The commentary centers on a study by Zhang and colleagues published in Molecular Plant, which examined how the gaseous signaling molecule hydrogen sulfide, or H2S, influences the balance between immunity and development in rice. Hydrogen sulfide has long been recognized as a versatile player in plant physiology. It promotes seed germination by activating antioxidant enzymes and MAPK signaling pathways, enhances photosynthetic efficiency by upregulating photosynthetic enzymes and light signaling responses, and suppresses chlorophyll degradation to delay senescence. Under abiotic stresses such as heavy metal contamination, drought, heat, cold, and salinity, H2S bolsters resilience through enhanced antioxidant activity, protection of the photosynthetic apparatus, regulation of sulfur metabolism, and crosstalk with phytohormones. It also participates in defense against pathogens and herbivores by inducing pathogenesis-related gene expression, modulating glutathione metabolism, and interacting with hormone signaling networks.

What has remained poorly understood, however, is how H2S fits into the growth-defense trade-off itself. The resource constraint hypothesis, one of the most prevalent explanations for this trade-off, holds that plants possess finite energy and materials, so any reallocation toward defense necessarily diminishes what is available for growth. Yet accumulating evidence suggests that plants do not simply passively divide a fixed budget. Instead, they actively regulate the balance through a sophisticated, multi-layered regulatory network in which hormone crosstalk plays a central role, supplemented by microRNAs and non-coding RNAs, epigenetic regulation, and post-translational modifications of key transcription factors and NLR immune receptors. The new work adds an unexpected layer to this network: a redox-controlled structural transition of a single metabolic enzyme.

Zhang and colleagues began with a simple observation: applying H2S externally to rice plants improved their resistance to two devastating bacterial pathogens, Xanthomonas oryzae pv. oryzicola and Xanthomonas oryzae pv. oryzae, the causal agents of bacterial leaf streak and bacterial blight respectively. The treatment triggered the release of hydrogen peroxide, a burst of reactive oxygen species, and the expression of defense genes. But there was a cost. The same treatment stunted root elongation and impaired the development of lateral roots, a textbook manifestation of the growth-defense trade-off. The question became how the plant could harness the defensive benefits of H2S while avoiding its developmental penalties.

The answer lay in a protein called OsCBSX3, a rice protein containing a cystathionine beta-synthase domain. CBS domain-containing proteins are homologs of enzymes known from mammals, where they catalyze the condensation of cysteine and homocysteine to form cystathionine and H2S. The researchers showed that OsCBSX3 positively regulates rice resistance to both Xoc and Xoo, and that this protective function depends on its ability to produce hydrogen sulfide. Crucially, like other CBS domain-containing proteins, OsCBSX3 exists in two distinct structural states within the plant: a monomeric form and an oligomeric form. When bacteria infect the plant, monomeric OsCBSX3 shifts into the oligomeric state, and this oligomer can enter the chloroplast, the energy-producing organelle of the cell.

The functional importance of this structural conversion was demonstrated through genetics. An oligomerization-deficient mutant of OsCBSX3 showed impaired H2S production, compromised resistance against Xanthomonas oryzae, and defective chloroplast localization. In other words, the ability of the protein to assemble into its multi-subunit form is not a structural curiosity but the very mechanism by which the plant ramps up sulfide-based signaling during an attack. The oligomeric state is the immune-active state, and the monomeric state is the quiet, growth-compatible state.

To understand how this toggle is itself controlled, the team searched for proteins that physically interact with OsCBSX3 and identified two partners: OsTrxZ, a member of the thioredoxin family of redox proteins, and OsPsbO, the manganese-stabilizing protein of photosystem II. The picture that emerged is elegantly self-regulating. Upon pathogen infection, PsbO binds to OsCBSX3 and promotes its monomer-to-oligomer transition, elevating H2S generation and thereby enhancing disease resistance. But once H2S levels rise too high, a second interaction takes over: TrxZ competes with PsbO for binding to OsCBSX3 and reduces the protein back to its monomeric form. This monomerization curtails further H2S synthesis, alleviating the overaccumulation of the gas and its detrimental impacts on growth and development. The system thus functions as a negative feedback loop, with the signal itself, H2S, triggering the shutdown of its own production.

The significance of this finding extends beyond rice pathology. As Pu and colleagues emphasize in their commentary, the study provides the first evidence that H2S plays a coordinating role in plant growth-defense trade-offs and reveals the underlying mechanism. It also overturns a long-standing assumption about how plants make hydrogen sulfide in the first place. Until now, H2S production in plants was attributed almost exclusively to cysteine desulfurization enzymes, namely L-cysteine desulfhydrase and D-cysteine desulfhydrase. The demonstration that a CBS domain protein catalyzes H2S synthesis in plants fills a genuine gap in the field and suggests that the enzymology of sulfide signaling is more diverse than previously appreciated. It also illustrates a universal strategy for managing the growth-defense trade-off: rather than changing gene expression wholesale, the plant dynamically tunes the metabolic activity of a single enzyme by switching its oligomeric state.

For breeders, the practical implications are considerable. OsCBSX3, PsbO, and OsTrxZ together constitute a module of potential targets for engineering disease resistance in rice, one of the world’s most important staple crops feeding billions of people. The commentary’s authors are careful to note, however, that the goal is not simply to maximize H2S production. Concentration thresholds must be optimized so that resistance is deployed on demand, avoiding the excessive growth inhibition that would erode any yield advantage gained from disease resistance. They point to precise gene editing techniques, including the use of pathogen-inducible promoters that would activate the defense module only when a threat is detected, as a plausible route to achieving this kind of calibrated immunity.

The work also reframes how scientists think about trade-offs in general. The resource constraint hypothesis remains valid as a broad principle, but the OsCBSX3 story shows that plants possess dedicated molecular machinery for actively arbitrating between growth and defense, rather than merely suffering the consequences of a fixed budget. A gaseous signal, a photosynthetic protein, a thioredoxin, and a metabolic enzyme form a self-correcting circuit that boosts immunity during infection and quietly stands down when the danger has passed or when the cost to the plant becomes too great. Understanding such circuits in rice may well presage similar discoveries in other crops, opening a path toward plants that no longer have to choose between thriving and surviving.

Subject of Research: Hydrogen sulfide signaling and the growth-defense trade-off in rice

Article Title: Growth or immunity? OsCBSX3’s molecular toggle decides

Article References: Pu, M., Liu, S., Xie, Y., & Chen, J. (2025). Growth or immunity? OsCBSX3’s molecular toggle decides. Crop Health, 3(1), Article 18. https://doi.org/10.1007/s44297-025-00057-0

Image Credits: AI Generated

DOI: 10.1007/s44297-025-00057-0

Keywords: rice, hydrogen sulfide, OsCBSX3, growth-defense trade-off, plant immunity, Xanthomonas oryzae, chloroplast, thioredoxin, PsbO, oligomerization, disease resistance breeding, plant signaling