A recent study published in Management System Engineering examines how specific characteristics of an enterprise’s immediate network, known as the ego-network, influence the relationship between broader network positions and market performance. The research focuses on the global automobile industry, utilizing a coopetition network framework to analyze how firms simultaneously compete and cooperate. The central finding indicates that while structural holes and centrality generally have a positive interaction on market performance, this effect is significantly moderated by the stability and density of the firm’s direct partnerships. Specifically, the positive impact of network position on market performance is stronger when ego-network stability is low and ego-network density is high, suggesting that the benefits of a favorable network position are not uniform but depend heavily on the quality and dynamics of immediate relationships.
The study was conducted by Feiyang Guan and published in 2024. It employs a quantitative approach to test hypotheses derived from social network theory and resource dependence theory. The researchers aimed to bridge the gap between whole-network analysis, which looks at the structure of all participants, and ego-network analysis, which focuses on the sub-network of direct connections surrounding a focal firm. By integrating these two perspectives, the study provides a more nuanced understanding of how firms leverage their network positions to enhance market share. The research questions whether the structural advantages provided by occupying central positions or bridging structural gaps are amplified or diminished by the specific attributes of the firm’s direct partners.
To investigate these questions, the authors selected a sample of automobile enterprises from the Factiva database. The sample included firms classified as automobiles that had international cooperation and competition events during the research period, excluding those with only domestic markets. This selection ensures that the network reflects global interactions, which are critical for the automotive industry. The data covered a five-year sample period, allowing for the observation of network dynamics over time. The use of the Factiva database provided access to both network relationship data and financial indicators, enabling a comprehensive analysis of how network structures correlate with economic outcomes.
The methodology involved constructing a symmetric matrix based on the coopetition relationships among the selected global automobile enterprises. The researchers used Ucinet software to visualize the coopetition network and calculate key network metrics. These metrics included structural holes, centrality, ego-network stability, ego-network expansion, and ego-network density. Structural holes were measured using Burt’s methodology, specifically the extent of structural holes, which indicates the presence of weak ties that bridge disconnected groups. Centrality was measured using degree centrality, which reflects the number of direct connections a firm has, serving as a proxy for strong ties and central position within the network.
Market performance was operationalized as market share, defined as the proportion of a company’s sales in the total sales of all participating companies in the global coopetition network. This measure aligns with existing literature on regional cluster performance and enterprise market outcomes. Ego-network stability was defined as the number of enterprises that maintained connections with the focal enterprise in both the previous and current periods, reflecting the firm’s ability to maintain long-term relationships. Ego-network expansion was measured by the number of newly added partners in the current period compared to the previous one, indicating the firm’s effort to seek new competitive and cooperative partners. Ego-network density was calculated as the ratio of the number of connections in the ego-network to the number of connections in the overall network, representing the degree of interconnection among the firm’s direct partners.
The primary hypothesis tested was that structural holes and centrality have a positive interaction effect on market performance. The results supported this hypothesis, with an interaction coefficient of 0.154, significant at the 0.01 level. This finding suggests that firms possessing both high structural holes and high centrality are better positioned to control information and resources, leading to superior market performance. The interaction implies that the benefits of one network position are enhanced by the presence of the other, creating a synergistic effect that drives market share growth.
However, the study found that this positive interaction is not constant but is moderated by ego-network characteristics. For ego-network stability, the three-way interaction coefficient was significantly negative (β = -0.130; P < 0.1). This indicates that the positive interaction between structural holes and centrality on market performance is stronger under conditions of low ego-network stability. In other words, when a firm’s immediate network is less stable and more dynamic, the advantages of its broader network position are more pronounced. The authors argue that overly stable networks can lead to resource homogeneity and redundancy, limiting the inflow of new knowledge and weakening the utility of structural holes and centrality. Conversely, lower stability allows firms to acquire diverse resources, enhancing the value of their network positions.
