Explaining fundamental concepts of quantum physics substantially increases public interest in quantum technology, while characterizing the field as mysterious or enigmatic does not appear to hinder audience engagement, according to a randomized controlled experiment conducted with a representative sample of adults in the Netherlands. Engaging non-specialist audiences with emerging quantum technologies has historically presented notable challenges for researchers and communicators, primarily because the theoretical principles that govern quantum phenomena depart radically from ordinary, day-to-day human experiences. In a study published in the journal EPJ Quantum Technology, researchers led by Aletta L. Meinsma evaluated how distinct communicative presentations—specifically enigmatic framing, explanatory concept framing, and treatments highlighting benefits, risks, or both—influence four distinct dimensions of public engagement: information seeking, internal efficacy, general interest, and perceived knowledge.
The investigation addressed an urgent practical dilemma within modern science communication, where quantum technologies are increasingly envisioned to bring far-reaching societal impacts. On the positive side, anticipated advances include accelerating drug discovery to save or extend human lives, providing secure communications resilient against hacking threats, and detecting subsurface geological hazards through high-precision sensing. Conversely, significant concerns accompany these innovations, ranging from the potential misuse of quantum computational power by criminal networks to structural inequalities that could arise if access is concentrated exclusively among wealthy nations and elite institutions, effectively denying broader populations equitable participation in technological benefits. Engaging citizens during the early development phase of the technology provides developers and policymakers with clearer insights into community priorities, supports democratic participation, and helps mitigate public opposition, yet non-specialists frequently feel underqualified to join technical discussions.
To rigorously evaluate how different narrative choices shape public perceptions, the research team designed an experimental survey using a 2 by 2 by 4 between-subjects factorial design, administering unique conditions across sixteen distinct experimental treatments. The first factor systematically tested the enigmatic frame by either including or omitting the explicit descriptor raadselachtig, meaning enigmatic or puzzling in Dutch, when referring to quantum mechanics. The second factor examined the explanation frame using a message sampling methodology, wherein participants in the explanatory condition were randomly exposed to accessible descriptions of one of three core principles—superposition, entanglement, or contextuality—presented in two distinct explanatory formats derived from common Dutch newspaper coverage, while avoiding alienating technical jargon. The third factor varied the thematic presentation of prospective societal outcomes across four levels: a frame highlighting health-related benefits, a frame focused on security risks, a balanced frame simultaneously describing both benefits and risks, or a baseline condition presenting neither.
The study recruited an initial cohort of 649 Dutch-speaking adults through the independent survey research organisation KiesKompas, establishing a sample designed to mirror the demographic composition of the Netherlands across age, gender, and educational attainment. The preregistered experimental protocol received formal ethical approval from the Ethics Review Committee of the Faculty of Science at Leiden University. Prior to analysis, researchers implemented quality screening by excluding twelve participants who completed the survey in ninety seconds or less—well below the median completion time of three minutes and eighteen seconds—on the assumption that their responses were not thoughtfully considered. The final analytical sample comprised 637 adults, including 394 men and 243 women, with a mean age of 57.53 years and a standard deviation of 15.98 years. Educational attainment within the cohort spanned 110 participants reporting low formal education, 260 reporting an average level, 265 reporting high educational attainment, and two individuals who did not specify.
To ensure demographic fidelity, the investigators applied post-stratification survey weights based on national distributions for age, gender, and education, trimming weighting values at the ninety-eighth percentile to restrict the influence of statistical outliers. Engagement was measured across four distinct psychological dimensions using an adapted multi-item five-point Likert scale, ranging from strongly disagree to strongly agree. Reliability analyses demonstrated high internal consistency across the measurement scales: information seeking, measuring future intentions to seek out quantum technology information, showed a Cronbach’s alpha of 0.94 across three items; internal efficacy, assessing participants’ beliefs in their own ability to understand and process quantum technology information, showed an alpha of 0.859 across four items; and general interest yielded an alpha of 0.892 across six items. For perceived knowledge, which originally exhibited low internal consistency across four items, a leave-one-out psychometric procedure identified an optimized three-item scale with a Cronbach’s alpha of 0.848.
Multiple linear regression analyses utilizing dummy variables and a Bonferroni-adjusted significance threshold of p less than 0.0125 revealed that providing an explanation of underlying quantum principles served as a statistically significant positive contributor to general interest. Specifically, participants exposed to an explanatory description scored an average of 1.171 points higher on the general interest scale than those in conditions that omitted theoretical explanations, a robust finding supported by an unstandardized regression coefficient b of 1.171 and a p-value of 0.004. Explanations of phenomena such as particles occupying superpositions of states, entangled particles sharing collective properties, or the contextual measurement dependencies of quantum states did not significantly alter participants’ internal efficacy, information seeking, or perceived knowledge, but successfully heightened curiosity without alienating readers.
