Study sheds light on bacteria associated with pre-term birth

Researchers from North Carolina State University have found that multiple species of Gardnerella, bacteria sometimes associated with bacterial vaginosis (BV) and pre-term birth, can coexist in the same vaginal microbiome. The findings add to the emerging picture of Gardnerella’s effects on human health. 

Gardnerella is a group of anaerobic bacteria that are commonly found in the vaginal microbiome. Higher levels of the bacteria are a signature of BV and associated with higher risk of pre-term birth, but it is also found in women who have no sign of disease.

“We were trying to understand diversity within Gardnerella,” says Ben Callahan, associate professor of population health and pathobiology at NC State and corresponding author of the work. “Scientists have only recently begun to look at individual Gardnerella species, so we don’t know yet whether different species might have different health effects. So our main aim was to explore the ecology of Gardnerella.”

The unique challenge in sequencing the vaginal microbiome is that any samples will be predominantly composed of the host’s DNA, which makes extracting microbial data more expensive and time consuming. The research team’s first job was to establish a methodology that allowed them to identify distinct species of Gardnerella from the microbiome data.

“The available tools to study the vaginal microbiome would consider all Gardnerella as the same species,” says Hanna Berman, postdoctoral research scholar at NC State and lead author of the work. “To even be able to do this work, we had to create our own database of Gardnerella genomes and devise a method to identify the different Gardnerella species. Hopefully this will also allow more researchers to be able to study Gardnerella diversity.”

The research team looked at sequencing data from three cohorts: two random populations of pregnant women, and one population with a history of pre-term birth. They analyzed the metagenomic sequences of Gardnerella from the samples to see if there was a relationship between a particular Gardnerella species and pre-term birth.

While they didn’t find a “smoking gun,” they did make two surprising findings.

First, they identified a potential 14th species of Gardnerella among the samples – prior to this work only 13 species had been identified. 

They also saw that in the majority of samples in which Gardnerella was present, multiple species of Gardnerella coexisted in the same microbiome: anywhere from two to as many as all 14 known Gardnerella species were found in single samples.

“Normally if a species of bacteria has colonized an environment, we expect it to exclude close relatives that would occupy the same environmental niche and consume the same resources,” Callahan says. “I often say that with bacteria all things are possible, but this is still unusual. We also saw that when the overall microbial load is higher, Gardnerella is a higher proportion of the microbial load.

“Evidence continues to build that Gardnerella has an association with pre-term birth, but the details of that relationship are complicated. In this work, we didn’t find one bad species of Gardnerella – they may all be bad. This is far from the end of the story.”

The researchers hope to explore questions of species coexistence and microbiome composition further in future work.

“The vaginal microbiome has been understudied,” Callahan says. “For example, it is often dominated by one species of Lactobacillus, which creates an environment that excludes other bacteria. When it isn’t there, Gardnerella is. So how do the bacteria interact?

“Answering these questions may lead to more effective treatments for BV, and for ways to predict and avoid pre-term birth. This work is an important step in that process.”

The research appears in mSystems and is supported by funding from the Eunice Kennedy Shriver National Institute of Child Health and Human Development under Award Numbers 5F31HD104353 and 730 K99HD090290, the National Institutes of Health NIGMS under award R35GM133745, and the March of Dimes. NC State student Megan Anderson, Daniela Aliaga Goltsman of Metagenomi, Inc., and David Relman of Stanford University also contributed to the work.

-peake-

Note to editors: An abstract follows.

“Gardnerella Diversity and Ecology in Pregnancy and Preterm Birth”

DOI:  10.1128/msystems.01339-23
 
Authors: Hanna Berman, Megan Anderson, Benjamin Callahan, North Carolina State University; Daniela S. Aliaga Goltsman, Stanford University, currently at Metagenomi Incorporated; David Relman, Stanford University and Veterans Affairs Palo Alto Health Care System
Published: May 16, 2024 in mSystems

Abstract:
The vaginal microbiome has been linked to negative health outcomes including preterm birth. Specific taxa, including Gardnerella spp., have been identified as risk factors for these conditions. Historically, microbiome analysis methods have treated all Gardnerella spp. as one species, but the broad diversity of Gardnerella has become more apparent. We explore the diversity of Gardnerella clades and genomic species in the vaginal microbiome of pregnant women and their associations with microbiome composition and preterm birth.
Relative abundance of Gardnerella clades and genomic species and other taxa was quantified in shotgun metagenomic sequencing data from three distinct cohorts of pregnant women. We also assessed the diversity and abundance of Gardnerella variants in 16S rRNA gene amplicon sequencing data from seven previously conducted studies in differing populations.
Individual microbiomes often contained multiple Gardnerella variants, and the number of clades was associated with increased microbial load, or the ratio of non-human reads to human reads. Taxon co-occurrence patterns were largely consistent across Gardnerella clades and among cohorts. Some variants previously described as rare were prevalent in other cohorts, highlighting the importance of surveying a diverse set of populations to fully capture the diversity of Gardnerella.
The diversity of Gardnerella both across populations and within individual vaginal microbiomes has long been unappreciated, as has been the intra-species diversity of many other members of the vaginal microbiome. The broad genomic diversity of Gardnerella has led to its reclassification as multiple species; here we demonstrate the diversity of Gardnerella found within and between vaginal microbiomes.