A qualitative investigation into university science, technology, engineering, and mathematics education has revealed that university teachers conceptualize the role of mathematics within their disciplines through five hierarchically inclusive categories of increasing sophistication. Published in Disciplinary and Interdisciplinary Science Education Research, the empirical study explores how educators in chemistry, computer science, geoscience, and physics perceive the function and structure of mathematical principles in their subject areas. While students across STEM pathways frequently encounter substantial academic barriers linked to mathematical proficiency, little systematic empirical evidence has documented how university educators themselves understand mathematics within their broader disciplinary knowledge structures. By conducting semi-structured qualitative interviews with sixteen experienced university instructors at a major Swedish university, the research team mapped an outcome space that characterizes mathematics progressively as a computational tool, a language for communication, a key to disciplinary understanding, an agent for developmental progress, and a foundational philosophical framework.
The underlying motivation for exploring academic conceptions stems from widespread educational challenges where student attrition across STEM subjects is heavily influenced by difficulties in applying mathematics to scientific problem-solving. Prior educational literature has established that success in pure mathematics courses does not guarantee effective problem-solving skills when students encounter contextualized physical, chemical, or geological phenomena. In applied disciplinary settings, mathematical representations become embedded with nuanced conceptual meanings, requiring learners to translate equations into concrete physical realities. The epistemic beliefs held by instructors inevitably influence classroom practices, defining the learning approaches they promote, the expectations they maintain for student mastery, and their willingness to provide explicit instructional scaffolding for contextualized mathematics. Despite this documented influence on pedagogy, research into educators’ perceptions of mathematics has historically remained theoretical and concentrated almost exclusively within physics education, leaving significant knowledge gaps regarding the broader spectrum of STEM fields.
To investigate the qualitative variation of these educator perspectives, the researchers grounded their investigation in phenomenography and variation theory. Phenomenography is an empirically driven educational research framework designed to describe the qualitatively distinct ways in which groups of individuals experience, conceptualize, and understand a given phenomenon. Rather than attempting to catalog every idiosyncratic personal view or construct statistical generalizations across a broader demographic, phenomenographic analysis focuses on collective patterns of awareness within a defined cohort. Central to variation theory is the understanding that learning requires discerning critical aspects of a phenomenon through the experience of variation. In this educational paradigm, differences in understanding correspond directly to varying degrees of analytical complexity. The resulting analytical structure, designated as an outcome space, categorizes collective conceptions into an ordered hierarchy where each successive tier reflects a more comprehensive and sophisticated understanding of the target subject.
The study commenced with a rigorous pilot phase designed to refine the interview protocol and evaluate whether educators across distinct scientific departments exhibited comparable conceptual frameworks. Eight pilot interviews were conducted among the co-authors themselves, who represented the four examined disciplines. The author team iteratively transcribed, reviewed, and mapped initial qualitative categories to calibrate the prompt questions, confirming consistent cross-disciplinary themes. Following these preliminary trials, the formal investigation recruited sixteen experienced faculty members comprising eleven men and five women from chemistry, computer science, geoscience, and physics at a major Swedish institution. Selecting seasoned educators ensured participants possessed deep reflective insight, maximizing the likelihood of capturing both elementary and highly advanced conceptualizations. Individual semi-structured interviews ranged between 15 and 50 minutes in duration, with six sessions conducted in Swedish and ten in English, following an interview guide structured around disciplinary background, daily academic practices, and pedagogical reflections.
To safeguard analytical validity and minimize personal bias, data collection and categorization followed a structured, multi-phase collaborative process. Each researcher conducted two interviews with departmental colleagues from their own home discipline, ensuring the interviewer maintained sufficient specialized technical knowledge to pose targeted follow-up inquiries. Audio recordings were transcribed verbatim, with Swedish transcripts translated into English, before all investigators independently reviewed the entire textual corpus to identify and tag relevant thematic excerpts. The research team then divided into two analytical subgroups—one containing four physicists and the other consisting of two chemists, one computer scientist, and one geoscientist—to independently synthesize proposals into candidate category systems. The entire group subsequently convened to resolve differences through iterative deliberation, establishing complete consensus on a single, unified outcome space comprising five hierarchically inclusive categories accompanied by representative narrative evidence.
