In deep underground engineering, localized structural instability along the boundary between composite concrete linings and surrounding rock represents a persistent operational challenge. Using two-dimensional particle flow code simulations calibrated against physical laboratory compression tests, researchers Haoran Shi, Hongtu Xiu, Tianyu Long, and Xiaojiang Deng have demonstrated that interface cracks induce severe anisotropic degradation of structural load capacity while showing how cementitious grouting restores stability through mesoscopic force-chain bridging and stress-ring reconstruction. Deep tunnels excavated for transportation, mining, and water conservancy projects encounter severe in situ stresses where interfacial cracking frequently develops from differential ground deformation, thermal variations, or mechanical construction disturbances. These pre-existing interfacial separations alter internal stress transmission paths and dictate macroscopic fracture propagation modes. The research team established a discrete-element framework to examine how varying crack position angles and crack extent angles govern mechanical failure, clarifying how targeted grouting and confining pressures work together to protect defective lining structures from catastrophic structural collapse.
To evaluate the mechanical degradation caused by interface flaws, the investigators designed a series of laboratory experiments using similar-material specimens measuring two hundred millimeters in length and width by thirty-five millimeters in thickness. A circular opening sixty millimeters in diameter was cut at the center of each specimen to represent the excavated cavern, around which an annular concrete lining measuring twenty millimeters in thickness was cast. Pre-set interface cracks were created by wire-cutting circular arc segments with outer diameters of sixty and sixty-five millimeters along the rock-lining boundary. The orientation of the defect was defined by the position angle alpha, measured between the vertical axis and the line connecting the crack midpoint to the tunnel center, while the defect length was characterized by the extent angle beta subtended by the crack edges. Specimen calibration incorporated experimental configurations with a fixed defect extent angle of ninety degrees positioned at angles of zero, forty-five, and ninety degrees across both ungrouted and grouted conditions.
The particle flow code discrete-element model matched the laboratory configuration using twenty-one thousand six hundred and ten bonded circular particles assigned linear parallel-bond contact models. Because synthetic granular particles differ from natural sandstone grains in microstructural arrangement, the investigators calibrated microparameters through a systematic trial-and-error procedure that aligned numerical peak compressive strength, elastic modulus, and post-peak softening curves with laboratory measurements. The resulting numerical parameters assigned an interparticle Young modulus of ten point three megapascals to the surrounding rock, twenty point two megapascals to the concrete lining, and one point five megapascals to the grouting material, alongside corresponding parallel-bond Young moduli of identical values. Ratios of normal to tangential stiffness were established at two point zero across all materials, with interparticle friction coefficients set to zero point five. Parallel-bond tensile and shear strengths were calibrated to five point three and seven point two megapascals for rock, four point one and five point three megapascals for lining, and two point two and three point two megapascals for grout.
Simulations conducted across crack extent angles ranging from fifteen to seventy-five degrees revealed that interfacial defects cause pronounced anisotropic weakening across all loading stages. Structural load-displacement curves exhibited four sequential phases encompassing initial pore compaction, linear elastic response, plastic yielding, and post-peak softening. When cracks were positioned at the tunnel spandrel at an angle of forty-five degrees, the structure exhibited its most unfavorable mechanical state. As the defect extent angle expanded from fifteen degrees to seventy-five degrees at the spandrel, the peak bearing load dropped sharply from two hundred seventeen point nine zero kilonewtons to one hundred ninety-eight point six two kilonewtons, representing an eight point eight percent reduction. Mechanically, the forty-five-degree orientation aligns closely with the plane of maximum shear stress under vertical compression. The interface crack serves as a frictionless pre-existing sliding surface that curtails effective load-bearing area and initiates premature shear-slip failure, producing a sharp post-peak stress drop without an extended plastic yield plateau.
Defect positions at the crown and invert, defined by a position angle of zero degrees, exhibited a different mechanical trajectory. Although the peak capacity decreased monotonically by approximately ten point eight percent as the crack extent expanded from fifteen to seventy-five degrees, falling from two hundred thirty-seven point eight one kilonewtons to two hundred twelve point sixteen kilonewtons, the absolute strength remained consistently higher than in the spandrel configuration. Under vertical compressive loading, the crown and invert regions experience dominant compressive stresses that force crack surfaces into contact, generating Mode II shear resistance governed by interparticle friction and delaying total interfacial debonding. In contrast, cracks located at the haunch with an orientation angle of ninety degrees experienced horizontal tensile opening, with peak loads declining from two hundred twenty-one point ten kilonewtons at fifteen degrees to two hundred seven point eighty-seven kilonewtons at seventy-five degrees. Because the vertical rock pillars along the sidewalls remained structurally continuous, the haunch defect produced intermediate load capacities between the crown and spandrel configurations.
Tracking crack propagation showed that defect orientation fundamentally dictates macroscopic fracture patterns. At a zero-degree orientation, initial microcracking concentrated near the opening boundaries and crack tips, redistributing stresses toward the haunches where concentrated tangential stresses generated symmetric conjugate X-shaped shear bands extending toward specimen corners. At a forty-five-degree orientation, failure was catastrophic, as wing cracks rapidly initiated at the singular stress concentrations of the crack tips and propagated along the maximum principal stress direction. At an extent angle of seventy-five degrees, extensive lining debonding caused the concrete layer to lose surrounding rock confinement, triggering localized buckling. In specimens with defects located at ninety degrees, layered spalling and vertical splitting parallel to the loading direction dominated the sidewalls.
