployment presents serious ecological and public health challenges. Repeated chemical applications often induce physiological pest resistance, trigger pest resurgence by eradicating non-target beneficial predators, and contaminate terrestrial and aquatic food webs. Moreover, synthetic pesticides pose direct toxic exposure hazards to small-scale farm applicators who rarely possess adequate protective gear, while purchasing imported synthetic sprays places severe financial pressure on rural family budgets. Although traditional cultural techniques such as applying sand and wood ash into leaf whorls are practiced, they demand extensive physical labor that often falls disproportionately on women and children. These practical and economic constraints have accelerated the search for sustainable, low-cost botanical insecticides, utilizing locally abundant plants capable of disrupting pest feeding, growth, and survival without inflicting persistent synthetic chemical residues on agricultural ecosystems.
To evaluate whether botanical treatments could deliver measurable protection under challenging environmental conditions, researchers established a field experiment at Sebele Valley near Gaborone, located at an elevation of 994 meters above sea level. The study site is characterized by an average annual rainfall of approximately 457 millimeters, with extreme summer temperatures reaching up to 35 to 50 degrees Celsius alongside winter frost risks. The field trial was configured according to a three-by-three factorial treatment structure arranged in a randomized complete block design across three independent replications. The overall experimental area encompassed 810 square meters subdivided into 44 distinct plots of nine square meters each, with each plot containing 25 maize plants spaced at 75-centimeter intervals. To manage irregular precipitation patterns typical of Botswana, the experimental plots were supported with gravitational drip irrigation delivering reclaimed non-potable grey water two to four times weekly, allowing the researchers to isolate insecticidal efficacy under uniform water management.
The experimental treatments incorporated three distinct botanical regimens: Tagetes minuta leaf extract, Melia azedarach leaf extract, and an equal one-to-one combination of both plant materials. Fresh leaves harvested from nursery stock and university grounds were weighed and crushed in a mechanical blender before undergoing aqueous maceration in one liter of water for 24 hours in darkness, supplemented with ten milliliters of liquid dishwashing soap to serve as a surfactant and improve foliar adherence. Three concentration levels were prepared using 100 grams, 500 grams, and 1000 grams of fresh leaf mass per liter, subsequently diluted into ten liters of water per nine-square-meter plot to create low, intermediate, and high application rates designated as T1 through T3, M1 through M3, and TM1 through TM3. These botanical sprays were compared against an untreated negative control plot and a standard commercial control treated with cypermethrin, a synthetic pyrethroid widely utilized in the region.
Applications commenced on December 13, 2024, exactly 14 days after crop emergence, targeting the earliest egg-laying and initial larval instars to suppress successive generational cycles before pests could bore deeply into plant whorls. Subsequent sprayings took place at scheduled 21-day intervals on December 28, 2024, and January 11, 2025, an interval designed to permit plant tissue recovery while avoiding potential phytotoxic stress from repeated exposure. Prior to each scheduled treatment, the research team conducted both non-destructive foliar observations and semi-destructive sampling by carefully unrolling damaged leaf whorls on nine randomly selected plants per plot following diagonal and W-shaped sampling transects. Pest incidence was calculated as the percentage of damaged plants relative to the surveyed sample, while damage severity was graded on a standardized one-to-five visual rating scale adapted from Davis and CIAT protocols, ranging from complete absence of symptoms to severe foliar destruction exceeding 80 percent of leaf area.
Statistical evaluation using general linear model analysis of variance revealed that treatment type exerted a highly significant influence on both fall armyworm incidence and foliar damage severity, whereas varying the concentration of extracts alone did not produce statistically significant main effects across the tested ranges. However, a significant statistical interaction between treatment type and concentration was detected for foliar damage severity, showing that the influence of dosage varied according to the specific botanical formulation employed. In untreated negative control plots, maize plants experienced severe vulnerability, exhibiting an average pest incidence of 94.4 percent and an average visual damage score of 3.56. Plots treated solely with Tagetes minuta provided only intermediate suppression, with incidence lingering near 66.7 percent and visual damage scores remaining elevated at 2.81 to 2.83, demonstrating that marigold alone offered incomplete protection against aggressive feeding activity.
In marked contrast, treatments containing Melia azedarach and the combined Tagetes-Melia formulations achieved outstanding reductions in both pest colonization and feeding damage. The highest combination concentration, designated as TM3, suppressed fall armyworm infestation rates down to 25 percent and lowered the mean damage severity score to 0.44. This protective performance proved statistically comparable to the standard cypermethrin chemical treatment, which recorded an incidence of 19.4 percent and a damage score of 0.53. Single Melia azedarach applications also exhibited notable insecticidal activity, yielding low mean severity scores of 0.36 across certain plots. Researchers attributed this heightened bioefficacy to complementary biochemical modes of action present in the two plant species, wherein limonoids with meliacin properties from chinaberry disrupt insect feeding, reproduction, and larval development, while thiophenes and terpenoids characteristic of marigold act as potent antifeedants and sensory repellents against foraging caterpillars.
