A systematic scoping review examining health-related evidence-based intervention implementation has revealed that explicit analyses of power remain rare across the published literature, with only twenty-eight papers directly discussing power dynamics out of more than thirty-five hundred screened records. The study team observed that although the discipline of implementation science frequently emphasizes contextual determinants of health, power imbalances and structural dynamics are rarely evaluated as active levers or explicit targets of systemic intervention.
To rigorously map the state of the science, the investigators conducted a protocol-driven scoping review informed by methodological frameworks established by Arksey and O’Malley alongside Levac and colleagues, while prospectively registering their protocol on the Open Science Framework and reporting outcomes under the PRISMA scoping review standards. Implementation science was operationalized as the scientific study of methods to promote the systematic uptake of research findings and other evidence-based interventions into routine practice to enhance health service quality and impact. The literature search was formulated in collaboration with a specialized health sciences librarian, executing queries across PubMed, Embase, APA PsychINFO, MEDLINE, and CINAHL through February 2022. The bibliographic search yielded 4,474 total citations, which was reduced to 3,531 distinct records after the automated and manual removal of duplicate publications.
The study selection process followed rigorous dual-screening protocols utilizing Covidence systematic review software. Paired independent reviewers evaluated all 3,531 titles and abstracts against pre-established eligibility criteria, resolving divergent assessments through third-reviewer adjudication and deliberate consensus meetings. Studies were required to be peer-reviewed empirical investigations involving human subjects in clinical, community, or public health settings focusing substantively on implementation science and explicit examinations of power. During title and abstract screening, 3,177 records were excluded, leaving 354 eligible for full-text examination. The full-text review subsequently eliminated 326 articles due to specific exclusion parameters: three were not in English, one could not be retrieved, ninety-five were purely conceptual without empirical data, sixty-five lacked substantive implementation science focus, two lacked specific interventions, fifty-three referenced empowerment non-substantively, two had no health focus, seventy-six did not sufficiently examine power, and twenty-nine applied definitions of power inconsistent with the review criteria.
The final analytical sample comprised twenty-eight articles published between 2006 and 2022, representing empirical data originating from twenty-two different countries. Methodologically, the literature was heavily weighted toward qualitative designs, which accounted for eighty-six percent of the included papers, while the remaining fourteen percent utilized mixed-methods designs. The distribution of implementation environments showed that seventy-nine percent took place within clinical or hospital environments, twenty-one percent were situated in community-based organizations, seven percent occurred in schools, seven percent took place in public health departments, and twenty-five percent spanned diverse community contexts including correctional facilities and microfinance cooperatives. Percentages exceeded one hundred percent because several evaluated programs operated across multiple simultaneous organizational settings.
A critical finding from data extraction was that only eleven of the twenty-eight included articles, or thirty-nine percent, articulated a formal definition of power, with merely six referencing established theoretical definitions from broader literature. For the remaining seventeen articles that lacked explicit definitions, eligibility was determined based on documented empirical efforts to evaluate or actively intervene upon power relations. Furthermore, only eleven of the twenty-eight studies explicitly named implementation science theories, models, or frameworks guiding their research, citing twelve distinct frameworks overall. This pattern indicates that even within the specialized subset of publications that examine power dynamics, formal grounding in established implementation science conceptual models remains remarkably uncommon.
To evaluate the distribution and targets of power-related actions, the investigators mapped the literature against Archon Fung’s four-level conceptual framework, which analyzes power across everyday, policy, structural, and ethical dimensions. Fung’s framework organizes power from individual interactions outward: Level 1 centers on everyday power in routine interpersonal encounters; Level 2 encompasses laws, formal institutional rules, and governmental policies; Level 3 addresses structural power, including environmental conditions and organizational parameters that enable advocacy; and Level 4 represents ethical power, comprising overarching cultural ideals, moral values, and societal norms that condition human expectations. Across the eighteen articles that described operationalizing power relative to implementation strategies or interventions, twelve addressed everyday power, seven addressed policy power, twelve addressed structural power, and only one single study addressed ethical power.
