Group decision-making in complex environments frequently presents significant mathematical and practical challenges, particularly when the relative weights of contributing experts and decision criteria cannot be established in advance. In a study published in the Journal of Mathematics in Industry, researchers Benting Wan, Shufen Zhou, Mengjie Han, Tongyuan Qu, and Youyu Cheng introduced an integrated multi-attribute group decision-making framework designed to overcome these limitations. The newly developed model operates within interval-valued q-rung orthopair fuzzy sets and fuses criteria importance through criteria correlation with the weighted aggregate sum product assessment methodology. By incorporating newly extended Yager aggregation operators, the mathematical framework allows analytical teams to derive objective weights directly from evaluation data rather than relying on subjective initial assignments, thereby systematically mitigating information loss and individual bias across complex evaluation scenarios.
Multi-attribute decision-making involves comparing several competing alternatives across an array of distinct attributes, and when expanded to multiple evaluators, it becomes multi-attribute group decision-making. Conventional fuzzy sets, originally introduced by Lotfi Zadeh, allowed for the representation of vague information, which was subsequently generalized into intuitionistic fuzzy sets, Pythagorean fuzzy sets, and q-rung orthopair fuzzy sets. The interval-valued q-rung orthopair fuzzy set structure expands these earlier formulations by expressing both membership and non-membership degrees as continuous numerical intervals rather than isolated singular points. Within the universe of discourse, the sum of the q-th powers of the upper bounds of membership and non-membership must remain between zero and one for an integer parameter q greater than or equal to one. This mathematical architecture provides decision-makers with substantial representational freedom to capture severe ambiguity, hesitation, and high-dimensional uncertainty without prematurely truncating borderline observations.
A persistent obstacle in real-world applications of these advanced fuzzy environments has been the determination of objective weighting vectors. Previous similarity-based expert weight allocation techniques frequently assigned identical overall weights to an expert across every competing alternative, failing to capture the reality that individual evaluators possess varying degrees of competence, certainty, and reliability depending on the specific profile of the alternative under review. To overcome this limitation, the authors developed a differentiated weighting technique based on ideal reference points. By defining positive ideal reference points where membership is the interval [1, 1] with zero non-membership and negative ideal reference points where membership is zero with non-membership [1, 1], the authors calculate the distances between an expert’s standardized assessment and these reference targets. Calculating relative similarity scores enables the formulation of an expert weight matrix that adapts dynamically across each alternative.
To aggregate expert evaluations effectively while controlling the influence of extreme opinions, the investigators formulated extensions of the Yager weighted average operator and the Yager weighted geometric average operator tailored specifically to interval-valued q-rung orthopair fuzzy numbers. Aggregation operators are indispensable for information fusion, yet standard operational formulas can struggle when balancing high-order consensus against outlying values. The operational laws governing addition, multiplication, scalar multiplication, and power functions under the Yager parameterization use strict mathematical limits to prevent bounded metrics from overflowing the unit interval. The resulting operators were proven to satisfy core structural axioms, including idempotency, boundedness, and monotonicity, ensuring that synthesized group matrices preserve the geometric boundaries and logical ordering of individual input matrices during complex computational merges.
Once expert decision matrices are condensed into a single collective matrix using the Yager weighted average operator, the criteria importance through criteria correlation method is utilized to establish objective attribute weights. Traditional approaches often suffer when decision criteria exhibit strong collinearity or varying data dispersions. The extended CRITIC technique resolves this by computing the standard deviation of each attribute across all evaluated alternatives alongside a correlation coefficient between each pair of attributes based on normalized distance measures. By multiplying an attribute’s dispersion by the sum of its conflict measures relative to all other attributes, the technique yields an objective metric of criteria information content. This approach prevents redundant, highly correlated parameters from dominating the evaluation while appropriately elevating discriminative, independent metrics within the overall decision space.
The synthesized decision matrix and derived attribute weights are subsequently processed through a modified weighted aggregate sum product assessment protocol. Under this formulation, the model generates two parallel evaluation vectors: a weighted arithmetic score calculated via the Yager weighted average operator and a weighted geometric score calculated via the Yager weighted geometric average operator. A compromise aggregation parameter, denoted as beta, combines these two components into a single joint alternative assessment. Setting this parameter to intermediate values allows decision analysts to balance linear additive utility against non-linear multiplicative sensitivity. To establish an unambiguous final ranking, the authors incorporated an improved score function governed by an alpha compromise parameter that evaluates lower and upper intervals alongside non-membership values, complemented by a secondary accuracy function to resolve potential mathematical ties.
