Experimental research has systematically analyzed the performance of various soil-reinforcement interface systems subjected to direct shear loading. By employing a multi-criteria evaluation approach, the researchers sought to move beyond simple strength metrics and assess performance across a range of geotechnical parameters.
To conduct the tests, the research team utilized two types of granular soil: a well-graded sand with silt and a poorly graded sand. These materials were subjected to direct shear testing within 100 × 100 mm and 300 × 300 mm shear boxes.
The study investigated four distinct interface configurations: unreinforced soil, high-density polyethylene (HDPE) geogrid, unidirectional carbon-fiber-reinforced polymer (CFRP) sheets, and epoxy-impregnated CFRP sheets. Each configuration offered different mechanical advantages. The geogrid primarily relied on friction and particle interlocking to enhance the shear response, facilitating improved dilation. In contrast, the CFRP-based systems were designed to offer superior post-peak strength retention, with epoxy impregnation further modifying the interface response through increased adhesion.
Analysis of the shear stress-horizontal displacement and vertical displacement responses revealed distinct performance patterns. The different interfaces demonstrated variations in peak strength, softening behaviors, and contraction-dilation trends. Mohr-Coulomb fits applied to the resulting data showed high coefficients of determination, although the authors noted that the limited number of stress levels necessitates careful interpretation of apparent cohesion and internal friction angle values.
To integrate these diverse findings, the researchers applied a TOPSIS multi-criteria decision-making framework. This framework incorporated several performance indicators, including peak strength, large-displacement shear resistance, initial interface shear-stiffness, strength retention, peak displacement, and an interface toughness index defined by the area under the shear stress-displacement curve up to 10 mm of displacement.
The resulting baseline ranking identified the epoxy-impregnated CFRP system as the top performer, achieving a closeness coefficient of 0.680, followed closely by the geogrid configuration at 0.661. A sensitivity analysis involving 45 different scenarios confirmed the robustness of these results, demonstrating that these two systems consistently outperformed the other tested configurations under various criteria and weighting assumptions. The geogrid ranked first in 24 of the scenarios, while the epoxy-impregnated CFRP ranked first in 21.
Ultimately, the researchers concluded that effective reinforcement selection requires a nuanced understanding of interaction mechanisms. Engineers must distinguish between the friction- and interlocking-dominated peak resistance provided by geogrids and the adhesion-related post-peak stability offered by epoxy-modified systems. Relying on a single strength parameter is insufficient for characterizing the complex behavior of these interface systems, necessitating the multi-faceted approach demonstrated in this experimental study.
Subject of Research: Experimental evaluation of granular soil-reinforcement interfaces using multi-criteria decision analysis.
Article Title: Multi-criteria experimental evaluation of soil–reinforcement interface systems under direct shear loading
Article References: Haj Ghanbari, M. M., Toufigh, M. M., & Toufigh, V. (2026). Multi-criteria experimental evaluation of soil–reinforcement interface systems under direct shear loading. Journal of Infrastructure Preservation and Resilience. https://doi.org/10.1186/s43065-026-00223-w
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1186/s43065-026-00223-w
Keywords: Soil reinforcement, Direct shear test, Geogrid, Carbon-fiber-reinforced polymer, CFRP, Epoxy impregnation, Interface friction, Soil mechanics, Infrastructure preservation, TOPSIS, Multi-criteria decision analysis, Granular soil, Geotechnical engineering, Interface stiffness, Shear strength, Soil-reinforcement interaction, Particle interlocking, Civil engineering, Laboratory testing
Cite Scienmag News
Neil Sanderson. (November 16, 2026). Multi-Criteria Analysis Evaluates Soil-Reinforcement Interface Systems Under Shear Loading. Scienmag. https://scienmag.com/multi-criteria-analysis-evaluates-soil-reinforcement-interface-systems-under-shear-loading/
Neil Sanderson. "Multi-Criteria Analysis Evaluates Soil-Reinforcement Interface Systems Under Shear Loading." Scienmag, 16 November 2026, https://scienmag.com/multi-criteria-analysis-evaluates-soil-reinforcement-interface-systems-under-shear-loading/. Accessed 16 November 2026.
Neil Sanderson. "Multi-Criteria Analysis Evaluates Soil-Reinforcement Interface Systems Under Shear Loading." Scienmag. November 16, 2026. https://scienmag.com/multi-criteria-analysis-evaluates-soil-reinforcement-interface-systems-under-shear-loading/