In contrast to theoretical expectations articulated in earlier science communication literature, introducing the enigmatic frame produced no statistically significant shifts across any of the four engagement dimensions. Prior scholarly critiques had suggested that portraying quantum mechanics as mysterious or spooky might discourage non-specialists by reinforcing the belief that laypeople could never acquire the knowledge necessary to contribute to societal dialogues. Although respondents who read statements describing quantum theory as enigmatic recorded marginally lower raw scores across all four outcome metrics, these differences failed to reach statistical significance. The authors observed that while a single exposure to the label did not demonstrably suppress engagement, questions remain regarding whether repeated or cumulative public exposure to enigmatic phrasing in mass media could produce compounding disincentives over longer periods.
The evaluation of thematic impact frames demonstrated that emphasizing the positive societal contributions of quantum technology significantly improved public confidence in comprehending the field. Exposure to the benefit frame was a statistically significant contributor to participants’ internal efficacy, yielding a regression estimate b of 1.060 with a p-value of 0.011. Presenting concrete applications, such as medical advancements in drug discovery, appeared to clarify the personal relevance of abstract physics, helping non-specialists feel more capable of engaging with the technological domain. Conversely, exposure to the risk frame alone did not produce statistically significant main effects on any measured dimension of engagement, aligning with predictions that citizens in early developmental phases experience neither acute information insufficiency nor substantial social pressure to master risk parameters.
When participants encountered both prospective benefits and hazards concurrently within the balanced frame, their self-reported perceived knowledge declined significantly compared to groups presented exclusively with benefit or risk narratives. The regression model revealed a statistically significant negative coefficient of b equal to negative 1.040 with a p-value of 0.011 for perceived knowledge among participants receiving balanced messages. The authors reasoned that encountering conflicting societal outcomes may introduce psychological ambivalence, prompting individuals to become more circumspect or doubtful regarding their actual mastery of quantum technology. Furthermore, multivariate analysis of variance evaluating an omnibus linear combination of all four engagement variables confirmed that only the explanation condition exerted a statistically significant overall effect across the entire engagement profile, yielding a Pillai’s trace of 0.028 with an F-statistic of 4.491 and a p-value of 0.001.
The authors identified several methodological boundaries, noting that the controlled online experiment relied on self-reported survey metrics rather than direct behavioral measurements, such as tracking whether participants actively clicked external links to obtain additional literature. Furthermore, the sampling was restricted to Dutch-speaking adults residing in the Netherlands, a country with specific strategic investments in quantum research as outlined in its National Agenda Quantum Technology, suggesting the need for cross-cultural replications. Despite finding that balanced framing caused a measurable drop in perceived knowledge scores, the researchers emphasized that the ethical necessity of fostering comprehensive public dialogue regarding emerging risks and benefits outweighs short-term decreases in perceived comprehension, ultimately advising science communicators to demystify technical mechanisms, highlight meaningful benefits, and maintain transparent discussions of associated societal risks.
Subject of Research: Experimental evaluation of framing effects on non-specialist engagement with quantum technology
Article Title: The effect of frames on engagement with quantum technology
Article References: Meinsma, A. L., Albers, C. J., Vermaas, P., Smeets, I., & Cramer, J. (2026). The effect of frames on engagement with quantum technology. EPJ Quantum Technology, 13(1), Article 88. https://doi.org/10.1140/epjqt/s40507-026-00549-0
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1140/epjqt/s40507-026-00549-0
Keywords: quantum technology, science communication, framing effects, public engagement, explanation frame, enigmatic frame, benefit frame, risk frame, balanced frame, internal efficacy, general interest, perceived knowledge, information seeking, superposition, entanglement, contextuality, KiesKompas survey
Cite Scienmag News
Katie Riggs. (November 21, 2026). Explaining Quantum Physics Concepts Boosts Public Interest While Enigmatic Descriptions Show No Effect. Scienmag. https://scienmag.com/explaining-quantum-physics-concepts-boosts-public-interest-while-enigmatic-descriptions-show-no-effect/
Katie Riggs. "Explaining Quantum Physics Concepts Boosts Public Interest While Enigmatic Descriptions Show No Effect." Scienmag, 21 November 2026, https://scienmag.com/explaining-quantum-physics-concepts-boosts-public-interest-while-enigmatic-descriptions-show-no-effect/. Accessed 21 November 2026.
Katie Riggs. "Explaining Quantum Physics Concepts Boosts Public Interest While Enigmatic Descriptions Show No Effect." Scienmag. November 21, 2026. https://scienmag.com/explaining-quantum-physics-concepts-boosts-public-interest-while-enigmatic-descriptions-show-no-effect/








