In primary education across Andalusia, Spain, an investigation evaluating 993 Year 5 and Year 6 pupils across 16 schools examined whether school governance types relate to pupils’ self-perceived key competencies and whether positive psychology virtues alter these relationships. Using continuous subscale measures and generalized estimating equations to account for institutional clustering, researchers found selective omnibus associations between school type and three of eight competency self-perceptions: linguistic communication, physical world interaction, and cultural and artistic competency. These findings provide preliminary evidence that while competency self-evaluations vary across sectors, school type does not systematically moderate virtue-competency associations.
The investigation adopted the Positive Development and Assessment Competencies theoretical model, known as PDAC, as its conceptual anchor. Within this framework, competencies are conceptualised as multidimensional, context-dependent combinations of knowledge, attitudes, values, and practical behaviors that foster pupil wellbeing and educational functioning. The PDAC architecture integrates positive psychology, drawing upon Peterson and Seligman’s Values in Action classification system. This taxonomy organizes character strengths into six higher-order virtues: wisdom, courage, humanity, justice, temperance, and transcendence. While PDAC posits that competencies are shaped by contextual settings, the authors treated school type as a distal structural indicator of institutional context to test an empirical extension of PDAC rather than assuming predicted moderation. Previous competence literature largely examined context at the level of specific learning tasks, leaving institutional classifications an unresolved empirical question.
To contextualise the structural classifications analysed in the study, the authors detailed the administrative and financial structure of the Spanish educational system. In this national context, primary education is divided into three distinct school sectors based primarily on governance and funding. Public schools are fully state-funded, administered directly by regional education authorities, and free to attend. State-subsidised private schools, known as colegios concertados, are privately managed but receive public funding through formal agreements with the state, ensuring tuition-free attendance while often maintaining religious or ideological orientations, representing approximately twenty-seven percent of national primary enrolment. Fully private schools operate entirely with private funds, charge tuition fees, and enjoy greater instructional autonomy, representing approximately seven to nine percent of primary enrolment. School type is treated as a structural classification based on governance and funding rather than an exhaustive measure of school climate.
The research sample comprised 993 Year 5 and Year 6 primary school students aged 10 to 13 years old from 16 participating schools across Andalusia, Spain. The broader sampling frame included 3,492 pupils enrolled within these participating institutions. Schools were initially identified through official regional educational records, with school-level participation preceding pupil sampling. Within participating schools, pupils were randomly selected from class registers, establishing random selection at the pupil level without claiming a simple random sample of all Andalusian schools. The final sample included 453 male pupils, 539 female pupils, and one pupil who did not specify gender. Across sectors, 434 pupils attended eight public schools, 471 attended five state-subsidised private schools, and 88 attended three private schools. Private-school pupils were unevenly distributed across the three private schools, comprising 66, 21, and 1 pupil respectively, which limited sector-level precision.
Data collection was conducted between May 2022 and February 2023, during which pupils completed validated questionnaires by hand during regular school hours. Character virtues were measured using the I.V.yF. Niños instrument, adapted and validated for children by Grinhauz and Castro Solano. To measure dependent variables, the research team administered the Perceived Learning Competence Questionnaire for primary students, abbreviated as #ICOMpri1, developed and validated by Meroño and colleagues. The #ICOMpri1 assesses pupil self-perceptions across eight European key competencies: linguistic communication, mathematics, knowledge of and interaction with the physical world, digital competency, social and civic competency, cultural and artistic competency, learning to learn, and personal autonomy. The researchers emphasized that these instruments capture pupils’ subjective evaluations of competence rather than demonstrated performance-based ability, reflecting the multidimensional nature of key competencies combining cognitive, practical, and affective dimensions within applied learning contexts.
Both instruments displayed high overall internal reliability across the sample, with the I.V.yF. Niños yielding an alpha of 0.845 and the #ICOMpri1 achieving an alpha of 0.893. However, several brief individual subscales exhibited modest internal consistency falling below the 0.70 benchmark, such as the humanity virtue subscale at 0.397 and personal autonomy at 0.415. Recognizing that alpha is sensitive to scale length, the researchers calculated mean inter-item correlations, reporting values from 0.174 to 0.341 across virtues and 0.191 to 0.477 across competencies. To evaluate continuous subscale scores while accounting for the nesting of pupils within sixteen schools, researchers used generalized estimating equations with a Gaussian identity link, an exchangeable working correlation, and a bias-reduced covariance estimator to prevent small-cluster bias. All primary models adjusted for available pupil-level demographic variables: sex, grade, and grade repetition history.
