In an experimental investigation evaluating training environments for live esports production, researchers found that immersive virtual reality significantly improved procedural task execution compared with standard desktop interfaces, while targeted gamification features increased learner engagement without yielding comparable gains in task accuracy or conceptual knowledge. Conducted with one hundred twenty undergraduate participants at Chiang Mai University, the study examined how interface modalities and motivational scaffolds operate within complex, technology-intensive training domains. Trainees assigned to virtual reality simulations achieved higher overall completion scores and committed substantially fewer operational errors during multi-step production exercises than those using personal computer setups. However, when examining conceptual knowledge acquired across the training curriculum, knowledge gains from pre-test to post-test rose across all experimental groups without demonstrating statistically significant differences between interface modalities or gamification conditions, indicating that immersive environments primarily enhance hands-on procedural coordination rather than abstract factual recall.
The rapid professionalization and structural expansion of the global competitive gaming ecosystem have generated acute demand for specialized technical crews capable of orchestrating complex live broadcasting workflows, dynamic lighting configurations, audio routing, and real-time media management. Despite this industry growth, formal educational pathways for esports event operations remain scarce, leaving novice technicians predominantly reliant on informal apprenticeship and unstructured on-the-job practice. Authentic live broadcast setups entail expensive physical consoles and delicate broadcast gear that cannot easily be made available for repeated instructional rehearsals without risking costly disruptions during commercial broadcasts. To surmount these physical and financial limitations, educators have turned toward simulation-based digital twins capable of replicating professional venues, offering scalable environments where trainees can practice demanding procedural interventions repeatedly and safely without commercial hardware constraints.
To evaluate these emerging instructional strategies within a controlled empirical framework, the research team designed an experimental digital twin modeled directly after the Northern Region Esports Learning Center at Chiang Mai University. This operational facility incorporates a full competition stage, audience seating arrays, large-scale video displays, and dedicated production control consoles for audio mixing, lighting control, and broadcast monitoring. The simulated digital twin captured the precise spatial layout and functional systems of this live venue, allowing trainees to interact with three core operational subsystems across nine scenario-based procedural challenges. Tasks were systematically sequenced from single-system adjustments, such as correcting stage visibility or switching mismatched audio feeds, to advanced cross-system troubleshooting, including synchronizing live commentary streams, realigning camera perspectives to match live match flows, and reordering interrupted broadcast feeds. The operational content, structural sequence, and time allocations were held identical across conditions, isolating the specific contributions of the interface modality and the motivational layer.
The study deployed a two-by-two factorial design comparing two distinct interaction modalities alongside two instructional motivation configurations. Participants were randomly assigned to one of four balanced experimental cohorts: desktop personal computer without gamification, desktop personal computer with gamification, immersive virtual reality without gamification, or immersive virtual reality with gamification. In the desktop interface conditions, trainees engaged with two-dimensional software dashboards and symbolic control panels via conventional computer mouse and keyboard peripherals. In contrast, participants assigned to the virtual reality modality operated standalone head-mounted displays paired with tracked handheld motion controllers, maneuvering within a three-dimensional spatial representation where they physically reached for, adjusted, and manipulated broadcast consoles, lighting switchboards, and audio channel sliders through direct embodied interaction.
Alongside the hardware manipulation, the researchers evaluated a focused gamification architecture engineered to scaffold learner performance without introducing extraneous cognitive distractions or real-time pressure. The gamification treatment integrated explicit goal-oriented missions that outlined clear operational criteria for each scenario, accompanied by a post-task comparative leaderboard displaying relative performance outcomes upon completion. Goal-oriented missions provided immediate clarity regarding operational criteria, steering trainees away from arbitrary trial-and-error behaviors and directing attention toward structured procedural pathways. Meanwhile, the post-task leaderboard acted as a reflective mechanism, enabling trainees to contextualize their execution efficiency against peers without inducing competitive time pressure during active system operations. Control groups completed the identical procedural scenarios within their assigned interface modality but proceeded without mission roadmaps or comparative performance rankings.
