As our planet steadily warms under the influence of anthropogenic climate change, ecosystems worldwide are undergoing profound transformations. Among these changes, shifts in phenology—the timing of biological events such as flowering, leaf-out, or microbial respiration—are particularly significant because they can reshape the intricate balance of life’s seasonal rhythms. While numerous studies have documented alterations in plant phenology in response to rising temperatures, the extent to which soil microorganisms, critical drivers of belowground ecological processes, synchronize or diverge in their phenological shifts compared to plants remains poorly understood. A groundbreaking new global synthesis led by Wang et al. sheds light on this crucial aspect, revealing a striking divergence in the phenological responses of plants and soil microbes to climate warming, a discovery with far-reaching implications for terrestrial ecosystem function.
Warming-induced changes in phenology have ripple effects that transcend individual species, affecting interactions among organisms and altering energy and nutrient flows through ecosystems. Historically, research has emphasized aboveground phenological responses, such as the earlier onset of flowering or leaf emergence observed in many plant species as temperatures climb. However, terrestrial ecosystems are composed of interconnected above- and belowground components, where soil microorganisms play pivotal roles in carbon and nutrient cycling by decomposing organic matter and modulating soil respiration. Understanding whether these belowground organisms adjust their biological clocks in tandem with plants, or on independent trajectories, is critical to comprehending how ecosystem processes will unfold under continued global warming.
The study by Wang and colleagues synthesizes an unprecedented collection of 1,032 phenological observations from experimental warming studies conducted across diverse biomes worldwide. This comprehensive dataset includes measurements of shifts in soil microbial respiration alongside changes in the phenology of plant shoots and roots under controlled warming scenarios. By analyzing these data, the researchers uncovered a consistent pattern: soil microorganisms displayed more pronounced advances in their spring phenology and greater delays in autumn phenology than plants. This asynchronous phenological adjustment suggests a fundamental decoupling between the timing of aboveground and belowground biological activities under warming conditions.
Intriguingly, the magnitude of this phenological mismatch varied across vegetation types. In ecosystems dominated by tall vegetation such as forests, soil microbial phenology shifted considerably more than plant phenology, compared to ecosystems characterized by low vegetation like grasslands. This finding highlights how structural complexity and vegetation height may influence microclimatic conditions, thereby differentially affecting microbial and plant responses to warming. The denser canopies and thicker litter layers in forested systems could buffer soil microbes from temperature extremes or alter moisture regimes, amplifying their phenological shifts relative to plants occupying more open environments.
Another dimension of this phenological divergence relates to soil properties, particularly the carbon-to-nitrogen (C:N) ratio, a critical factor governing microbial nutrient availability and metabolic activity. Soils with higher C:N ratios, commonly found in boreal and temperate regions, exhibited more substantial mismatches between microbial and plant phenology than soils with lower ratios. Elevated C:N ratios typically correlate with slower organic matter decomposition and nutrient cycling, potentially sensitizing microbial communities to warming-induced temporal adjustments in substrate availability. This interplay suggests that ecosystem-level nutrient dynamics can modulate how biotic components synchronize—or fail to synchronize—their seasonal biological functions.
The consequences of this phenological asynchrony extend beyond mere changes in timing. Temporal mismatches between plants and soil microorganisms can unravel the delicate synchrony that underpins nutrient uptake, carbon cycling, and energy transfer within terrestrial ecosystems. If soil microbes become active earlier in spring and remain active later into autumn relative to plants, the decoupling could lead to inefficiencies in the flow of carbon and nutrients. For instance, microbes might decompose organic matter and release nutrients before plants have fully developed their absorptive tissues, leading to periods of nutrient loss or altered soil carbon sequestration dynamics. Over time, these disruptions may destabilize ecosystem productivity and resilience.
Moreover, this study challenges previous notions that plant and microbial phenologies are tightly coupled due to their interdependence. By demonstrating a divergent response to climate warming, Wang and colleagues reveal that aboveground and belowground organisms may be operating under fundamentally different environmental cues or physiological constraints. For example, soil temperature and moisture regimes, which directly influence microbial metabolism, may respond to warming differently from ambient air temperatures that primarily affect plant growth cycles. This decoupling raises important questions about the ability of terrestrial ecosystems to maintain stable functioning amid ongoing climate change.
From a methodological perspective, the use of experimental warming manipulations across a globally distributed network strengthens the robustness of these findings. By controlling temperature increases while monitoring phenological events in situ, the researchers could isolate temperature effects from confounding environmental variables. Such experimental precision, combined with the breadth of ecosystems studied, lends strong confidence to the observed patterns of phenological divergence. This large-scale empirical approach represents a significant advance over localized or observational studies that may be influenced by site-specific variables.
The implications of these findings resonate with concerns about the sustainability of ecosystem services under climate change. As plants represent primary producers supporting food webs, and soil microbes drive decomposition and nutrient mineralization, disconnects in their seasonal timing could impinge on carbon storage, soil fertility, and ultimately agricultural productivity. In boreal forests, for instance, where high soil C:N ratios prevail, amplified phenological mismatches may exacerbate carbon release from soils, feeding back into the climate system and potentially accelerating warming trends.
Looking forward, this study underscores the urgent need to integrate belowground microbial processes into predictive models of ecosystem response to climate change. Traditional phenological models often emphasize aboveground indicators such as leaf-out or flowering times, potentially overlooking critical microbial contributions and their unique sensitivity to climatic variables. Incorporating microbial phenology into Earth system models will enhance our capacity to forecast carbon cycling dynamics and ecosystem resilience under future scenarios of warming and altered precipitation regimes.
Furthermore, the recognition of differential phenological responses invites a deeper investigation into the physiological mechanisms governing soil microbial activity. Factors such as substrate availability, enzymatic adaptations, and microbial community composition may modulate how microbes track seasonal environmental changes. Understanding these underlying processes could reveal targets for mitigating the impacts of phenological mismatches and preserving ecosystem function.
In sum, the pioneering work by Wang et al. reveals that climate warming is driving a disruptive divergence in the seasonal rhythms of soil microorganisms and plants, reshaping the temporal blueprint of terrestrial ecosystems worldwide. This uncoupling threatens to destabilize fundamental ecological processes by fragmenting the coordination between above- and belowground biological activity. As climate change accelerates, recognizing and addressing these subtle yet pervasive shifts will be crucial for safeguarding the integrity and functioning of ecosystems upon which human well-being depends.
This research not only redefines our understanding of phenological responses across trophic levels but also spotlights the complexity of ecological interactions under stress. It urges scientists, land managers, and policy makers to consider both visible plant responses and the often-hidden microbial dynamics when devising strategies to adapt to and mitigate climate change impacts.
The global scope and integrative nature of this study offer a powerful testament to the value of international collaboration and data sharing in unraveling the intricate effects of climate change on the biosphere. By illuminating the asynchronous dance of plants and microbes in warming worlds, Wang and colleagues provide a vital piece of the puzzle toward predicting and managing ecosystem futures in an era of rapid environmental change.
Subject of Research: Phenological responses of soil microorganisms and plants to climate warming and their ecological consequences
Article Title: Divergent phenological responses of soil microorganisms and plants to climate warming
Article References:
Wang, H., Zhou, H., He, J.S. et al. Divergent phenological responses of soil microorganisms and plants to climate warming. Nat. Geosci. (2025). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41561-025-01738-9
Image Credits: AI Generated