Pap screenings linked to less cervical cancer in elderly women
CHAMPAIGN, Ill. — A new study from the University of Illinois confirms a link between Pap smear screenings and a lower risk of developing cervical cancer in women over age 65. However, most American health guidelines discourage women in that age range from receiving screenings unless they have pre-existing risk factors.
The new findings are published in the journal Gynecologic Oncology.
"Some studies report that Pap smears are unnecessary in older age, while others show that there is a benefit in the over-65 age group," said Karin Rosenblatt, a cancer epidemiologist and a professor of kinesiology and community health at Illinois. "There's been a great debate about it."
Early research on cervical cancer screenings recommended not testing women over age 50. This suggested age cutoff for screening was increased in recent years as the disease and risk factors are better understood.
"While the incidence of cervical cancer is greater in adult women under the age of 65 years, those over 65 tend to have more fatal cases of the disease," Rosenblatt said.
When detected early – often via a Pap test – pre-malignant cervical cancer tissue can be removed or treated so it does not progress into malignant cancer.
Rosenblatt assessed whether Pap tests reduce the risk of cervical cancer, specifically in women over age 65. She and her team looked at Medicare billing data from 1991-99 and extracted information for more than 1,200 women who had been recently diagnosed with cervical cancer. The researchers compared their screening histories with those of more than 10,000 control patients who had no cancer diagnosis and were matched on age and geographic location. The team determined which of the patients had received a Pap test two to seven years prior to diagnosis. The results were adjusted for race and income in the regions where the subjects lived.
"We found that the newly diagnosed cervical cancer group was 36 percent less likely to have had a Pap smear, compared with the control group," Rosenblatt said. "The reduction in risk was 52 percent after taking into account women in the control group who may have had hysterectomies before age 65. Both of these results were statistically significant."
These results suggest that Pap tests may be beneficial for preventing malignant cervical cancer in women over 65, she said.
The option of having a Pap test should be weighed against potential psychological complications of a pre-malignant diagnosis, other co-occurring diseases or disabilities, and general life expectancy, Rosenblatt said.
"There also needs to be a more thorough cost-benefit analysis of conducting the screenings in elderly women," she said. Medicare covered a Pap test every three years at the time of the study and now covers a Pap test every 2 years, she said.
"There needs to be further study of the benefits and risks of doing Pap smears in the elderly," Rosenblatt said Future studies should comprehensively assess cervical cancer screenings in older women and more accurately inform health policy recommendations, she said.
This project was funded by the University of Illinois Campus Research Board and the Mary Jane Neer Fund of the College of Applied Health Sciences.
To reach Karin Rosenblatt, call 217- 244-8131; email [email protected]
The paper "Case-Control Study of Cervical Cancer and Gynecologic Screening: A SEER-Medicare Analysis" is available onlineabstract] and from the News Bureau.