A comprehensive bibliometric and qualitative content analysis mapping academic literature across sixteen years has established that scholarly inquiry into Web 3.0 marketing has undergone an evolutionary transition from technical infrastructure toward decentralized consumer experiences. Conducted by researchers Evgenia Gimelshtein, Ilan Alon, Berger Ron, and Shalom Levy, the investigation systematically examined 121 peer-reviewed publications and conference proceedings drawn from the Web of Science Core Collection spanning from 2009 through 2025. By applying performance analysis alongside network science mapping tools including Bibliometrix, VOSviewer, and CitNetExplorer, the authors traced how scholarship moved beyond the mathematical mechanics of ledger security into relational governance, consumer psychology, and immersive digital platforms.
The methodological framework of the review adhered strictly to Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses guidelines to extract, screen, and pool relevant documents. An initial Topic search executed in September 2025 returned 1,237 bibliographic records across marketing and decentralized technology terms. Following iterative calibration and screening against predefined criteria, the authors excluded 1,116 records that either focused entirely on technical computer science without commercial application, mentioned search terms only in passing, prioritized standalone artificial intelligence, or evaluated immersive tools operating exclusively within centralized Web 2.0 architectures. Full-text assessments retained a final corpus of 121 documents, comprising 90 articles, 19 conference proceedings, 7 review articles, 4 editorial items, and 1 book review across 88 publishing outlets.
Publication trajectories identified through Bibliometrix software indicated that scholarly production remained minimal from 2009 to 2020, consistently generating fewer than ten papers per year. To explore the intellectual organization underlying this sudden expansion, the researchers executed co-citation and keyword co-occurrence analyses, uncovering three delimited thematic clusters that define the developmental stages of the emerging discipline.
The first thematic domain captured by the study focuses on the foundational operational role of blockchain technology within enterprise and digital advertising structures. Early foundational research in this stream, including foundational works by Yli-Huumo and colleagues as well as subsequent extensions by Risius and Spohrer, emphasized technical data protection, operational verification, and the removal of intermediaries from online transactions. Later management scholarship analyzed by the authors demonstrated how these distributed ledgers could be incorporated into marketing technology stacks to mitigate ad fraud, ensure end-to-end supply chain transparency, improve brand safety, and restructure corporate data security protocols without relying on central multi-party intermediaries.
The second thematic cluster identified in the bibliographic mapping acts as a conceptual bridge connecting technical ledger systems to consumer interactions through ethics, trust, and decentralized customer relationship management. Network analysis of co-citations and bibliographic couplings revealed that scholars in this cluster evaluated how immutable transaction records alter the psychological contract between commercial entities and individual users. While distributed ledger transparency is shown to verify authenticity and support fair sharing-economy models, researchers documented persistent managerial tensions regarding consumer privacy safeguards, ethical communications, and the commercial viability of substituting corporate points systems with blockchain-based loyalty mechanisms that grant individuals full ownership of their rewards.
The third and most recent thematic cluster centers on immersive frontend engagement facilitated through the metaverse, non-fungible tokens, and virtual reality platforms. Chronological mapping revealed that while the foundational co-citation networks of early blockchain literature centered around a mean publication year of 2018.4, papers investigating virtual engagement demonstrated an average bibliographic coupling publication year of 2022.7. Scholarship within this domain explores how virtual showrooms, synthetic customer experiences, digital asset ownership, and virtual avatars alter traditional consumer psychology, prompting companies to overhaul legacy promotional campaigns in favor of real-time virtual interaction and gamified brand loyalty.
Beyond structural mapping, the authors completed a qualitative content analysis of 38 central papers to synthesize the theoretical frameworks employed by scholars to explain consumer behavior in decentralized contexts. The investigation found that literature heavily relies on four foundational lenses: the Theory of Planned Behavior, which explains user adoption through attitudes, subjective norms, and perceived behavioral control; Social Exchange Theory, which models reciprocal value exchange between brands and token holders; Stakeholder Theory, which assesses power distributions among creators, platform operators, and consumers; and Value Co-creation Theory, which interprets how shared ownership of digital assets fosters collaborative brand ecosystems.
Despite the commercial momentum surrounding decentralized technologies, the authors identified extensive gaps that constrain managerial implementation and empirical clarity. Future inquiry must establish how consumer behavioral intentions transfer across disparate decentralized platforms, how firms can resolve marketing technology integration friction, and whether gamified emotional engagement with virtual influencers provides sustainable long-term customer retention. Furthermore, the synthesis observed that while Web 3.0 promises decentralized value distribution, modern digital ecosystems remain heavily shaped by dominant technology conglomerates, highlighting an urgent need for research into equitable governance structures, cross-border regulatory compliance, and consumer protection safeguards against psychological manipulation in synthetic spaces.
The researchers also documented clear methodological limitations inherent in their systematic review design. Data collection was restricted to a single repository, the Web of Science Core Collection, which omitted studies indexed exclusively in other databases such as Scopus, and the cutoff date of September 2025 precluded a complete bibliometric assessment of that full calendar year. Additionally, because foundational papers naturally accumulate higher citation volumes over extended timeframes, the network calculations are subject to citation-age bias relative to newer metaverse publications, while the qualitative labeling of clusters and theoretical mapping reflects necessary interpretive synthesis by the study authors.
