In a comprehensive examination published in BMC Psychiatry, researchers have delved into the intricate relationship between visual impairment (VI) and certain mental health disorders (MHDs), exposing significant gaps and challenges in understanding their combined effects on daily functioning. This systematic review meticulously assessed existing literature to unravel how co-occurring visual and psychiatric conditions influence psychological, social, physical, and educational dimensions of life, particularly focusing on populations most affected by this complex interplay.
Visual impairment, a condition that profoundly affects sensory experience, often necessitates extensive adaptation in individuals’ lives. When compounded by mental health disorders such as personality disorders (including antisocial, borderline, and dependent types), autism spectrum disorder (ASD), obsessive-compulsive disorder, and psychotic conditions, the complexity of impairment increases manifold. The review aimed to amalgamate scattered findings to provide a clearer picture of how these combinations impact daily functioning and highlight critical areas for future research.
The authors adhered strictly to the PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) framework, rigorously screening multiple prominent scientific databases, including PubMed, Embase, CINAHL, PsycINFO, the Cochrane Library, and Web of Science. This exhaustive search, spanning until December 2024, sought to uncover peer-reviewed articles that explored the dual burden of VI and specified MHDs on individual functioning, carefully applying quality assessments through the PHO MetaQAT criteria to evaluate the robustness of the evidence.
Out of the extensive literature pool, only twenty-two relevant studies met the inclusion criteria, underscoring a striking scarcity of focused research on this subject. Remarkably, twenty-one of these centered on children with both VI and ASD, predominantly analyzed within school environments. This narrow concentration underscores a significant research bias toward pediatric autism in visual impairment contexts, while other crucial mental health categories remain glaringly under-explored.
One outlier study investigated the impact of VI combined with psychotic disorders but stood alone in its scope, highlighting an urgent need to diversify investigative efforts across other potentially debilitating mental health conditions. The findings unravel a multifaceted impact encompassing five thematic domains of daily life, namely psychological functioning, social integration, physical capabilities, academic performance, and the availability and efficacy of parental and clinical support systems.
Psychological functioning revealed significant challenges for individuals managing both VI and mental health disorders. Emotional regulation difficulties, heightened stress responses, and vulnerability to exacerbated symptoms were recurrent themes. These impairments often intertwine, making diagnosis and treatment notoriously complex and necessitating nuanced clinical approaches tailored to the unique needs arising from this co-morbidity.
Social functioning, an essential facet of human experience, was markedly compromised in those bearing the dual burden. Isolation, communication barriers, and diminished participation in community and peer activities were prevalent, especially among children with ASD, accentuating the pressing requirement for integrated social support interventions. These social deficits not only impair quality of life but also contribute to secondary mental health complications, forming a vicious cycle of disengagement.
Physical functioning, although less frequently emphasized, still emerged as a critical concern. The dual strain of visual deficits alongside mental health challenges undermined mobility, daily self-care routines, and overall health maintenance, necessitating multidisciplinary rehabilitative care. The intricate relationship between physical and mental health warrants more focused research to optimize therapeutic strategies and improve independence outcomes.
Academic settings appear as focal environments where the interplay between VI and MHDs uniquely manifests. Many studies highlighted diminished school performance due to difficulties in communication, sensory processing, and behavioral challenges inherent to autism and other disorders. These educational impairments not only hinder cognitive development but also limit future opportunities, emphasizing the need for tailored educational policies and support frameworks.
Parental and clinical support systems emerged as pivotal yet variably effective domains in managing this complex co-morbidity. The literature indicated that caregivers often face enormous strain, underscoring a gap in targeted assistance and resources. Clinicians also encounter hurdles in diagnostic clarity and treatment planning due to overlapping symptoms and limited interdisciplinary collaboration, calling for enhanced training and integrated care models.
Crucially, the review’s quality assessment revealed that most studies were hindered by methodological shortcomings, with only one study rated as ‘sufficient’ or ‘good’ in validity, while the remainder showed at least one ‘insufficient’ or ‘unclear’ rating. This pervasive lack of high-quality evidence raises important concerns about the reliability of existing conclusions and highlights a formidable barrier to developing evidence-based interventions.
The authors concluded by emphasizing the profound need for future research efforts to address these critical gaps. Expanding the spectrum of mental health disorders studied alongside VI, improving methodological rigor, and exploring longitudinal outcomes could significantly advance understanding and support for affected individuals. Such research holds promise for refining diagnostic criteria, personalizing treatment, and ultimately improving life quality in this vulnerable population.
Integrating these findings into healthcare policies will require a multidimensional approach, integrating ophthalmology, psychiatry, psychology, education, and social care. Stakeholders must prioritize enhanced awareness, resource allocation, and comprehensive support systems to mitigate the compounded challenges faced by individuals with visual impairments and comorbid mental health disorders.
This systematic review, while illuminating, serves more as a call to action than a definitive source of guidance. It exposes an urgent need for more nuanced and methodologically sound research to develop effective strategies that can improve daily functioning and long-term outcomes for these individuals. Collaborative frameworks that bridge sensory and mental health disciplines are essential to usher in a new era of holistic care.
As the population ages and diagnostic practices evolve, the prevalence and recognition of co-occurring visual and mental health impairments are expected to rise. This trend further accentuates the urgency for comprehensive research and clinical models equipped to address these multifactorial challenges in diverse populations across the lifespan.
In conclusion, while the current knowledge base is limited, the intersection of visual impairment and mental health disorders presents a critical frontier for clinical science. Addressing the complex needs of these individuals demands innovative, interdisciplinary approaches informed by rigorous research. The insights provided by van Munster and colleagues’ systematic review lay a foundational framework from which future investigations can expand, fostering improved understanding and compassionate care.
Subject of Research: The combined impact of visual impairment and specific mental health disorders on daily functioning.
Article Title: The impact of visual impairment and comorbid mental health disorders on daily functioning: a systematic literature review.
Article References: van Munster, E.P., Onnink, M.L., Teunissen, L.B. et al. The impact of visual impairment and comorbid mental health disorders on daily functioning: a systematic literature review. BMC Psychiatry 25, 721 (2025). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12888-025-07085-8
Image Credits: AI Generated