In primary continuous-score models adjusting for sex, grade, and grade repetition, omnibus Wald tests for school type remained statistically significant after Benjamini-Hochberg false discovery rate correction for three outcomes. Linguistic communication showed a significant omnibus sector association with a corrected q-value of 0.001, where private pupils scored 0.478 points higher than public pupils and state-subsidised pupils scored 0.274 points higher than public pupils. Knowledge of and interaction with the physical world demonstrated an omnibus association with a q-value of 0.044, where private pupils scored 0.473 points higher than public pupils, while the state-subsidised contrast was not significant. Cultural and artistic competency also showed an omnibus association with a q-value of 0.009, reflecting a 0.270-point higher score among private pupils compared to public pupils, with no significant difference for state-subsidised schools. Across models, public schools served as the reference category.
Omnibus school-type tests did not remain statistically significant after false discovery rate correction for the remaining five competencies: mathematics, digital competency, social and civic competency, learning to learn, and personal autonomy and initiative. Furthermore, when researchers conducted a sensitivity analysis adding all six virtue scores simultaneously as covariates, school-type associations attenuated across the board. In this adjusted analysis of 904 complete cases, only linguistic communication retained an omnibus association surviving multiple-testing correction, with a q-value of 0.033, showing a private-public coefficient of 0.292 points and a state-subsidised-public coefficient of 0.201 points. This widespread attenuation across competency domains indicated that observed sector differences should not be attributed directly to institutional classification alone.
The researchers conducted an additional sensitivity analysis using the original high versus not-high outcome classification, defined as scoring more than one standard deviation above the sample mean. In binomial-logit generalized estimating equations adjusting for school clustering and student demographics, the proportion classified as high ranged from 10.4 percent to 24.3 percent across dimensions. Although private pupils showed higher odds of high linguistic self-perception relative to public pupils with an odds ratio of 3.36, no omnibus school-type test survived false discovery rate correction across the eight binary outcomes. Notably, this cluster-adjusted analysis revised earlier interpretations regarding digital competency. An apparent state-subsidised advantage observed in prior unadjusted single-level analyses failed to reach significance in cluster-robust continuous models.
Regarding their second research question, the authors examined whether relationships between the six positive psychology virtues and pupils’ self-perceived competencies varied across school types. To evaluate these forty-eight potential interaction tests, models incorporated grand-mean-centred virtue scores and twelve interaction terms between school type and virtues. Following Benjamini-Hochberg correction, not a single school-type-by-virtue interaction survived multiplicity adjustment. The smallest raw p-value appeared for the school-type-by-temperance interaction in cultural and artistic competency at 0.003, but its adjusted q-value was 0.123. The corresponding private school interaction coefficient of negative 0.447 was therefore designated strictly as exploratory. Pearson correlations between virtue and competency subscales ranged between 0.232 and 0.552, demonstrating substantive positive relationships without indicating construct redundancy.
The authors highlighted several critical methodological limitations that restrict the interpretative scope of the study. Most importantly, the investigation relied on a cross-sectional, observational design, preventing any inferences regarding causality or directionality. Furthermore, student enrolment across public, subsidised, and private sectors in Spain is non-random, introducing potential selection bias from unmeasured family background characteristics. Crucial variables including household socioeconomic status, parental educational attainment, family resources, admissions processes, and prior academic achievement were unavailable in the dataset. Statistical precision was further constrained by the inclusion of only three private schools with highly unequal cluster sizes. Additionally, the dependent variables captured self-reported competency perceptions rather than objective demonstrations of academic performance. Finally, modest internal consistency across several short subscales may have introduced measurement error, meaning observed differences should be interpreted cautiously as descriptive, hypothesis-generating patterns rather than institutional causal effects.
Subject of Research: Institutional school types, character virtues, and pupil self-perceived key competencies
Article Title: Extending the PDAC framework to examine associations between school type and character virtues and pupil perceptions of key competencies
Article References: Gil Ortega, M., Vazquez-Marin, P., & Sandoval-Hernández, A. (2026). Extending the PDAC framework to examine associations between school type and character virtues and pupil perceptions of key competencies. Discover Education, 5(1), Article 1306. https://doi.org/10.1007/s44217-026-02359-z
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1007/s44217-026-02359-z
Keywords: primary education, school type, key competencies, character virtues, PDAC framework, positive psychology, generalized estimating equations, educational research, Extending, PDAC, framework, examine
Cite Scienmag News
Courtney Benton. (November 11, 2026). School Types and Character Virtues Linked to Primary Student Competency Perceptions. Scienmag. https://scienmag.com/school-types-and-character-virtues-linked-to-primary-student-competency-perceptions/
Courtney Benton. "School Types and Character Virtues Linked to Primary Student Competency Perceptions." Scienmag, 11 November 2026, https://scienmag.com/school-types-and-character-virtues-linked-to-primary-student-competency-perceptions/. Accessed 17 November 2026.
Courtney Benton. "School Types and Character Virtues Linked to Primary Student Competency Perceptions." Scienmag. November 11, 2026. https://scienmag.com/school-types-and-character-virtues-linked-to-primary-student-competency-perceptions/