In contrast, ego-network density positively moderated the interaction, with a significant coefficient of 0.272 (P < 0.1). This means that the positive effect of structural holes and centrality on market performance is stronger when the ego-network is dense. Dense networks foster higher levels of trust and dependence among partners, facilitating the transfer of resources and knowledge. The authors suggest that in dense networks, the reputational mechanisms and normative systems ensure that partners share valuable information, allowing focal firms to better leverage their network location advantages. This finding highlights the importance of relationship quality in unlocking the potential of network positions.
The study also examined the moderating role of ego-network expansion, but the results did not support the hypothesis that expansion positively moderates the interaction. The three-way interaction coefficient was not significant (β = 0.010; P > 0.1). The authors propose that in the global automotive industry, national boundaries, geographic distance, and cultural differences may hinder the formation of deep trust and reciprocity with new partners. Consequently, simply adding new partners may not be sufficient to enhance the benefits of network position if the relationships lack the depth and trust characteristic of dense or stable networks. This null result underscores the complexity of network dynamics in international contexts.
Robustness tests were conducted by introducing additional control variables, including the number of competitive behaviors and the development level of the home country. The results remained consistent, with the moderating effects of stability and density retaining their significance. This reinforces the reliability of the core findings and suggests that the observed relationships are not driven by omitted variables. The study contributes to the theoretical understanding of how whole-network and ego-network characteristics interact to influence firm performance, providing a more comprehensive framework for analyzing coopetition networks.
From a practical standpoint, the findings offer insights for managers in the automotive industry and other sectors characterized by coopetition. The results suggest that firms should not focus solely on their position in the overall network but should also manage the characteristics of their immediate partnerships. While maintaining a central position and bridging structural holes is beneficial, firms should avoid overly stable networks that may lead to resource stagnation. Instead, they should seek to maintain a balance that allows for the inflow of new resources while fostering the trust and density necessary for effective resource transfer. This implies a strategic approach to partnership management, where the quality and dynamics of direct relationships are as important as the firm’s broader network standing.
The study has several limitations that should be considered when interpreting the results. The sample is limited to the global automobile industry, which may restrict the generalizability of the findings to other industries with different coopetition dynamics. Additionally, the use of market share as a proxy for market performance may not capture all aspects of firm success, such as profitability or innovation output.
Despite these limitations, the study provides valuable evidence on the conditional nature of network advantages in coopetition settings. By identifying the specific ego-network characteristics that moderate the impact of structural holes and centrality, the research offers a refined perspective on how firms can maximize their network resources. The integration of whole-network and ego-network perspectives advances the field of social network analysis in management, highlighting the interplay between different levels of network structure. This work serves as a foundation for further exploration of how firms navigate the complex landscape of competition and cooperation in global markets.
Subject of Research: The moderating effect of ego-network characteristics on the relationship between structural holes, centrality, and market performance in global automotive coopetition networks.
Article Title: Ego-network characteristics moderates the interaction of structural hole and centrality on market performance: based on coopetition network
Article References: Guan, F. (2024). Ego-network characteristics moderates the interaction of structural hole and centrality on market performance: based on coopetition network. Management System Engineering, 3(1), Article 7. https://doi.org/10.1007/s44176-024-00031-0
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1007/s44176-024-00031-0
Keywords: coopetition network, ego-network stability, ego-network density, structural holes, degree centrality, market share, global automobile industry, social network analysis, resource dependence theory, two-stage least squares, Ucinet software, Factiva database, network position, firm performance, strategic alliances, knowledge transfer, network dynamics, Management System Engineering, Feiyang Guan, 2024 research
Cite Scienmag News
Denise Maddox. (November 21, 2026). Network Stability and Density Shape Automotive Market Performance. Scienmag. https://scienmag.com/network-stability-and-density-shape-automotive-market-performance/
Denise Maddox. "Network Stability and Density Shape Automotive Market Performance." Scienmag, 21 November 2026, https://scienmag.com/network-stability-and-density-shape-automotive-market-performance/. Accessed 21 November 2026.
Denise Maddox. "Network Stability and Density Shape Automotive Market Performance." Scienmag. November 21, 2026. https://scienmag.com/network-stability-and-density-shape-automotive-market-performance/