The pronounced reduction in foliar damage directly translated into enhanced agronomic productivity and grain recovery at harvest time. Individual ear metrics showed that plots protected by combined extracts and standard chemical controls produced the longest cobs, the highest cob weights, and superior hundred-kernel mass, reflecting robust grain filling during reproductive development. Pairwise correlation analyses confirmed strong, statistically significant positive relationships between overall cob weight and total grain weight, as well as moderate positive associations with the number of kernel rows. Untreated control plots suffered catastrophic yield collapse, producing only 0.72 kilograms per plot, equivalent to an extrapolated field productivity of 144.9 kilograms per hectare, reflecting an estimated yield loss exceeding 70 percent driven by uninterrupted larval whorl feeding.
Total grain yield comparisons demonstrated that the intermediate combined botanical formulation, TM2, produced the highest overall yield performance among all experimental treatments, averaging 5.8 kilograms per plot or 681.5 kilograms per hectare. This outcome significantly exceeded the untreated control and closely matched the standard cypermethrin control, which yielded 5.3 kilograms per plot or 667.2 kilograms per hectare. Notably, the grain yield achieved under the TM2 botanical regimen slightly surpassed Botswana’s nationwide average maize productivity benchmark of 670 kilograms per hectare projected for the 2024 to 2025 cropping campaign. While absolute yields in this semi-arid environment naturally remain lower than those recorded in high-rainfall agroecological regions like Zambia, matching synthetic chemical performance under supplemental irrigation underscores the practical viability of botanical mixtures for smallholder farmers operating under low-input constraints.
Field observations also highlighted critical ecological contrasts between the management strategies regarding non-target organisms within the experimental agroecosystem. Plots treated with standard cypermethrin showed marked mortality among beneficial and non-target insect species, including honeybees such as Apis mellifera, visiting butterflies like Junonia oenone and Hehomoïa glaucippe, foraging driver ants, antlions, and predatory bush crickets. Such unintended disruptions to beneficial entomofauna can inadvertently destabilize natural biological control mechanisms and threaten vital crop pollination services. In contrast, botanical extracts utilize biodegradable natural compounds that offer targeted suppression while avoiding the severe non-target mortality associated with persistent synthetic broad-spectrum neurotoxins.
Despite these encouraging agronomic outcomes, the investigators identified several experimental boundaries that must guide the interpretation and future development of botanical insect management. The field evaluation was conducted over a single cropping season at one geographic research station, meaning multi-season and multi-location field trials across varied agroecological zones remain necessary to confirm formulation consistency under fluctuating climatic pressures and pest dynamics. Furthermore, the trial did not employ mathematical interaction models, such as the Chou-Talalay Combination Index, to formally quantify whether the observed enhancement constitutes true pharmacological synergy rather than additive bioactivity. Future investigations will also need to address batch-to-batch phytochemical variability in harvested wild plant leaves, assess storage shelf-life and field persistence, conduct comprehensive economic cost-benefit analyses, and monitor long-term impacts on natural pollinator communities to support the widespread adoption of standardized botanical pest control programs.
Subject of Research: Bioefficacy of botanical extracts against fall armyworm on maize in Botswana
Article Title: Bioefficacy of plant extracts of Tagetes minuta L. and Melia azedarach L. against fall armyworm (Spodoptera frugiperda J. E. Smith) on maize (Zea mays)
Article References: Kiete, S., Buxton, M., Legwaila, M. M., Tiroesele, B., Omoloye, A. A., & Byaundaombe, J.-P. L. (2026). Bioefficacy of plant extracts of Tagetes minuta L. and Melia azedarach L. against fall armyworm (Spodoptera frugiperda J. E. Smith) on maize (Zea mays). Discover Agriculture, 4(1), Article 338. https://doi.org/10.1007/s44279-026-00797-9
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1007/s44279-026-00797-9
Keywords: Fall armyworm, Spodoptera frugiperda, Maize, Zea mays, Botanical insecticides, Tagetes minuta, Melia azedarach, Integrated pest management, Agroecology, Botswana agriculture, Crop protection, Foliar damage, Agricultural entomology, Cypermethrin alternative, Grain yield, Semi-arid farming
Cite Scienmag News
Alan Morgan. (November 20, 2026). Combined Botanical Leaf Extracts Suppress Fall Armyworm Damage in Botswana Maize Trials. Scienmag. https://scienmag.com/combined-botanical-leaf-extracts-suppress-fall-armyworm-damage-in-botswana-maize-trials/
Alan Morgan. "Combined Botanical Leaf Extracts Suppress Fall Armyworm Damage in Botswana Maize Trials." Scienmag, 20 November 2026, https://scienmag.com/combined-botanical-leaf-extracts-suppress-fall-armyworm-damage-in-botswana-maize-trials/. Accessed 20 November 2026.
Alan Morgan. "Combined Botanical Leaf Extracts Suppress Fall Armyworm Damage in Botswana Maize Trials." Scienmag. November 20, 2026. https://scienmag.com/combined-botanical-leaf-extracts-suppress-fall-armyworm-damage-in-botswana-maize-trials/