To demonstrate the practical validity of the complete CRITIC-WASPAS framework, the researchers applied their methodology to a clinical hypertension risk assessment problem aimed at supporting community healthcare management systems. Residents were classified across five tiered risk categories: red for extremely high risk, orange for high risk, yellow for medium risk, blue for low risk, and green for normal susceptibility. Five clinical experts evaluated examination records across five efficiency criteria: current blood pressure measurement, family genetic history, longitudinal blood pressure trends, age, and associated risk factors. In an empirical test case involving a fifty-year-old resident presenting with a systolic pressure of 135 mmHg, diastolic pressure of 87 mmHg, and a documented family history of hypertension, the model determined objective criteria weights of approximately 0.20506 for blood pressure, 0.17143 for family history, 0.22288 for measurement trends, 0.28682 for age, and 0.11381 for associated risk factors.
The computational pipeline yielded compromise alternative scores of approximately 0.89726 for the red warning, 0.90602 for the orange warning, 0.87932 for the yellow warning, 0.83684 for the blue warning, and 0.78967 for the normal green status. Consequently, the optimal ranking was determined to be orange warning, followed by red, yellow, blue, and green, designating the resident as a high-risk candidate requiring prompt medical intervention to avert cardiovascular complications. This analytical prioritization aligned perfectly with the qualitative diagnoses independently delivered by the panel of five medical experts. Parameter sensitivity analyses conducted across the aggregation parameter p, the fuzzy order q, the score preference alpha, and the WASPAS compromise coefficient beta demonstrated complete ranking stability, confirming that the classification was immune to numerical perturbations within the underlying decision algorithms.
The authors verified the generalizability of their methodology by conducting a secondary empirical case study in the financial sector, evaluating corporate environmental, social, and corporate governance scores across six major banking institutions. Data collected from three major evaluation agencies—Bloomberg, Shangdao Ronglu, and Huaxun—were transformed into standardized decision matrices under the interval-valued q-rung orthopair fuzzy environment. The CRITIC-WASPAS algorithm yielded composite scores of 0.84720 for Ping An Bank, 0.91639 for China Merchants Bank, 0.79654 for Pudong Development Bank, 0.82510 for Industrial Bank, 0.86627 for CITIC Bank, and 0.71091 for Minsheng Bank. The resulting prioritization placed China Merchants Bank in the lead position, a finding directly corroborating the published benchmark conclusions from prior financial literature and demonstrating the model’s cross-disciplinary operational validity.
Comparative analyses against several established multi-attribute methods underscored the discriminative capabilities of the integrated approach. Across both domain cases, the ranking results matched those obtained from the MOORA, MACBETH, MABAC, TOPSIS, standard WASPAS, and ARAS methods, while displaying greater score differentiation between closely ranked alternatives than standalone techniques. Discrepancies observed with the COPRAS method were attributed to the fact that COPRAS requires mixed benefit-cost distributions, whereas the evaluated benchmarks comprised purely beneficial efficiency attributes. Furthermore, benchmarking the Yager operators against Aczel-Alsina, power aggregating, Dombi, and Hamacher operators confirmed superior data separability. While acknowledging current limitations related to small expert cohorts and fixed attribute dimensions, the authors indicated that future iterations will expand toward linear Diophantine fuzzy spaces and large-scale artificial intelligence analytics.
Subject of Research: Interval-valued q-rung orthopair fuzzy multi-attribute group decision-making using Yager operators and CRITIC-WASPAS
Article Title: Yager-based operator interval-valued q-rung orthopair fuzzy CRITIC-WASPAS multi-attribute group decision-making method
Article References: Wan, B., Zhou, S., Han, M., Qu, T., & Cheng, Y. (2026). Yager-based operator interval-valued q-rung orthopair fuzzy CRITIC-WASPAS multi-attribute group decision-making method. Journal of Mathematics in Industry, 16(1), Article 1. https://doi.org/10.1186/s13362-025-00180-1
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1186/s13362-025-00180-1
Keywords: multi-attribute group decision-making, interval-valued q-rung orthopair fuzzy sets, CRITIC method, WASPAS method, Yager aggregation operators, expert weights, attribute weights, hypertension risk assessment, ESG scoring, information fusion, score function, accuracy function, parameter sensitivity analysis, weight sensitivity analysis, decision-making under uncertainty, fused decision models
Cite Scienmag News
Reid Dalton. (November 17, 2026). New Fuzzy Decision Framework Solves Complex Group Evaluations with Unknown Weights. Scienmag. https://scienmag.com/new-fuzzy-decision-framework-solves-complex-group-evaluations-with-unknown-weights/
Reid Dalton. "New Fuzzy Decision Framework Solves Complex Group Evaluations with Unknown Weights." Scienmag, 17 November 2026, https://scienmag.com/new-fuzzy-decision-framework-solves-complex-group-evaluations-with-unknown-weights/. Accessed 17 November 2026.
Reid Dalton. "New Fuzzy Decision Framework Solves Complex Group Evaluations with Unknown Weights." Scienmag. November 17, 2026. https://scienmag.com/new-fuzzy-decision-framework-solves-complex-group-evaluations-with-unknown-weights/








