- Online video gaming environment makes it possible to compare male and female approaches to competition, and the differences when those gender identities are known or concealed.
- Men are more likely to try harder if they know their opponent is female.
- Women don’t change their approach based on their opponent’s gender.
BALTIMORE, MD, May 4, 2023 – It is well understood that in the labor market there exists wage gaps between men and women, and in general, women had to fight to break the “glass ceiling” to get to upper management in the workplace. The causes of the gender gap could be multiple factors from discrimination to ability difference, and it is not easy to separate one from the other.
These questions were on the mind of researchers when they decided to use video game platforms to get some answers. They chose the online video gaming environment to do their research because you can be two dimensional there. When creating a character or avatar, you can use your birth sex, or you could conceal your gender and portray yourself virtually as the opposite sex.
In the end, the researchers found that men are more or less motivated by the knowledge of the gender of their competition, whereas women are not. Further, they found that this leads to poorer performance for women when competing against men unless they conceal their gender.
The study, “Does Concealing Gender Identity Help Women Win the Competition? An Empirical Investigation into Online Video Games,” is authored by Xinlei (Jack) Chen of the Shanghai Advanced Institute of Finance; Xiaohua Zeng of Peking University HSBC Business School; and Cheng Zhang of the Fudan School of Management in Shanghai.
“Given the competitive nature of video games, we wanted to explore the similarities and differences between the aggressiveness of men versus women,” says Chen. “Common stereotypes assume that men tend to be more aggressive, while women are more passive, and that in a competitive environment, men would strive more for dominance while women would not. This is the ‘dominance effect.’”
“Through our research, we found that women did perform better when they actively concealed their gender identities in online video games,” says Chen. “To understand these findings, you have to know that online video games can be a toxic environment for women. According to a Pew Research Center survey on online harassment in 2014, compared with male players, female players experience more severe harassment, such as stalking, sexual harassment and sustained bullying.”
The researchers said that this has caused women to quit playing online video games. For those who stayed, by muting their voices and concealing their identity, they were able to play under ambiguous or male names, and ultimately perform on a par with or better than their male counterparts.
“To analyze competitive performance, we had to examine the dominance effect among players of online video games,” says Chen. “When men perceive their opponent as female, they tend to exert increased effort in competition, while women seem unaffected by their opponent’s gender.”
In the end, the researchers confirmed that gender stereotype arises during interpersonal competition and does affect the outcome of the competition.
“It’s important to note that the reason for this is not that women are submissive, but rather, when men perceive their opponent to be female, they are more likely to exert increased effort than they would if they perceive their competitor to be a man,” adds Chen. “Women don’t change their approach regardless. So, by concealing their gender, they gain an advantage simply by the neutralizing effect such knowledge has on their opponent.”
The study authors conducted extensive empirical research to arrive at their findings.
Link to Study
About INFORMS and Marketing Science
Marketing Science is a premier peer-reviewed scholarly marketing journal focused on research using quantitative approaches to study all aspects of the interface between consumers and firms. It is published by INFORMS, the leading international association for the decision and data sciences. More information is available at www.informs.org or @informs.
# # #
Method of Research
Subject of Research
“Does Concealing Gender Identity Help Women Win the Competition? An Empirical Investigation into Online Video Games”