The experimental protocol progressed through three distinct phases spanning more than two hours of structured activity. Trainees first completed a ten-minute orientation introducing the esports venue and its primary subsystems, followed immediately by a twenty-item conceptual pre-test assessing foundational knowledge of broadcast roles, signal flows, and console architectures. After receiving a brief five-minute tutorial covering their assigned hardware interface, participants undertook the nine scenario-based production tasks over an intensive training period lasting approximately one hundred twenty minutes. Each participant was permitted up to five successive attempts per task to stabilize procedural execution. Automated data logging recorded operational errors, including incorrect component selections, faulty sequences, and misrouted signals, alongside task completion rates. Immediately after concluding the training tasks, participants completed an identical twenty-item knowledge post-test, together with standardized psychometric evaluations using the User Engagement Scale Short Form and the Igroup Presence Questionnaire.
The empirical findings revealed marked divergences across cognitive, experiential, and behavioral outcomes. On the behavioral measures of task execution, virtual reality demonstrated a pronounced advantage over desktop computing. Trainees in the non-gamified virtual reality group achieved a mean completion score of 82.20 percent with a standard deviation of 7.02, while those in the gamified virtual reality cohort attained 83.40 percent with a standard deviation of 10.14. By contrast, participants utilizing the desktop interface achieved mean completion scores of 72.16 percent with a standard deviation of 7.82 in the non-gamified condition and 75.06 percent with a standard deviation of 6.35 in the gamified condition. Inferential two-way analysis of variance confirmed a statistically significant main effect of interface modality on completion scores, yielding an F ratio of 39.88 with p less than .001 and a partial eta squared of .256. Conversely, the main effect of gamification on completion scores was not statistically significant, producing an F ratio of 1.99 with p equal to .161, and no significant interaction emerged between interface modality and gamification.
A corresponding pattern appeared in operational error frequencies logged during task execution. Participants practicing in virtual reality recorded substantially fewer execution mistakes, averaging 3.86 errors with a standard deviation of 1.92 under non-gamified training and 3.76 errors with a standard deviation of 1.71 under gamified training. Desktop participants incurred noticeably higher error counts, averaging 5.30 errors with a standard deviation of 1.51 in the non-gamified group and 5.26 errors with a standard deviation of 1.76 in the gamified group. Statistical analysis confirmed that interface modality exerted a significant main effect on error reduction, reflected by an F ratio of 21.45 with p less than .001 and a partial eta squared of .156. In sharp contrast, gamification showed no significant influence on error mitigation, registering an F ratio of .04 with p equal to .834, and the interaction between interface and gamification remained nonsignificant at an F ratio of .01 with p equal to .916.
Experiential evaluations showed that both interface immersion and gamification significantly altered trainee psychological states, but they influenced distinct experiential dimensions. Subjective presence, assessed across spatial presence, involvement, and experienced realism, was decisively driven by hardware modality. Trainees in the virtual reality cohorts reported mean presence ratings of 3.76 with a standard deviation of .67 in the non-gamified condition and 4.03 with a standard deviation of .80 in the gamified condition, whereas desktop participants reported mean scores of 3.06 with a standard deviation of .63 and 3.13 with a standard deviation of .62, respectively. Analysis of variance yielded a significant main effect for interface modality on presence, showing an F ratio of 40.01 with p less than .001 and a partial eta squared of .256. Gamification, however, did not significantly impact presence ratings, producing an F ratio of 1.74 with p equal to .190, nor did the interaction between interface and gamification reach significance.
User engagement scores, reflecting focused attention, perceived usability, aesthetic appeal, and perceived reward, responded positively to both experimental interventions. Engagement scores rose progressively from 3.16 with a standard deviation of .64 in the non-gamified desktop group to 3.40 with a standard deviation of .49 in the gamified desktop group, 3.73 with a standard deviation of .69 in the non-gamified virtual reality cohort, and 4.16 with a standard deviation of .64 in the gamified virtual reality condition. Statistical analysis revealed significant main effects for both interface modality, with an F ratio of 34.07, p less than .001, and partial eta squared of .227, and gamification, with an F ratio of 8.52, p equal to .004, and partial eta squared of .068. The interaction between interface and gamification was not statistically significant, indicating that immersive spatial displays and structured motivational features provided independent, additive boosts to overall trainee engagement.