Injecting grout into the interfacial fissures produced substantial mechanical restoration, lifting peak structural bearing capacities by nine point twenty-eight percent to twenty-six point ninety-four percent across all modeled geometries. The magnitude of structural recovery directly correlated with pre-grouting damage severity. The weakest configuration, characterized by a spandrel crack angle of forty-five degrees and an extent angle of seventy-five degrees, achieved the maximum load increase of twenty-six point ninety-four percent, elevating its peak resistance from one hundred ninety-eight point six two kilonewtons to two hundred fifty-two point thirteen kilonewtons. At a sixty-degree extent along the spandrel, capacity rose by twenty-six point zero one percent, from two hundred seven point twenty-five kilonewtons to two hundred sixty-one point seventeen kilonewtons. Conversely, the crown defect at an extent of fifteen degrees registered the lowest gain of nine point twenty-eight percent, moving from two hundred thirty-seven point eight one kilonewtons to two hundred fifty-nine point eighty-nine kilonewtons, because the interface already maintained partial compressive contact.
At the mesoscopic scale, discrete-element force-chain visualizations clarified that the essence of grouting reinforcement stems from force-chain bridging and the reconstruction of continuous stress rings. In ungrouted models, interfacial separations produced distinct unloaded shadow zones behind the lining while generating severe stress singularities at crack tips. Grouting material re-established cohesive bonds across the void, allowing strong contact force chains to traverse directly from rock particles into lining particles. This bridging mechanism dispersed local stress concentrations into uniform load distributions along the boundary, preventing premature bond breakage. Furthermore, grout solidification re-formed a closed, dense annular band of strong compressive force chains encircling the opening. This restored force-chain ring provided continuous passive confinement around the concrete lining, while post-peak force networks remained partially intact, enabling grouted specimens to retain substantial residual load capacity while replacing wide macroscopic rupture planes with diffuse networks of microcracks.
Evaluating the composite system under confining pressures of zero point five, one point zero, and one point five megapascals demonstrated a clear transition in failure modes from brittle fracture to ductile deformation. At a low confining pressure of zero point five megapascals, specimens lacked sufficient lateral constraint, allowing microcracks to undergo unstable tensile propagation and coalesce into macroscopic splitting surfaces that penetrated to external boundaries. When confining pressure rose to one point zero megapascals, tensile opening displacements were suppressed, causing damage to localize into shear-slip bands around the opening. At a high confining pressure of one point five megapascals, macroscopic boundary-penetrating cracks disappeared entirely, confining mechanical damage to a narrow annular crushed zone surrounding the lining. This lateral pressure suppressed radial particle dilation, enabling the deep surrounding rock mass to remain within an elastic regime and function as an autonomous self-supporting arch.
The discrete-element simulations established a strong positive coupling between confining pressure and grouting reinforcement. Under zero point five megapascals of confining pressure, grouted specimens still experienced minor localized shear bands because low lateral constraint permitted interfacial tensile and shear failure. Under one point five megapascals, however, grouted models developed virtually no macroscopic fracture paths, displaying uniform elastic stress responses that remained well below ultimate yield thresholds. Mechanically, confining pressure elevated normal stresses across the interface, mobilizing high frictional resistance according to the Mohr-Coulomb criterion while enhancing the apparent compressive strength and ductility of the grout medium itself. Even if chemical bonding degraded under extreme deformation, residual frictional interlocking prevented slip instability. These findings confirm that grouting efficacy is amplified in deep, high-stress geological environments, providing quantitative discrete-element support for designing defect remediation schemes in deep tunnel engineering.
Subject of Research: Discrete element modeling of tunnel interface cracks and grouting reinforcement mechanisms under confining pressure
Article Title: Study on evolution law of interface cracks in tunnels and grouting reinforcement mechanism based on particle flow simulation
Article References: Shi, H., Xiu, H., Long, T., & Deng, X. (2026). Study on evolution law of interface cracks in tunnels and grouting reinforcement mechanism based on particle flow simulation. Frontiers in Earth Science, 14, Article 2009739. https://doi.org/10.3389/feart.2026.2009739
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.3389/feart.2026.2009739
Keywords: particle flow code, discrete element modeling, tunnel lining, interface cracks, grouting reinforcement, confining pressure, rock mechanics, stress ring reconstruction, force chain bridging, tunnel spandrel, shear slip failure, surrounding rock, underground engineering, brittle ductile transition, geotechnical engineering, linear parallel bond
Cite Scienmag News
Violet Maxwell. (November 16, 2026). Discrete Element Models Reveal Grouting Restores Deep Tunnel Lining Interface Cracks. Scienmag. https://scienmag.com/discrete-element-models-reveal-grouting-restores-deep-tunnel-lining-interface-cracks/
Violet Maxwell. "Discrete Element Models Reveal Grouting Restores Deep Tunnel Lining Interface Cracks." Scienmag, 16 November 2026, https://scienmag.com/discrete-element-models-reveal-grouting-restores-deep-tunnel-lining-interface-cracks/. Accessed 22 November 2026.
Violet Maxwell. "Discrete Element Models Reveal Grouting Restores Deep Tunnel Lining Interface Cracks." Scienmag. November 16, 2026. https://scienmag.com/discrete-element-models-reveal-grouting-restores-deep-tunnel-lining-interface-cracks/