The first and most basic category identified within the outcome space characterizes mathematics strictly as a computational tool. Within this conceptualization, mathematics functions as a practical instrument applied to calculate numerical values, execute formulas, and resolve operational problems without requiring deep structural comprehension. Instructors articulating this view described treating mathematical procedures almost like an operational black box, where established equations are utilized mechanically to produce an output required for an ongoing experiment or computational task. In this instrumental perspective, mathematical manipulation neither demands a deep engagement with abstract theoretical principles nor inherently deepens the student’s conceptual mastery of the scientific discipline itself. Instead, mathematical techniques are viewed as pragmatic devices borrowed from textbooks or external sources solely when a specific operational roadblock arises during disciplinary practice.
Advancing beyond mere calculation, the second category conceptualizes mathematics as a universal language for academic communication. In this conception, which subsumes the computational utility of the first category, mathematics serves as an explicit, shared formal system that allows educators and researchers to articulate scientific phenomena, physical processes, and structural dynamics with precision. Interviewees noted that mathematical representations enable scientists in hydrology, physical chemistry, or computational modeling to express disciplinary knowledge across international and interdisciplinary boundaries through standardized notation. However, the researchers observed that while this communicative conception recognizes mathematics as an efficient symbolic medium for translating and formalizing qualitative observations, it does not necessarily consider mathematical fluency to be fundamentally indispensable for attaining deep, intrinsic conceptual insights into the nature of the discipline itself.
The third hierarchical tier elevates mathematics to a key to understanding, viewing it as an indispensable cognitive framework necessary for acquiring profound disciplinary insight. Under this conceptualization, mathematics is not merely a tool for calculating quantities or transmitting information, but a foundational structure that facilitates systematic reasoning, illuminates complex relationships between disparate concepts, and underpins the formulation of predictive models. Educators emphasizing this perspective highlighted that genuine comprehension of physical or chemical phenomena requires analyzing underlying mathematical interactions rather than simply memorizing qualitative descriptions. In computer science and physics, participants argued that mathematical formulations provide the essential deductive scaffolding needed to reason through abstract theoretical mechanisms, establish valid connections between empirical data, and draw robust scientific conclusions that qualitative language alone cannot achieve.
In the fourth category, mathematics is conceptualized as an active agent for disciplinary development, serving as an engine that expands the boundaries of scientific knowledge. While incorporating all previous functions of computation, formal communication, and conceptual understanding, this tier uniquely identifies mathematics as a creative mechanism that generates novel research hypotheses, drives theoretical evolution, and propels the discipline beyond its current frontiers. Faculty members described how advanced mathematical logic and complex modeling enable researchers to perceive unexplored nuances within physical and chemical systems, directly prompting original scientific questions that guide future experimental and theoretical exploration. This perspective highlights the dynamic, bidirectional relationship between mathematical modeling and disciplinary discovery, where increasingly sophisticated scientific challenges stimulate new mathematical formulations that subsequently facilitate unprecedented conceptual breakthroughs.
The fifth and most advanced category regards mathematics as a philosophical foundation, viewing disciplinary knowledge as inherently intertwined with mathematical structure. At this level of sophistication, the boundary between the scientific field and mathematics becomes deeply integrated, prompting educators to engage with fundamental ontological and epistemological questions regarding the nature of scientific reality. Some participants, particularly in theoretical computer science, viewed their subject as practically synonymous with mathematical reasoning, utilizing identical structures of formal proof. Crucially, this category also captured critical pedagogical debates regarding mathematical Platonism, the belief that mathematical entities exist independently within the universe. Educators cautioned that dogmatically assuming nature must adhere to idealized mathematical beauty or algorithmic perfection risks detaching researchers from empirical physical realities, transforming theoretical models into unquestioned dogmas rather than interpretative tools.
