ACA expansion did not improve access to complex surgeries for low-income/minority patients
WASHINGTON — A first look at the Affordable Care Act (ACA)'s Medicaid expansion finds that despite expectations, there was no increased use of complex surgical procedures at high volume hospitals–a proxy for high quality hospitals–among ethnic/racial minorities and low-income populations.
The findings came from comparing surgery records from high-volume hospitals in three states that opted in to the ACA's Medicaid expansion with similar hospitals in two states that did not expand their Medicaid program.
The study, published in Journal of the American College of Surgeons, suggests that, in its infancy, Medicaid expansion under the ACA does not appear to reduce disparities in use of regionalized surgical care among vulnerable persons, says the study's senior investigator, Waddah B. Al-Refaie, MD, FACS, Georgetown Lombardi Comprehensive Cancer Center Surgeon-In-Chief, and Regional Chief of Surgical Oncology at MedStar Georgetown University Hospital.
"We are surprised at the results, because we already know, from other studies, that the ACA's Medicaid expansion has increased access to surgical care overall," says Al-Refaie, who also leads the MedStar-Georgetown Surgical Outcomes Research Center. "But we found that the expansion did not improve access to complex surgery that are typically centralized to high volume hospitals. Medicaid expansion under the ACA showed a flat effect," he says. "These early results may be highlighting what could be a continuing potential limitation of the program to persons with complex surgical problems."
The ACA was signed into law in March 2010, and insurance exchanges utilizing the expansion of Medicaid took effect January 1, 2014. This study examined patient treatment from 2012 (pre-ACA expansion) through the end of 2014.
The study was designed to evaluate access to four intricate surgeries at high volume hospitals, which are known to provide higher-quality care. These complex surgeries are representative of centralized complex surgical care–heart bypass surgery, pancreatic cancer surgery, total hip replacement and total knee replacement–in three expansion states (Kentucky, Maryland, New Jersey) and two non-expansion states (North Carolina, Florida).
"Current evidence suggests that vulnerable populations, such as racial and ethnic minorities and low-income individuals are less likely to benefit from ongoing trends to regionalize complex surgical care to high volume hospitals. We sought to examine how the Medicaid expansion impacted this disparity," says the study's first author, James McDermott, who conducted the research while working with the MedStar-Georgetown Surgical Outcomes Research Center.
In all, the researchers examined the records of 166,588 patients, ages 18 to 64, at 468 hospitals in the five states.
Data from State Inpatient Databases (2012-2014), American Hospital Association Annual Survey Database, and Area Resource File from Health Resources and Services Administration were used in the analyses.
The researchers found that while more patients, overall, had access to these surgeries in the expansion states than before ACA was enacted, the proportions of low-income individuals and racial/ethnic minorities receiving their complex surgery at high volume hospitals did not increase.
"White and high-income patients were more likely to receive these complex surgeries at high volume hospitals, relative to disadvantaged patients," Al-Refaie says. "Indeed, we also observed that ACA's expansion did not accelerate access to complex surgery at high volume hospitals overall.
"Typically, the biggest driver to access to care is the availability of insurance, and Medicaid insurance expansion didn't seem to increase utilization of complex surgical care at high volume hospitals for these vulnerable populations" he says.
Al-Refaie and his collaborators have suggested that a number of issues may be at play, including patient, referring physician and hospital factors. For example, patients may prefer to have their surgery at low-volume hospitals (closer to where they live) or are unable to travel to high volume hospitals; physician referral patterns may not have changed in this short timeframe; and/or some hospitals may limit the number of Medicaid patients they treat given their high number of privately insured patients.
"These results reinforce the complex and multifaceted nature of surgical disparities and suggest that factors beyond the availability of insurance coverage are contributing to disparities in utilization of regionalized surgical care at high volume hospitals," says McDermott. "We hope that these findings will spur further investigation and action to address surgical disparities."
"We know that the ACA has led to a large reduction in the rate of uninsured patients, but concerns remain as to whether increased coverage has translated into improved access to quality care hospitals" Al-Refaie says. "We need to continue to evaluate and track how the ACA is providing access to quality care hospitals for complex surgery on both a national level and within states."
Other study authors include Alexander Zeymo, MS from MedStar Health Research Institute and MedStar-Georgetown Surgical Outcomes Research Center; Andrew Crocker, MS, David Xiao, BS, from Georgetown University Medical Center and MedStar-Georgetown Surgical Outcomes Research Center; Nawar Shara, PhD, from the MedStar Health Research Institute; Kitty Chan, PhD, from Georgetown University Medical Center and MedStar Georgetown University Hospital Department of Surgery; Afshin Ehsan, MD, FACS, from Cardiovascular Research Center, Rhode Island Hospital; Jasjit S. Ahluwalia, MD, MPH, MS, from Brown University School of Public Health; and Thomas DeLeire, PhD, from Georgetown's McCourt School of Public Policy.
This study was supported by a grant from the Georgetown-Howard Universities Center for Clinical and Translational Science and The Lee Folger Foundation.
The authors report having no personal financial interests related to the study.
About Georgetown University Medical Center
Georgetown University Medical Center (GUMC) is an internationally recognized academic medical center with a three-part mission of research, teaching and patient care (through MedStar Health). GUMC's mission is carried out with a strong emphasis on public service and a dedication to the Catholic, Jesuit principle of cura personalis — or "care of the whole person." The Medical Center includes the School of Medicine and the School of Nursing & Health Studies, both nationally ranked; Georgetown Lombardi Comprehensive Cancer Center, designated as a comprehensive cancer center by the National Cancer Institute; and the Biomedical Graduate Research Organization, which accounts for the majority of externally funded research at GUMC including a Clinical and Translational Science Award from the National Institutes of Health. Connect with GUMC on Facebook (Facebook.com/GUMCUpdate), Twitter (@gumedcenter) and Instagram (@GeorgetownMedicine).