Ultimately, the synthesis demonstrates that Web 3.0 marketing has evolved systematically through three distinct phases: initial technical validation of blockchain infrastructure, intermediate development of ethical trust frameworks, and experiential deployment in immersive virtual environments. By codifying 121 studies into a structured conceptual framework, the review equips marketing academics and enterprise strategists with a rigorous foundation to navigate operational decentralization, align token economics with consumer trust, and develop responsible governance models for the evolving digital economy.
Beyond aggregate publication totals, the bibliometric extraction provided specific structural details regarding the composition of the research corpus. Across the 121 analyzed works, scholarship represented the contributions of 377 authors writing in three languages, encompassing 118 documents in English, two in Spanish, and one in Portuguese. The literature search protocol was calibrated through five successive development rounds, expanding from an initial query of 34 records into the final Topic string.
The authors configured the science mapping software with exact mathematical thresholds to ensure reproducible cluster boundaries. Executing VOSviewer with association strength normalization, attraction set to two, and repulsion at zero, the team required at least three occurrences for author keywords and Keywords Plus. This criterion isolated 68 qualifying terms out of 659 candidates, initially generating five algorithmic groupings before the two smallest clusters were integrated into the primary metaverse and token stream. Bibliographic coupling applied a two-citation threshold, preserving 73 documents across seven algorithmic groupings that consolidated into three streams. Meanwhile, co-citation mapping retained 29 references meeting a seven-citation threshold, and CitNetExplorer mapped citation paths across 26 metaverse papers without a citation cutoff.
To confirm that the three thematic streams reflected genuine conceptual structures rather than search vocabulary artifacts, researchers performed a sensitivity analysis. They recomputed the keyword network after eliminating 13 core search terms, including blockchain, metaverse, non-fungible token, cryptocurrency, bitcoin, and digital marketing. The recalculation across the remaining 55 keywords reproduced the three clusters without distortion. Retained terms segregated into brand trust, loyalty, purchase intention, and social media in the first cluster; adoption, big data, innovation, and supply chain in the second; and engagement, experience, gamification, and virtual reality in the third, verifying that the topology reflects authentic research streams.
The qualitative content evaluation of 38 central studies also established clear distinctions between explanatory theories, tactical marketing concepts, and technological mechanisms. While behavioral models such as the Theory of Reasoned Action, the Stimulus-Organism-Response framework, and the Theory of Planned Behavior explained individual adoption motives, other publications concentrated strictly on strategic concepts. For example, electronic word of mouth was identified as the focal framework across six central investigations examining social communication dynamics, while four studies formally evaluated the restructuring of the traditional marketing mix. Coding guidelines required authors to have explicitly specified a theoretical framework to be cataloged as theory driven, leading the researchers to designate purely technical architectural contributions as lacking an applicable theoretical framework.
Finally, the review outlined practical managerial imperatives across six operational dimensions to guide commercial deployment. Managers are urged to audit internal marketing technology infrastructure before adopting decentralized systems, ensuring distributed ledgers address specific operational objectives such as supply chain verification while immersive environments enhance frontend consumer interactions. In loyalty management, enterprises should replace passive point accumulation with tokenized structures that confer verifiable asset ownership to consumers. Strategists must also resolve the tension between blockchain transparency and data privacy through strict protective safeguards, leverage virtual influencers and interactive environments for gamified value co-creation, implement equitable governance models that counteract monopolistic data capture, and coordinate proactive legal compliance to navigate unstable international digital asset regulations.
Subject of Research: Bibliometric and content analysis of marketing research within the Web 3.0 ecosystem
Article Title: A bibliometric and content analysis of marketing in Web 3.0
Article References: Gimelshtein, E., Alon, I., Ron, B., & Levy, S. (2026). A bibliometric and content analysis of marketing in Web 3.0. Management & Marketing, 21(1), Article 35. https://doi.org/10.1007/s44491-026-00030-9
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1007/s44491-026-00030-9
Keywords: Web 3.0, digital marketing, blockchain, metaverse, non-fungible tokens, bibliometric analysis, content analysis, PRISMA guidelines, customer relationship management, Theory of Planned Behavior, Social Exchange Theory, Stakeholder Theory, Value Co-creation Theory, VOSviewer, consumer trust, data privacy, gamification
Cite Scienmag News
Austin Grant. (November 19, 2026). Bibliometric Study Maps Shift From Blockchain Infrastructure to Metaverse Marketing. Scienmag. https://scienmag.com/bibliometric-study-maps-shift-from-blockchain-infrastructure-to-metaverse-marketing/
Austin Grant. "Bibliometric Study Maps Shift From Blockchain Infrastructure to Metaverse Marketing." Scienmag, 19 November 2026, https://scienmag.com/bibliometric-study-maps-shift-from-blockchain-infrastructure-to-metaverse-marketing/. Accessed 19 November 2026.
Austin Grant. "Bibliometric Study Maps Shift From Blockchain Infrastructure to Metaverse Marketing." Scienmag. November 19, 2026. https://scienmag.com/bibliometric-study-maps-shift-from-blockchain-infrastructure-to-metaverse-marketing/








