Mayo Clinic study finds no evidence that anesthesia in young children lowers intelligence
ROCHESTER, Minn. – A Mayo Clinic study finds no evidence that children given anesthesia before their third birthdays have lower IQs than those who did not have it. A more complex picture emerges among people who had anesthesia several times as small children: Although their intelligence is comparable, they score modestly lower on tests measuring fine motor skills, and their parents are more likely to report behavioral and learning problems. The findings are published in Anesthesiology.
The U.S. Food and Drug Administration warned in 2016 that prolonged or repeated sedation before age 3 may affect brain development. The warning was based largely on data from animals, which may or may not apply to children.
Mayo researchers studied 997 people born from 1994 through 2007 in Olmsted County, Minnesota, the home of Mayo Clinic's Rochester campus. They were grouped according to the anesthesia exposures they had before their third birthdays: 206 had two or more; 380 had one; and 411 had none. Ear, nose and throat procedures were the most common surgeries.
The researchers used the Rochester Epidemiology Project medical records database, brain function testing at ages 8-12 or 15-20, and parent reports to assess behavior and brain function. Beyond their anesthesia exposure, the three groups of patients were matched to be as similar as possible.
Intelligence, memory, and several other measures of brain function were similar among the groups.
However, those with multiple exposures to anesthesia had modest declines in fine motor skills, such as the ability to draw figures with a pencil, and how quickly they processed information when reading. Their parents reported more learning and behavioral problems, such as difficulty reading; behaviors consistent with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder; breaking rules; or displaying aggression, anxiety or social withdrawal.
Parents whose children had anesthesia once under age 3 reported more problems with mental skills known as executive functions – skills that help with memory, impulse control, planning and flexibility – but not with other behaviors.
"For the majority of kids undergoing surgery, the results overall are reassuring," says lead author David Warner, M.D., a pediatric anesthesiologist at Mayo Clinic Children's Center. "About 80 percent of kids who need surgery under age 3 only need one, and it's relatively brief."
Several other studies also show little evidence that a single anesthetic is associated with significant harm.
"Although we do have some concerns about the children who are receiving multiple anesthetics, it's important to note that our results don't allow us to conclude that anesthesia itself is causing problems," Dr. Warner says, adding that other factors, such as the conditions that make surgery necessary, could contribute. "However, the fact that we found some problems in some of these children means that research in this area needs to continue, including further analysis of our data."
In the meantime, in most cases the benefit of surgery outweighs any risk, Dr. Warner says. However, the potential for problems may need to be part of the decision-making process when parents and surgeons discuss surgery, he adds.
The study was funded by grant R01 HD071907 from the National Institutes of Health's Eunice Kennedy Shriver National Institute of Child Health and Human Development. The Rochester Epidemiology Project is supported by National Institute on Aging grant R01 AG034676.
The study's senior author is Randall Flick, M.D., a pediatric anesthesiologist at Mayo Clinic Children's Center.
Mayo Clinic's research into the effects of anesthesia on children and other age groups is ongoing. The Mayo Clinic team next plans to image the brains of the children in this study to see whether there are structural and functional differences in those who had anesthesia as small children compared with those who did not.
About Mayo Clinic
Mayo Clinic is a nonprofit organization committed to clinical practice, education and research, providing expert, comprehensive care to everyone who needs healing. Learn more about Mayo Clinic. Visit the Mayo Clinic News Network.