Migratory ungulate species exhibit significantly higher rates of extinction alongside higher rates of speciation when compared directly to their nonmigratory counterparts, according to a macroevolutionary analysis published in PLOS Biology by Abraham and colleagues and evaluated in an accompanying Primer by Gustavo Burin. The investigation applied trait-dependent speciation and extinction models across ungulates, an ecologically vital and charismatic group of mammals, to evaluate how migratory behaviour influences evolutionary branching and lineage termination over deep time. While migration fundamentally serves as an adaptive mechanism enabling animals to overcome local environmental hardships, the empirical modelling indicates that relying on this strategy has historically driven an intense macroevolutionary turnover. Lineages that migrate experience elevated probabilities of lineage loss that are simultaneously accompanied by rapid bursts of speciation, fundamentally shaping the diversification dynamics of the entire ungulate clade and producing substantial consequences for terrestrial ecosystem properties and functioning.
The underlying ecological driver of migratory behaviour across vertebrate groups—spanning terrestrial ruminants and birds as well as marine fish and whales—is the capacity to overcome local resource deficits. By shifting their ranges across seasons, migratory populations can escape locally deteriorating conditions, including severe shifts in temperature, depleted forage, restricted water availability, and seasonal shortages of potential mating partners. In the immediate term, moving between distinct geographic regions provides tangible survival and reproductive benefits to individual animals and their broader populations. Nevertheless, over extended macroevolutionary timescales, the evolutionary ramifications of relying on long-distance seasonal movements become substantially more precarious. Successfully tracking biological and environmental resources across space and time can shield populations from localized crises, but any failure to accurately synchronize movements with dynamic resources can rapidly precipitate catastrophic population crashes.
When animal populations fail to track moving resources with precision, the demographic risks escalate dramatically. Migratory herds face heightened vulnerability to severe food shortages, elevated rates of predation encountered along transit corridors, and severe mismatches with prevailing environmental conditions at their destinations. These acute vulnerabilities help clarify why Abraham and colleagues detected elevated extinction rates among migratory ungulates relative to sedentary lineages. In their analytical models, migratory species exhibited a persistent baseline of higher extinction risk, demonstrating that the failure to establish in seasonal destination areas or mistimed migration events can lead to the outright demise of entire populations and, ultimately, the permanent termination of whole species lineages across macroevolutionary history.
Conversely, the same spatial dynamics that drive population mortality appear to accelerate speciation rates among migratory ungulates. The researchers speculate that this elevated speciation stems from geographic range fragmentation caused by partial migration failure or local extirpations. When migratory pathways collapse or contiguous geographic distributions break apart, surviving herds frequently become trapped in isolated habitat pockets. If gene flow between these fragmented populations and the remainder of the parent species is severed, local adaptations and genetic divergence accumulate rapidly within the isolated demes. Over macroevolutionary durations, this interruption of reproductive exchange fosters the emergence of distinct new species, directly explaining how high speciation rates can operate concurrently with heightened extinction rates to maintain a swift evolutionary turnover within migratory clades.
A critical methodological advance in the study was the explicit incorporation of recently extinct species—specifically those lost during the Quaternary—alongside extant lineages within the trait-dependent diversification frameworks. Trait-dependent diversification models have faced extensive methodological scrutiny over the past decade because traditional phylogenies that include only contemporary, living species rely heavily on indirect inferences to reconstruct historical extinction rates. Some macroevolutionary researchers have criticized extant-only approaches as inherently prone to producing inaccurate rate estimates, with some arguing that extinction rates cannot be reliably derived without direct historical records. By formally integrating species that went extinct during the Quaternary, Abraham and colleagues successfully mitigated key methodological limitations inherent in extant-only phylogenies, generating significantly more robust, dependable estimates of historical speciation and extinction dynamics.
The integration of Quaternary fossil and subfossil records also revealed a profound ecological footprint: the elevated extinction of migratory ungulates caused a measurable reduction in the total volume of ecomorphospace occupied by the broader ungulate lineage. Ecomorphospace serves as a multidimensional analytical representation where each point reflects a distinct combination of ecological and morphological characteristics exhibited by a given species. The study demonstrated that migratory species were disproportionately prevalent among recently extinct Quaternary taxa compared to their representation among surviving contemporary species. Because these lost migratory ungulates possessed specialized ecological attributes and functional morphologies that are entirely absent in surviving lineages, their preferential extinction resulted in a pronounced contraction of the morphological and ecological space filled by ungulates globally.
