Lived retrospective accounts from practitioners in a devotional community indicate that core constructs of the Integrated Triguna Framework, a process model of wellbeing derived from Indian Knowledge Systems, are recognizable and subject to refinement in real-world practice. In a qualitative investigation centered on a Sattvik practice ecology within a single bhakti community, researchers examined how far theoretical constructs were recognizable in, qualified by, or exceeded by the personal experiences of practitioners. The study revealed that while key theoretical dimensions were recognizable in the participants’ retrospective narratives, the constructs required careful qualification, and devotional practice was not universally sufficient on its own for resolving personal dysregulation.
The research addresses prominent limitations in existing subjective wellbeing literature, which has faced recurring criticism from scholars for theoretical fragmentation, weak causal modeling, and limited cultural grounding. In response to calls for culturally grounded process models of flourishing, the authors investigated the Integrated Triguna Framework as an indigenous alternative rooted in Indian Knowledge Systems.
To assess how the theoretical framework aligns with lived reality, the investigators conducted qualitative interviews with 14 adult practitioners, consisting of nine men and five women between the ages of 18 and 60. Thirteen of the participants narrated their personal trajectories of practice, which spanned from under two years to more than two decades of sustained engagement.
The research team conducted the interviews using a theory-anchored semi-structured guide designed to explore practitioners’ lived experiences against the conceptual model. Transcripts from the interviews were subsequently evaluated using Template Analysis within a hybrid deductive–inductive interpretive stance. To ensure analytical rigor and systematic evaluation, the researchers maintained an audit trail, applied explicit disconfirmation criteria throughout the coding process, and conducted a deliberate search for negative cases that diverged from or challenged the core assumptions of the framework.
From the qualitative analysis, the researchers identified seven overarching themes that describe a reported progression across practitioners’ developmental trajectories. This trajectory begins with initial experiences of Rajas–Tamas dysregulation, transitions through externally scaffolded entry and the adoption of embodied discipline, and leads toward an imperfect, effortful stabilization.
The analysis demonstrated that most core constructs of the Integrated Triguna Framework were recognizable within the practitioners’ descriptive accounts, with Agent–Kṣetra co-evolution emerging as the most extensively described dynamic. However, the lived reports also indicated that several theoretical constructs required refinement. For example, reported persistence in practice differed markedly depending on whether surrounding supports were maintained or disrupted. In response to these observed differences, the researchers divided each persistence-related construct into two distinct variants to reflect the presence or absence of maintained supports.
The practitioner accounts further revealed three distinct pathways through which individuals originally entered into the Sattvik practice ecology: through family upbringing, through direct contact with the devotional community, and through various media channels. Notably, one participant’s entry into devotional practice occurred specifically through social-media content.
Within this single bhakti community, negative cases demonstrated that devotional practice was sometimes insufficient on its own and was experienced as beneficial only when pursued alongside professional clinical and psychosocial care.
The authors concluded by noting that while the qualitative findings demonstrate that the constructs of the Integrated Triguna Framework are recognizable and refinable in lived accounts, they do not validate the framework or establish causal mechanisms. Because the data rely exclusively on retrospective interviews from a single bhakti community, the findings remain descriptive and context-specific. Demonstrating causal relationships, confirming directional mechanisms, and assessing broader generalizability will require future empirical research utilizing longitudinal designs, comparative settings, and quantitative methods.
Subject of Research: Qualitative evaluation of the Integrated Triguna Framework in a devotional practice community
Article Title: Lived trajectories of wellbeing in a Triguna-based Sattvik practice ecology
Article References: Bhuvanagiri, K. K., Gannamraju, S. K., & Chembrolu, V. H. (2026). Lived trajectories of wellbeing in a Triguna-based Sattvik practice ecology. Frontiers in Psychology, 17, Article 1909645. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2026.1909645
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.3389/fpsyg.2026.1909645
Keywords: Integrated Triguna Framework, Sattvik practice ecology, bhakti community, subjective wellbeing, Indian Knowledge Systems, Rajas-Tamas dysregulation, Agent-Kṣetra co-evolution, Digital Kṣetra, Template Analysis, negative-case search, embodied discipline, indigenous psychology, Bhagavad-Gita, qualitative research, psychosocial care, process models of flourishing, disconfirmation criteria, practice trajectories
Cite Scienmag News
Glenn Wilkins. (November 14, 2026). Devotional Practice Trajectories Reflect and Refine Integrated Triguna Wellbeing Framework. Scienmag. https://scienmag.com/devotional-practice-trajectories-reflect-and-refine-integrated-triguna-wellbeing-framework/
Glenn Wilkins. "Devotional Practice Trajectories Reflect and Refine Integrated Triguna Wellbeing Framework." Scienmag, 14 November 2026, https://scienmag.com/devotional-practice-trajectories-reflect-and-refine-integrated-triguna-wellbeing-framework/. Accessed 20 November 2026.
Glenn Wilkins. "Devotional Practice Trajectories Reflect and Refine Integrated Triguna Wellbeing Framework." Scienmag. November 14, 2026. https://scienmag.com/devotional-practice-trajectories-reflect-and-refine-integrated-triguna-wellbeing-framework/








