In recent years, the field of medical education has increasingly focused on the complexities surrounding professional identity formation, particularly among underrepresented groups. Recognizing the disparity in representation within medicine, researchers are now delving into the environmental, societal, and institutional factors that contribute to the challenges faced by these groups. A recent systematic scoping review by Abdi, Sooudi, and Milota sheds light on this critical issue within the context of Dutch medical schools, providing valuable insights into the interventions that can foster a more inclusive and supportive educational landscape.
Professional identity formation (PIF) is a fundamental aspect of becoming a competent medical professional. It involves not only the acquisition of medical knowledge and skills but also the internalization of values, beliefs, and attitudes associated with the profession. For underrepresented groups, this process can be significantly more complex due to systemic barriers and ingrained biases. The authors of the review highlight that these barriers can often manifest in subtle, yet powerful, ways, ultimately influencing the career trajectories and professional satisfaction of these individuals.
Moreover, the systematic scoping review emphasizes that traditional medical education frameworks often overlook the unique experiences and challenges faced by students from underrepresented backgrounds. These students may encounter a range of adversities, including feelings of isolation, stereotype threats, and a lack of mentors who share their backgrounds. Such factors can inhibit their ability to form a robust professional identity, which is crucial for their success in the medical field.
The review identifies a number of significant challenges that underrepresented groups face in their pursuit of a medical career. One critical issue is the prevalence of implicit bias within educational institutions, which can undermine the confidence and performance of marginalized students. Implicit biases often lead to lower expectations from faculty, creating a self-fulfilling prophecy that impacts the educational experience of these students. The authors advocate for a more conscious effort to mitigate these biases through targeted training and policy reforms within medical schools.
Furthermore, the findings of the review highlight the need for structural changes within the curricula and pedagogical approaches of medical education. By integrating concepts of diversity and inclusion into the core curriculum, medical schools can foster an environment that not only acknowledges but celebrates the diverse backgrounds of students. This approach can promote empathy, cultural competence, and an understanding of social determinants of health, which are vital in addressing health disparities in the community.
Interventions that have proven effective in supporting professional identity formation among underrepresented groups include mentorship programs, community engagement initiatives, and peer support networks. The authors of the review found that mentorship, in particular, can play an instrumental role in helping students navigate the challenges of medical school. By connecting students with mentors who understand their unique struggles, institutions can facilitate a sense of belonging and validation, which enhances students’ resilience and confidence.
Another noteworthy finding from the review is the importance of experiential learning opportunities. Engaging with diverse patient populations through clinical placements and community service can help students acquire critical skills while also solidifying their professional identity. These real-world experiences enable students to contextualize their learning, challenge stereotypes, and foster a deeper understanding of the disparities within healthcare systems.
The implementation of educational interventions requires a collaborative approach among faculty, administration, and students. Effective strategies should not only involve curriculum changes but also institutional policies that prioritize diversity and inclusion at all levels. It is imperative that medical schools cultivate a culture of accountability, where institutions are held responsible for promoting equity and supporting underrepresented groups throughout their training.
In conclusion, the systematic scoping review conducted by Abdi, Sooudi, and Milota serves as a crucial contribution to the discourse on professional identity formation in medical education. By identifying the challenges faced by underrepresented groups and elucidating potential interventions, the authors provide a roadmap for medical schools aiming to foster inclusive learning environments. Addressing these issues is not merely an ethical responsibility but a necessity for the future of healthcare, ensuring that the medical workforce is reflective of and responsive to the diverse populations it serves.
The conversation on professional identity in medicine is ongoing, and the insights garnered from this review will hopefully stimulate further research and discussion. As the landscape of medical education evolves, it is vital that institutions remain vigilant in addressing the inequities that persist, ensuring that every aspiring physician has the opportunity to form a strong and positive professional identity.
By confronting the systemic challenges highlighted in this review and implementing meaningful interventions, medical schools can take significant strides towards a more equitable future in healthcare, ultimately benefiting all practitioners and patients alike.
Subject of Research: Professional identity formation for underrepresented groups in medicine.
Article Title: Professional identity formation for underrepresented groups in medicine: challenges and interventions for Dutch medical schools: a systematic scoping review.
Article References:
Abdi, M., Sooudi, O.K. & Milota, M. Professional identity formation for underrepresented groups in medicine: challenges and interventions for Dutch medical schools: a systematic scoping review.
BMC Med Educ (2025). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12909-025-07811-6
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI:
Keywords: professional identity formation, underrepresented groups, medical education, diversity, inclusion, mentorship, healthcare disparities