The structural hierarchy of the outcome space reveals an overarching progression from instrumental utility to deep disciplinary integration. In the foundational tier, mathematics operates purely as an external, mechanical instrument, whereas in subsequent tiers it becomes increasingly intrinsic, eventually emerging as an inseparable component of disciplinary reasoning and epistemology. When contrasting these findings with broader educational literature, the authors noted that previous research frequently consolidates these nuanced roles into undifferentiated groupings, often conflating conceptual understanding with developmental progression. Furthermore, the emergence of explicit philosophical reflections among higher education teachers represents a dimension largely unaddressed in prior empirical studies. By revealing that experienced university instructors naturally contemplate foundational epistemological considerations, the study illustrates how phenomenographic inquiry exposes qualitative nuances that remain obscured in studies relying solely on pre-existing analytical frameworks.
These identified conceptions carry significant practical implications for undergraduate curriculum design and instructional delivery across university STEM departments. Prior research indicates that undergraduate students, even those nearing graduation, predominantly view mathematics through the narrow lens of category one, treating it merely as a computational chore rather than a vehicle for conceptual discovery. Because an educator’s implicit beliefs directly influence course design, the authors suggest that faculty must deliberately articulate the multifaceted roles of mathematics during classroom instruction. To prevent conceptual disconnects, institutions could introduce bridging or parallel courses where pure mathematics is taught alongside disciplinary science, enabling learners to contextualize formal equations immediately. Furthermore, structured collegial dialogues among faculty could help early-career educators recognize the broader epistemic functions of mathematics, encouraging intentional instructional strategies that systematically cultivate deeper student engagement across scientific domains.
The authors acknowledge several methodological boundaries, including the exclusive focus on experienced faculty at a single university and the collegial dynamics inherent in interviewing academic peers. While interviewing professional colleagues encouraged rich, scholarly dialogue, it may have prompted interviewees to articulate polished, sophisticated perspectives while omitting fundamental assumptions they considered obvious. Additionally, the relatively modest sample of sixteen educators and the uneven distribution of interviews across departments prevented direct statistical comparisons between separate disciplines. Future research could broaden this empirical foundation by investigating early-career instructors, exploring larger cohorts across additional STEM disciplines, and implementing longitudinal assessments to determine how reflective pedagogical training influences teaching approaches and measurable student learning outcomes over time.
Subject of Research: University STEM educators' hierarchical conceptions of mathematics across disciplinary knowledge structures
Article Title: Teachers’ conceptions of the role of mathematics in STEM higher education
Article References: Koerfer, E., Polverini, G., Elmgren, M., Eriksson, L.-H., Freyhult, L., Herbert, R. B., Ho, F. M., Solders, A., & Eckerdal, A. (2025). Teachers’ conceptions of the role of mathematics in STEM higher education. Disciplinary and Interdisciplinary Science Education Research, 7(1), Article 15. https://doi.org/10.1186/s43031-025-00135-x
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1186/s43031-025-00135-x
Keywords: phenomenography, STEM higher education, mathematics education, teacher conceptions, computational tool, scientific communication, conceptual understanding, disciplinary knowledge, pedagogical strategies, epistemic beliefs, interdisciplinary education, variation theory, physics education, chemistry education, computer science education, geoscience education, bridging courses
Cite Scienmag News
Reid Dalton. (November 13, 2026). Study Identifies Five Hierarchical Ways University Educators Conceive Mathematics in STEM. Scienmag. https://scienmag.com/study-identifies-five-hierarchical-ways-university-educators-conceive-mathematics-in-stem/
Reid Dalton. "Study Identifies Five Hierarchical Ways University Educators Conceive Mathematics in STEM." Scienmag, 13 November 2026, https://scienmag.com/study-identifies-five-hierarchical-ways-university-educators-conceive-mathematics-in-stem/. Accessed 22 November 2026.
Reid Dalton. "Study Identifies Five Hierarchical Ways University Educators Conceive Mathematics in STEM." Scienmag. November 13, 2026. https://scienmag.com/study-identifies-five-hierarchical-ways-university-educators-conceive-mathematics-in-stem/