This contraction of ungulate ecomorphospace was found to be notably uneven across different biogeographic zones, exhibiting its most pronounced reduction within the African fauna. The selective disappearance of migratory forms possessing unique combinations of functional traits suggests that ecosystem functioning was unevenly and profoundly disrupted in geographic areas where migratory ungulate losses were concentrated. The findings emphasize that Quaternary extinctions were not functionally random, but rather eliminated specialized functional roles that had previously anchored ecosystem dynamics across broad geographic expanses.
Furthermore, incorporating Quaternary extinctions permitted the researchers to isolate specific morphological and biological characteristics that rendered certain migratory lineages especially vulnerable to extinction. The analyses revealed that large-bodied species were disproportionately represented among the taxa that suffered the most extensive recent losses.
The macroevolutionary duality of migration—characterized by high extinction rates balanced against high speciation rates—ultimately yields evolutionary lineages defined by rapid species turnover. As Burin highlights in the Primer, clades characterized by rapid turnover are inherently ephemeral and exceptionally sensitive to stochastic, short-term fluctuations in environmental conditions. In periods of broad ecological instability, this intrinsic ephemerality makes migratory species disproportionately susceptible to abrupt demographic collapses when normal spatial dynamics are compromised.
This evolutionary vulnerability is particularly critical in the modern era, where anthropogenic activities are rapidly transforming the biosphere through pervasive landscape modification and accelerated climatic warming. When environmental phenology changes faster than migratory herds can adjust their travel schedules, the spatial and temporal mismatches described in macroevolutionary models become immediate demographic realities, drastically heightening the probability of local extirpations and irreversible species extinctions.
Ultimately, synthesizing evidence from deep-time evolutionary models with recent Quaternary extinctions provides critical historical context for understanding and forecasting modern biodiversity trends. The findings demonstrated by Abraham and colleagues indicate that current anthropogenic pressures do not act upon a clean slate; rather, modern human disturbances represent an acute intensification of deep-seated macroevolutionary trends that have long governed migratory lineages. By exposing which lineages possess evolutionary histories characterized by high turnover, specialized ecomorphology, and heightened extinction probabilities, this integrated research framework identifies the biological groups facing the greatest current peril, providing an evidence-based foundation to inform targeted conservation policies designed to preserve the remaining migratory ungulates of the world.
Subject of Research: Macroevolutionary diversification dynamics, speciation, and extinction rates in migratory ungulates
Article Title: Migration as a key influence on ungulate eco-evolutionary history
Article References: Burin, G. (2026). Migration as a key influence on ungulate eco-evolutionary history. PLOS Biology, 24(11), e3004115. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.3004115
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1371/journal.pbio.3004115
Keywords: ungulates, migratory behaviour, macroevolutionary dynamics, speciation rates, extinction rates, ecomorphospace, trait-dependent diversification, Quaternary extinctions, resource tracking, species turnover, African fauna, phenology, landscape disruption, mammalian evolution, ecosystem functioning, biodiversity conservation
Cite Scienmag News
Gavin Prescott. (November 19, 2026). Migratory Ungulates Face Elevated Extinction and Speciation Rates in Macroevolutionary Analysis. Scienmag. https://scienmag.com/migratory-ungulates-face-elevated-extinction-and-speciation-rates-in-macroevolutionary-analysis/
Gavin Prescott. "Migratory Ungulates Face Elevated Extinction and Speciation Rates in Macroevolutionary Analysis." Scienmag, 19 November 2026, https://scienmag.com/migratory-ungulates-face-elevated-extinction-and-speciation-rates-in-macroevolutionary-analysis/. Accessed 19 November 2026.
Gavin Prescott. "Migratory Ungulates Face Elevated Extinction and Speciation Rates in Macroevolutionary Analysis." Scienmag. November 19, 2026. https://scienmag.com/migratory-ungulates-face-elevated-extinction-and-speciation-rates-in-macroevolutionary-analysis/