Despite the substantial gains observed in procedural execution and subjective engagement, cognitive evaluations demonstrated that neither interface modality nor gamification significantly magnified conceptual learning gains. Pre-test scores ranged from a mean of 6.50 to 7.03 across groups, while post-test scores rose to between 12.06 and 13.73, producing mean knowledge gains of 5.56 for non-gamified desktop, 5.73 for gamified desktop, 6.86 for non-gamified virtual reality, and 6.40 for gamified virtual reality. A linear mixed-effects model accounting for repeated measures confirmed a significant baseline increase in knowledge over time across all participants, evidenced by a significant time coefficient with beta equal to 5.560, standard error of .642, t equal to 8.665, and p less than .001. However, interaction terms testing differential improvement yielded no significant effects: the time by modality interaction produced beta equal to 1.310, t equal to 1.444, and p equal to .149; the time by gamification interaction yielded beta equal to .180, t equal to .198, and p equal to .843; and the three-way interaction produced beta equal to negative .650, t equal to negative .507, and p equal to .613.
Interpreted through the Cognitive-Affective Model of Immersive Learning and Cognitive Load Theory, these findings illuminate the functional boundaries of immersive technologies in technical workforce education. Virtual reality excels in facilitating embodied cognition, where direct physical manipulation and authentic spatial alignment allow learners to master motor routines and monitor visual layouts intuitively, directly improving real-time procedural performance. Nevertheless, heightened sensory richness and complex interactive inputs can elevate cognitive demands, which may restrict working memory resources available for assimilating abstract conceptual frameworks without explicit instructional guidance. Similarly, while lightweight gamification features successfully heighten learner motivation and focused attention, motivation alone cannot compensate for missing spatial cues when navigating intricate physical equipment configurations. The authors conclude that optimal simulation-based training environments require a balanced instructional design, pairing immersive spatial interactions for motor execution with structured pedagogical explanations and explicit reflection strategies to support durable conceptual comprehension.
Subject of Research: Comparative effects of virtual reality interfaces and gamification on procedural performance, engagement, and conceptual learning in esports simulation training
Article Title: Effects of interface modality and gamification on learning, engagement, and performance in simulation-based training
Article References: Intawong, K., Thongthip, P., Worragin, P., Ariya, P., & Puritat, K. (2026). Effects of interface modality and gamification on learning, engagement, and performance in simulation-based training. Computers & Education: X Reality, 9, Article 100185. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cexr.2026.100185
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1016/j.cexr.2026.100185
Keywords: virtual reality simulation, esports event production, interface modality, educational gamification, procedural task performance, user engagement scale, igroup presence questionnaire, cognitive load theory, embodied cognition, digital twin training, simulation-based learning, vocational training technology, linear mixed effects model, technical skill acquisition, broadcast production education, chiang mai university
Cite Scienmag News
Denise Maddox. (November 22, 2026). Virtual Reality Outperforms Desktop Interfaces in Procedural Simulation Training for Esports. Scienmag. https://scienmag.com/virtual-reality-outperforms-desktop-interfaces-in-procedural-simulation-training-for-esports/
Denise Maddox. "Virtual Reality Outperforms Desktop Interfaces in Procedural Simulation Training for Esports." Scienmag, 22 November 2026, https://scienmag.com/virtual-reality-outperforms-desktop-interfaces-in-procedural-simulation-training-for-esports/. Accessed 22 November 2026.
Denise Maddox. "Virtual Reality Outperforms Desktop Interfaces in Procedural Simulation Training for Esports." Scienmag. November 22, 2026. https://scienmag.com/virtual-reality-outperforms-desktop-interfaces-in-procedural-simulation-training-for-esports/