The synthesis demonstrated that operational interventions cluster heavily around immediate interpersonal and organizational friction points rather than broader sociopolitical structures. In evaluating this distribution, the authors noted that implementation research predominantly targets short-term integration goals, focusing on routine interactions and quantifiable metrics that fit neatly within conventional research grant lifespans. Policy-level power received markedly less attention, while ethical power was almost entirely unaddressed. The authors underscored that the lone study attempting to influence ethical power—an initiative described by Swendeman and colleagues focusing on sex workers in India—was embedded within an extensive community-led social movement. That structural initiative successfully leveraged multi-tiered alignment, simultaneously addressing everyday agency, household negotiating dynamics via microfinance, organizational structural reframing, and the ethical normalization of sex work to reduce vulnerability to sexually transmitted diseases.
The review emphasized several conceptual and operational mechanisms through which power influences implementation trajectories, highlighting the contrast between dominating forms of power and liberatory frameworks emphasizing collective power. Drawing on wider sociological scholarship, the authors identified how implementation efforts generate discursive power over narrative priorities, epistemic power regarding whose knowledge and evidence types are validated, and material power governing access to essential financial and physical resources. When power dynamics are ignored, conventional implementation initiatives risk reinforcing closed decision-making spaces where external authority figures unilaterally dictate intervention selection, site allocation, and adaptation protocols. In contrast, incorporating power analyses encourages teams to explicitly question whose interests are being served and examine how participatory approaches can foster authentic power-sharing.
The authors situated their findings within specific study limitations that contextualize the analytical results. First, the scoping review did not incorporate grey literature, advocacy publications, or non-peer-reviewed documentation produced by community organizers and grassroots mobilization efforts, such as initiatives highlighted by The Praxis Project, which regularly execute real-world power shifts beyond academic literature. Second, the screening criteria intentionally restricted inclusion to studies with explicit, published treatments of power, thereby omitting initiatives that addressed power relations implicitly. Third, the analysis was limited to English-language publications and featured predominant representation from high-income countries, leaving open questions regarding how power operates across low- and middle-income implementation settings. Additionally, the review scoped publications through February 2022 and did not evaluate the comparative clinical efficacy or implementation outcome success of the underlying interventions.
In their conclusions, the investigators argued that advancing health equity through implementation science requires researchers to transition from viewing power as a passive contextual determinant to deliberately treating it as an active lever for structural change. The authors noted emerging advancements, such as the Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research 2.0, the Health Equity Implementation Framework, and the He Pikinga Waiora Implementation Framework, which have begun integrating power dynamics directly into analytical models. To systematically shift health systems toward justice, the authors recommended routinizing power evaluations alongside traditional metrics such as cost, fostering deep community co-creation, and establishing sustained community partnerships that outlast short-term academic funding cycles.
Subject of Research: Scoping review of power conceptualization and operationalization in evidence-based intervention implementation
Article Title: How power is conceptualized and operationalized in evidence-based intervention implementation: a scoping review
Article References: Ramanadhan, S., Cruz, J. L., Safaeinili, N., Alexander, S., Lee, M., Jeon, E. D., Adsul, P., Shelton, R. C., & Stanton, M. (2026). How power is conceptualized and operationalized in evidence-based intervention implementation: a scoping review. Implementation Science, 21(1), Article 41. https://doi.org/10.1186/s13012-026-01511-5
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1186/s13012-026-01511-5
Keywords: implementation science, evidence-based interventions, power dynamics, scoping review, health equity, everyday power, structural power, policy power, ethical power, systemic change, participatory research, health disparities, organizational context, PRISMA-ScR, public health
Cite Scienmag News
Phoebe Ingram. (November 19, 2026). Scoping Review Reveals Rare Explicit Power Analysis in Intervention Implementation Studies. Scienmag. https://scienmag.com/scoping-review-reveals-rare-explicit-power-analysis-in-intervention-implementation-studies/
Phoebe Ingram. "Scoping Review Reveals Rare Explicit Power Analysis in Intervention Implementation Studies." Scienmag, 19 November 2026, https://scienmag.com/scoping-review-reveals-rare-explicit-power-analysis-in-intervention-implementation-studies/. Accessed 19 November 2026.
Phoebe Ingram. "Scoping Review Reveals Rare Explicit Power Analysis in Intervention Implementation Studies." Scienmag. November 19, 2026. https://scienmag.com/scoping-review-reveals-rare-explicit-power-analysis-in-intervention-implementation-studies/








