Only seven of 42 implementation science theories, models, and frameworks explicitly designed or adapted to advance health equity satisfy all eight established equity criteria, according to a scoping review and critical appraisal published on August 19, 2026, in the journal Implementation Science. Their appraisal identified widespread proliferation of equity-focused models alongside substantial conceptual omissions across the field, with most available frameworks lacking concrete procedures to address structural barriers or establish community co-ownership.
In their background assessment, the authors explained that implementation science theories, models, and frameworks can guide implementation research and practice to address widening inequities in healthcare access, quality, and health outcomes. The stated aim of the scoping review was to map and critically appraise implementation science theories, models, and frameworks that were explicitly created or adapted to advance health equity.
The team conducted the review in accordance with Joanna Briggs Institute guidance. Investigators systematically searched MEDLINE, CINAHL, and five specialized implementation science and equity journals from their inception dates through May 20, 2025. Eligible records were limited to primary descriptions of implementation science theories, models, and frameworks purposely built to advance health equity, as well as equity-focused adaptations of existing implementation science frameworks. Studies examining applications of these frameworks in research or practice were excluded, and any non-implementation science theories, models, or frameworks were also excluded.
Screening and evaluation procedures involved duplicate independent reviews. Two reviewers independently evaluated titles and abstracts, followed by full texts, using Covidence software, resolving conflicts through consensus adjudication. Relevant data were extracted and charted on a standardized form. Each included framework then underwent duplicate critical equity appraisal evaluated against eight a priori criteria, with an equity expert providing methodological input. The authors compiled and summarized their findings narratively and in evidence tables, noting that no formal review registration was applicable.
From an initial pool of 6,012 retrieved records, 42 theories, models, and frameworks met the eligibility criteria. Among these 42 included tools, 23 were equity-focused adaptations of existing frameworks and 19 were purpose-built models explicitly constructed to advance health equity. The development of these tools has accelerated rapidly in recent years, with 69 percent of the included frameworks published after 2020. However, geographic provenance was heavily skewed toward high-income settings: 67 percent of the frameworks originated in the United States, and none originated in low-income countries.
When categorizing the primary functional aims of the included tools, the researchers found that 45 percent aimed to orient the implementation process, while 23 percent were designed to assess implementation determinants. The duplicate assessment across the eight a priori equity criteria revealed uneven coverage across different dimensions of equity. The highest compliance was observed in foundational recognition and cultural engagement: 90 percent of the frameworks explicitly name health inequities, 88 percent suggest incorporating lay knowledge into implementation processes, and 86 percent promote cultural responsiveness.
Coverage declined substantially when evaluating relational engagement and structural intervention. While 64 percent of the frameworks emphasize two-way learning and relationship building, and 60 percent consider structural determinants, fewer than half provided concrete operational mechanisms. Specifically, only 45 percent of the included frameworks propose concrete community co-ownership mechanisms, only 40 percent outline explicit strategies to mitigate inequities, and only 40 percent offer processes addressing structural barriers. Across the entire sample, only seven frameworks, accounting for 17 percent of the 42 evaluated models, successfully covered all eight equity criteria.
Based on these findings, the authors concluded that while equity-focused theories, models, and frameworks are proliferating within implementation science, most originate in high-income countries and few provide concrete guidance for addressing structural determinants of health inequities. Consequently, the researchers advised that before adopting any candidate framework, researchers and practitioners should critically appraise candidate theories, models, and frameworks with communities and equity experts. They further recommended co-adapting candidate tools to local contexts and, where necessary, extending them to strengthen underdeveloped domains, with particular emphasis on advancing structural change and establishing community co-ownership.
Subject of Research: Implementation Science and Equity-Focused Frameworks
Article Title: Equity-focused theories, models, and frameworks in implementation science: a scoping review and critical appraisal
Article References: Crump, L., Semenic, S., Ahun, M. N., Doyle, S., Stuart, R., Weight, C., Froehlich-Chow, A., King, A., Etherington, C., Welch, V., Shelton, R. C., Presseau, J., & Fontaine, G. (2026). Equity-focused theories, models, and frameworks in implementation science: a scoping review and critical appraisal. Implementation Science, 21(1), Article 67. https://doi.org/10.1186/s13012-026-01536-w
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1186/s13012-026-01536-w
Keywords: Implementation Science, Health Equity, Scoping Review, Health Care Policy, Structural Determinants of Health, Research Methodology, Equity-Focused Frameworks, Public Health, Healthcare Access, Implementation Research, Health Disparities, Critical Appraisal, Community Engagement, Health Outcomes, Healthcare Quality
Cite Scienmag News
Phoebe Ingram. (November 18, 2026). Scoping Review Identifies Gaps in Equity-Focused Implementation Science Frameworks. Scienmag. https://scienmag.com/scoping-review-identifies-gaps-in-equity-focused-implementation-science-frameworks/
Phoebe Ingram. "Scoping Review Identifies Gaps in Equity-Focused Implementation Science Frameworks." Scienmag, 18 November 2026, https://scienmag.com/scoping-review-identifies-gaps-in-equity-focused-implementation-science-frameworks/. Accessed 18 November 2026.
Phoebe Ingram. "Scoping Review Identifies Gaps in Equity-Focused Implementation Science Frameworks." Scienmag. November 18, 2026. https://scienmag.com/scoping-review-identifies-gaps-in-equity-focused-implementation-science-frameworks/








